3 ms·
How many plants are needed to counter this?
by k__ 8y ago
How many plants are needed to counter this?
- Filligree 8y agoFar too many to be plausible. You'd need to live in a terrarium. Which would certainly be nice, but it's a lot of maintenance... There are plants that do pretty well at air filtering, though not as well as a HEPA filter... but for CO2, they won't absorb more than they can use. This means you need dozens, and also that you'd need grow lights to keep them photosynthesizing as fast as possible. I've seen an office that was built like that, and it was actually a very nice experience. The owner enjoys spending as hour gardening each evening, though, which is important.
- 0xcde4c3db 8y agoDepends on the plant and other aspects of the environment, and actual numbers are hard to find. Also, you need the plants to actively be growing; their steady-state metabolism just temporarily captures carbon and then releases it again.
- graeme 8y agoDoesn't work. Try exhaling near a co2 monitor and you'll see why. Humans emit a ton of co2, relative to indoor space size. Ventilation is the only solution.
- dredmorbius 8y agoA typical person exhales just over 1kg of CO2 daily. You'd need emough plants to fix about the same amount of CO2 from the air, under indoor, shaded conditions. https://www.reference.com/science/much-co2-human-exhale-3f8cfdd9076c129 https://www.reference.com/science/much-co2-human-exhale-3f8c... The fastest rate of carbon fixation by any plants are photosynthetic algae eds, which fix u to 4.4 kg of carbon per square meter per year, or 16.3kg CO2/(m^2 * yr). http://carbon.ycombinator.com/ocean-phytoplankton/ http://carbon.ycombinator.com/ocean-phytoplankton/ That works out to about 22 m^2 or 240 ft^2 of algae. Most land plants offer at best about 1/10th this rate, in full sunlight, and far less in indirect, partial, or shaded light. A lot.
- jtms 8y agoWow - imagine the price of that space in an expensive urban center apartment like NYC
- dredmorbius 8y agoThis is a chief reason why urban agriculture is at best of limited viability.
- avar 8y agoThe source you're citing talks about 4.4 kg estimated per m^2 for algae in the open ocean, and notes that the maximum known rate is 9.16, so around 9 * (44/12) = 33 kg per m^2/yr converting C to CO^2, or around 11 square meters. In terms of CO^2 sequestration it doesn't seem implausible to fit a farm of that area in something the size of an apartment.. Of course the energy/water use would be insane, hopefully you could funnel sunlight in, or just open the window. But as a thought experiment that ignores the economics of it think more space station than apartment. Critically, you need on the order of N m^2 of sunlit area on your culture, not N m^2 of floor space. If you image search "phytoplankton culture" you can see that people grow these in bottles or thin plastic bags under artificial lighting, maximizing the surface area. You can easily fit 11 m^2 in one square meter like that under standard 250 cm ceiling height. Just have a stack every 20 cm.
- dredmorbius 8y agoNote that the article refers to both carbon and carbon dioxide fixation. CO2 weighs more than the carbon it contains, by a lot. Carbon has an atomic weight of 12, CO2 a molecular weight of 44 (12 + 216), or just shy 4x the mass of the carbon* component of CO2. The 4.4 kg I gave was carbon, the 16.3 kg CO2. Your 9.16 kg refers to CO2, fixed per square meter per year, which is less than the CO2 fixation value I'd used. That is, http://carbon.ycombinator.com http://carbon.ycombinator.com are making a more conservative estimate of about 56% the maximum observed rate. That increases rather than decreases the required area. At 9.63 kg/(m^2yr) you'd need 39.8 m^2, or 429 ft^2, of algae to offset one person's CO2 exhalation. Using GNU units: You have: (1kg/day)/(9.16 kg/(m^2*yr)) You want: m^2 * 39.873602 / 0.025079249 You have: (1kg/day)/(9.16 kg/(m^2*yr)) You want: ft^2 * 429.19589 / 0.0023299385 You have: 9.16/16.3 You want: % * 56.196319 / 0.01779476 Apologies for typos in GP post. Android soft-keyboard stinks.
- JohnJamesRambo 8y agoIt's far more than you could ever plant, I suspect. I've been in legal marijuana grows in houses where it is nearly wall to wall massive growing plants under many 1000W bulbs and the CO2 still goes up when people go in the house and start breathing and moving around. When we see science fiction movies and there is a tiny little area with plants that is supposed to be providing the multi-person crew with CO2 scrubbing and O2 generation, I think the size needed is vastly underestimated. >A human breathes about 9.5 tonnes of air in a year, but oxygen only makes up about 23 percent of that air, by mass, and we only extract a little over a third of the oxygen from each breath. That works out to a total of about 740kg of oxygen per year. Which is, very roughly, seven or eight trees' worth. from- https://www.sciencefocus.com/planet-earth/how-many-trees-does-it-take-to-produce-oxygen-for-one-person/ https://www.sciencefocus.com/planet-earth/how-many-trees-doe...
- jandrese 8y agoTo get an idea of what you need check out the Biodome and Biodome II projects. They were massive structures chock full of plants to sustain a small handful of people, and it wasn't enough.
- drivers99 8y agoBiosphere 2 you mean. Looks like they did two self-sustaining attempts there. Bio-dome is a movie based on the premise.
- jtms 8y agoSome is definitely better than none for more reasons than just air scrubbing, but I believe one of the sibling comments stating “too many to be practical” is probably (and unfortunately) correct
- jtms 8y agoAlso don’t take my word for it, but I remember reading that the viney/dangley kind are better than average for certain pollutants (and they just look really nice dangling from a ledge or window sill)
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoIf you want this to work at night, you need a CA (crassulacean acid metabolism) plant. Practically speaking, that means a bunch of succulents.