2 ms·
What Wikileaks is doing is called journalism. I wouldn't compare that to revolution, even if they are both rare these days. What Anonymous is doing is an attac
by wtallis 16y ago
What Wikileaks is doing is called journalism. I wouldn't compare that to revolution, even if they are both rare these days.
What Anonymous is doing is an attack, and its only justification so far is the attempted suppression of Wikileaks' journalism. Suppression of rights like the freedom of the press are among the best justifications for revolution. So, while the current DDOS probably isn't the start of a revolution, it is the kind of thing you would expect to see in the opening stages of a modern revolt in an industrialized society, before things get to the physical violence.
- gwright 16y agoFreedom of the press is about protecting the press from the government. It is not about forcing private companies to run their businesses according to the diktats of small group of anonymous geeks.
- sirrocco 16y agoWell wikileaks would not have the problems it does if the government would not have interfered. The government stepped in and `advised` the private companies that it wouldn't be in their best interest to continue doing business with wikileaks. Even though nothing illegal on the part of wikileaks has been proved. Taking away the freedom of press doesn't mean shoot the leader in the head and imprison all the rest. If they manage to isolate you enough , they've succeeded in taking away your freedom.
- wtallis 16y agoVisa and MasterCard cannot act in isolation from the government: They form a duopoly that requires regulation, and they are subject to quite a bit of it. As felixmar pointed out elsewhere in the thread [1], they have gotten favors from the government that have been exposed by the very leaks at issue. It doesn't take actual evidence of a specific request from the government to establish that the government influenced their decision to change their minds about doing business with Wikileaks. [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1985128 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1985128