3 ms·
> Yet, at some point in the past decade an insatiable greed appears to have taken over the industry. I'm not saying that there aren't greedy game companies, or
by dijit 8y ago
> Yet, at some point in the past decade an insatiable greed appears to have taken over the industry.
I'm not saying that there aren't greedy game companies, or outright nefarious practices; but speaking as an industry insider I can at least understand why the entire industry has lurched this way.
There's 3 things that you must take on faith are true:
1) Microtransactions bring in money.
2) Games cost more to produce than they ever have.
3) Roughly 90% of gamers are very price sensitive.
So, if you leave out micro transactions, then your budget is slashed and you have to make a lesser game, you might think this is fine, but our competitors will (and do, because we have a very tight policy regarding microtransactions) walk all over us in terms of budget. R&D is expensive and we'll be playing catch-up for years.
You could of course, attempt to keep the budget and not introduce micro-transactions. You could argue that our games make a modest profit even without monetisation but that's certainly not always true, and the closer we move to operating on the breadline the more likely we are to make "safe" choices because risking anything could put hundreds of people out of work (and, we are guilty of this in some cases; see: Assassins Creed)
Finally you could say: well, if the cost of producing games has increased, why not increase the base price instead of chopping it up into add-ons to create special editions and in-game content that needs to be purchased. The answer is of course that if we raise the base price people will be outraged, games can be expensive (if you only play a handful of hours they are more expensive than a movie ticket, but obviously the cost-per-hour of entertainment goes down if you enjoy the game- still, there is personal risk for this) so people aren't willing to risk $100-$120 for a base game, in fact, many people wait for the game to come down in price before buying (as high as 15% of players based on the last time I looked at our market segmentation).
I mean, I understand, it's not enriching your experience to have paywalled content inside the game. But what you don't realise is that a lot of the content that even made it in to the base game, made it in on the fact that there are people who _really_ want to buy a special hat.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoIf gamers are all that price sensitive, why are they buying new games at all? Wait a few years for the price to drop in half. It seems to me that the solution to this problem should be either: • Make newly-released games cost $80+ • Stop the price from dropping so quickly Everyone seems to think the former will be catastrophic, but consider that after adjusting for inflation, game prices have fallen significantly over the past 15 years or so. The latter option is easier said than done (since the price is still largely determined by the used resale market), but Nintendo always manages it somehow, so I'm inclined to think it's possible.
- dijit 8y ago> If gamers are all that price sensitive, why are they buying new games at all? Wait a few years for the price to drop in half. fwiw I'm referring to the people who wait for the first price drop (which is roughly 20%), but there are a larger amount of people doing as you say, often waiting a full year. But the picture isn't clear on why they wait- it could easily be that they're waiting for the game to be in a good state and it's hubristic to assume intent like that. Regardless, I think your broader point isn't echoed in the sentiment from gamers at large. I say "I think" because I'm a technologist and it's not my business to know, although I sit on the same floor as our Consumer Market Knowledge team, and I pick up some things. -- but I can see clearly what I have described just by taking a cursory look at any discussion gamers have regarding the price of games and monetisation. It's a hotly discussed topic, especially on reddit where there are good examples that you can find immediately[0][1] [0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/truegaming/comments/blsmca/should_older_games_cost_less/ https://www.reddit.com/r/truegaming/comments/blsmca/should_o... [1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/bbl4cd/how_have_game_prices_changed_over_time/ekjho3n/ https://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/bbl4cd/how_have_gam...
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoIf you ask people "would you prefer to pay more or pay less", they're going to say "we'd rather pay less". We're not going to know how consumers actually respond until someone has the guts to try raising prices on a sufficiently large scale. Mind, I think the better strategy might be to just stop game prices from dropping so quickly. Again, this seems to work extremely well for Nintendo.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoI'm past the edit window, but I wanted to add: > But the picture isn't clear on why they wait- it could easily be that they're waiting for the game to be in a good state and it's hubristic to assume intent like that. This is its own problem—why are you giving consumers an extra incentive to wait until the game costs less and you will make less money? Release dates ought to be pushed back by however long is necessary to fix essential problems. This would ultimately benefit both developers and players. There are, of course, some bugs that will not be discovered until a game has been played by lots of people, so patches will always be desirable. But this is not how post-release game patches are being used today.
- dfxm12 8y ago2) Games cost more to produce than they ever have. Why is this? Where is the increased cost coming from?
- dijit 8y agoComplexity of a game increases complexity of all elements, engine development, testing, asset creation, narrative design. It takes roughly 1,000 people 7+ years to make a "new IP" game, or the same number of people 3-5 years for a decent sequel. Check the number of people credited in a game from 20 years ago and compare it to the latest AAA's, it's an order of magnitude or two different. GTA1 took 50 people to make[0] The Division took 1,083 to make[1] Yet the price of games has not increased in real terms in that time. (although, yes, the sales have increased, but not enough) [0]: https://www.giantbomb.com/grand-theft-auto/3030-13567/credits/ https://www.giantbomb.com/grand-theft-auto/3030-13567/credit... [1]: https://www.mobygames.com/game/windows/tom-clancys-the-division/credits https://www.mobygames.com/game/windows/tom-clancys-the-divis...
- dfxm12 8y agoI'm not taking on faith that that games have to be more complex today than they ever were. Yet the price of games has not increased in real terms in that time. The "price" of a game isn't a good measurement, as people are paying on top of that via microtransactions.
- jerf 8y agoIt's an arms race situation; games, or at least AAA games, have to be more complex because they have to be more complex or they won't sell like the previous complex game. I think you're picking up on the circularity there, which I fully agree with, but it doesn't stop it from existing. (Technically back in the past there is a recursion base case for all this, somewhere around when the hobbyiest-level game scene, where 1 person could create a professional-quality game, and where professional-quality games took a staff to exist at all. This would be in the late 8-bit era; by the 16-bit era, a professional game took a staff.) I'm not sure I can Google this up, but I remember when the PS4 era was just starting up, Shamus Young (http://www.shamusyoung.com/twentysidedtale/ http://www.shamusyoung.com/twentysidedtale/ ) hypothesized that the gaming industry was going to have an even harder time justifying the expense of a "true" PS4 game because of the yet-again increased expense of the asset pipeline. Assets are technically getting cheaper to generate over time, but they're not getting cheaper faster than they're getting more expensive. The PS5 may yet make this worse again, and the continuous PC market is definitely getting crazy to build for the top end. Eventually, even microtransactions aren't going to be able to cover this, and the only games that can be made are going to be so "safe" that nobody at all will like them. This is a sort of bubble that is going to burst at some point. It's arguable that it's already starting to burst; it seems like we're seeing a slowly increasing number of very high-profile, very expensive failures, and that can't continue forever. Keep an eye on Nintendo's strategy (if they continue making boatloads of money with their Switch on the complexity foothills while the rest of market is climbing so high up the complexity mountain that they are gasping for breath, eventually people with lots of initials in their titles in other companies are going to start asking why they can't do what Nintendo is doing), and the indie market. I do sometimes wonder if movies will see this as well. Right now, most movies that cost significant fractions of a billion dollars will make it back, but as that number goes up, it takes proportionally less and less to screw up things really quickly, even if you're profitable most of the time. Star Wars, for instance, is quite unexpectedly in a dangerous spot right now, profit-wise. If for instance the Marvel movies had the same problems, we could see a sea change in movie finances in a few years. But it doesn't seem to be happening yet.