5 ms·
Could be. I never bought the whole Dyson spheres idea. A truly advanced civilization wouldn't need that much energy (they would be very efficient), and certain
by raverbashing 8y ago
Could be. I never bought the whole Dyson spheres idea.
A truly advanced civilization wouldn't need that much energy (they would be very efficient), and certainly wouldn't need to "kidnap" a start for that.
A single digit percent of the Earth would need to be covered with solar panels with today's technology for our energetic consumption, I don't see why advanced civilizations would need let's say 10% of the energy of a star (let alone need to capture it)
- newsbinator 8y agoOne reason to harness a star might be replicator or transporter technology. It takes a lot of energy to make an omelette. Or a lot more energy to make a person-sized person.
- ajuc 8y ago> they would be very efficient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox > In economics, the Jevons paradox (/ˈdʒɛvənz/; sometimes Jevons effect) occurs when technological progress or government policy increases the efficiency with which a resource is used (reducing the amount necessary for any one use), but the rate of consumption of that resource rises due to increasing demand.[1] > In 1865, the English economist William Stanley Jevons observed that technological improvements that increased the efficiency of coal-use led to the increased consumption of coal in a wide range of industries. He argued that, contrary to common intuition, technological progress could not be relied upon to reduce fuel consumption.[4][5] With enough energy crazy things are possible. Terraforming planets, human-lifespan interstellar travel, swarms of space habitats allowing everybody to have their own ecosystem changing to their will. Assuming people won't do it because they don't do it now (when energy is limited) is unwise. Don't you think some rich people would like to have their own space habitat where they can change gravity, day-night cycle, and the whole ecosystem at will? It's possible with current technology, just very expansive. It creates new real estate from scratch. With enough energy everybody could have one. I don't see any point at which people decide "this is enough". Always there will be some people that want more. BTW I agree it won't be a Dyson sphere, it will probably be a Dyson swarm. Much easier to start, cheaper, and has all the benefits of a sphere.
- raverbashing 8y agoThat's a good comeback The counterproblem is: capturing energy from a star is one thing, transporting it to where it can be used a different problem (as we even see today with electric cars) Or maybe they will just mine bitcoin with it, who knows
- TeMPOraL 8y agoTransporting energy from a star is simple: concentrating the light. The most basic incremental design for a Dyson sphere would be a swarm of mirror satellites. How do we see energy transport problem with electric cars? That's only a matter of the right sockets not being available. The power grid is there.
- raverbashing 8y agoCan the grid handle 10% of cars moving from gas to electricity? 50%? 90%? Not to mention battery issues (range, charge time, safety, etc) which are getting better, no doubt about it It's not only a matter of having the right socket
- ajuc 8y agoIt's complicated, for sure, and will need changes in the infrastructure. But it has some advantages as well. Imagine 10 000 000 cars with 50 kWh battry capacity each connected to the grid and letting 10% of their capacity to be used for balancing of the network. If the grid has excess power - charge to 100%. If the grid lacks power - discharge to 90%. That's 50 GWh of balancing capacity. It basically solves the problems with unpredictability of most of the renewable power sources.
- BuckRogers 8y agoGlad to hear I'm not the only Dyson doubter. Seems too primitive to me. Any advanced civilization will have advanced knowledge on the truth to our reality, and will find ways to manipulate the laws of nature in this or other universes. We're already getting an initial grasp on that with our own developments and we're way behind. Mega structures around a star is just too basic to make sense at the stage where you could build one.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoWhy? Basic things usually work well. Chemical rockets, firearms, water wheels, wind generators, pumping water for energy storage - these are just few random examples of the extremely basic, brute-force approaches that work really well for us, and see no sign of being replaced. Complexity beyond the point of what's needed is usually sign of bad design.
- BuckRogers 8y agoYour question forces me to restate the original post again in other words, but you're correct, if understanding and manipulating the substrate of our reality is a sign of "bad design". Nothing you mentioned is basic from the viewpoint of a mere single planet species. But it's all basic enough to ensure we've remained a single planet species. Thus, if you can build a Dyson sphere, you probably won't need one because at that point your fundamental knowledge will be much greater than "bigger gun". In fact, we stopped building bigger firearms long ago due to greater understanding.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> I don't see why advanced civilizations would need let's say 10% of the energy of a star (let alone need to capture it) Because you're thinking about maintaining status quo of early XXI century Earth (and not that, solar panels won't be enough for that), not about future possibilities. Space travel, for one, is a huge energy sink if you want to do it in reasonable timeframes. A probe to Mars in a year? Sure, usual chemical rockets will do. A passenger ship in 2 weeks? Now we're talking absurd amounts of energy. If human history teaches us anything, it's that there's always use for more energy. Hell, recently we've been inventing some potentially infinite energy sinks - like the idea of running the economy on cryptocurrencies. I'm still not sure whether Bitcoin is a conspiracy to have humanity cook itself on Earth, or to force humans to start building a Dyson sphere in the next 100 years...
- raverbashing 8y agoBut you see, the problem with space travel is not the lack of energy, it's how to transport it efficiently (rocket equation) and how to use it efficiently to increase speed (specific velocity, etc) You can throw all the fuel you want at a chemical rocket and it won't take you to Mars in less than a year (more or less).
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> it's how to transport it efficiently (rocket equation) This applies only if you have to carry chemical fuel with you; you can cheat a lot if you have lots of raw energy available. Chemical rockets won't open up the outer Solar System to us, but beamed power just might. Hell, at the Dyson sphere technology level, you could just push things around the system with giant lasers. (Yes, that same technology could also be used as a powerful weapon, but it's the unfortunate feature of distances in space - anything interesting you'd like to do in timescales we're used to from daily lives requires handling energy in levels and forms that could be used as weapons of mass destruction.)
- xondono 8y agoYou do realize that covering 10% of the planet in solar panels is the start of a Dyson sphere right? Just push it up to 100% and start adding "fake" planets until a sphere is formed. :) Jokes aside, "A truly advanced civilization wouldn't need that much energy" reminds me of "640K ought to be enough for anybody", energy is in some sense like RAM, the more you have, the more you can do with it.