4 ms·
This is nothing new. People were constantly introducing new languages back in the 1990s too. Of your preferred languages, Rust and Typescript are fairly new. Th
by mcv 8y ago
This is nothing new. People were constantly introducing new languages back in the 1990s too. Of your preferred languages, Rust and Typescript are fairly new. They are among the success stories of this tower of Babel.
There's a constant churn of replacing and improving languages. Nobody is using Algol, Pascal or Smalltalk anymore, and even COBOL is losing ground. (Only Lisp and C seem to survive everything.) There's a constant process of learning and improving, that resulted in this latest generation.
And every language is good at something that no other language is good at. There are good reasons why some people prefer Perl, Python, Javascript or C for some tasks. Kotlin is rising in popularity because it's turning out to be the better Java that Groovy and Scala weren't.
Expecting everybody to use the same programming language for everything is like expecting a carpenter to choose a single tool to use for everything. And maybe a Swiss army knife really can do it all, but still not as well as a more dedicated tool.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y ago> Kotlin is rising in popularity because it's turning out to be the better Java that Groovy and Scala weren't. I'd say Kotlin is rising in popularity mainly because it's a Java alternative backed up by Google.
- cloverich 8y agoBacking by Google has helped, but I honestly think the two main reasons its succeeding are the same two reasons Typescript is succeeding: A "better" language that's "pragmmatic". What i mean is, they both provide the features people want (types, inference, less verbose than Java) and have quality out of the box tooling (because Jetbrains and vs-code). The moment I saw and tested either, I knew they would be a smashing success because they solved the problems people wanted solved, and "just worked".
- jordanpg 8y agoI think the rebranding of Intellij IDEA as Android Studio in 2013 was a good clue of where Google's long term plans were pointed.
- ionised 8y agoIt's not a rebranding. IntelliJ IDEA is still IntelliJ IDEA and is still owned by Jet Brains. Android Studio is just Google's own version of it.
- vorg 8y agoThe rise-and-fall adoption of Scala and Apache Groovy is because their whole rationale for existing was to be a better something. Groovy (2003) tried to be a better Beanshell (1998) by adding closures to it. Beanshell tried to be a better Java (1995) by adding dynamic typing to it. Scala (2003) tried to be a better Java by adding definable operators to it. But when something even better comes along, their rationale for existing disappears. They will try to catch up by adding features later (e.g. Groovy 2's inferred typing to compete with Scala, or its more recent macros to compete with Clojure) but by then the newer language has made a foothold, and it's too late.
- mcv 8y agoI think it's not just that Groovy and Scala were temporarily a better Java that was eventually overtaken by the next even better Java, I think they were not sufficiently better. Better at some things, but with a cost not everybody wanted to pay. Groovy doesn't perform the way Java does, Scala is fast, but is a lot more complex and occasionally hard to read. I haven't really tried Kotlin yet, but my impression is that it improves a lot on Java without any real downsides. It might not have all the improvements that Groovy and Scala offer, but it has the most important ones. And it's a clean slate that leaves some of the poorer decisions in Java behind it.
- zmmmmm 8y ago> Groovy doesn't perform the way Java does, Scala is fast, but is a lot more complex That's not quite how it seems for me. Groovy is faster than Scala in my hands (using CompileStatic) but its main challenge is complexity. It introduces a thousand quirks that have to be learned and then managed. There are some terrible legacy choices that can't be changed (eg: implicit coercion to Strings). I think this is behind the antipathy you see with people like Gradle users and Jenkins users that are incidentally exposed to it. But it applies also when you use it as a "replacement for Java". It has so many useful built in features but the price of that is all the implicit behavior of all of those need to be learned, along with actually learning Java really well, and with that along with less than perfect IDE support, and it's a steep steep curve.
- 8y ago