4 ms·
Can someone smarter than me explain if this system maintains anonymity? To a layperson, statements like the one below raise a flag. If I can track it electroni
by bumby 8y ago
Can someone smarter than me explain if this system maintains anonymity?
To a layperson, statements like the one below raise a flag. If I can track it electronically, is it also possible for someone else to see who voted for whom?
"After the election is complete, the tracker codes can be used by voters to confirm that their votes were not altered or tampered with and that they were properly counted"
Again, to a layperson the above statement seems potentially at odds with the one below at first blush (because I don't understand the technology):
"With homomorphic encryption, individually encrypted votes can be combined to form an encrypted tabulation of all votes which can then be decrypted to produce an election tally that protects voter privacy."
So we have privacy but electronic traceability to the individual voter? To the uninitiated like myself, it seems like we'd have to choose between electronic traceability and anonymity.
- useerup 8y agoThe system does not ensure anonymity as to who has voted, but it does maintain secrecy as to how you voted. The idea is that you can have a public, verifiable "ledger" of voters. You can verify that you are on the list with your encrypted vote. I.e. you verify that your vote counts. You can match it to the receipt you received when voting. You do not, however possess the key to decrypt your vote or the vote of anyone else. The public list can also be used (more work) to verify that only real people voted: They could presumably be contacted. Homomorphic encryption allows the votes to be tallied while still encrypted. The result is an encrypted tally. At this point someone with the decryption key can decrypt the final tally and reveal the result. Presumably this can happen per polling place.
- bumby 8y agoThank you for taking the time to clarify. So if I understand this correctly, the system can allow an individual to verify that their vote was counted but not validate that the vote was counted correctly? From that perspective, it seems analogous to the system in use but perhaps more efficient. In other words, does this actually introduce any new features or just translate the existing features of the current system to a new medium?
- PyroLagus 8y ago> the system can allow an individual to verify that their vote was counted but not validate that the vote was counted correctly > does this actually introduce any new features Well, the current system doesn't allow you to verify that your vote was counted, so that's what it adds.
- bumby 8y agoIn the U.S. there's a ledger in the current system that provides verification.