2 ms·
You cannot choose one thing, but then still expect to not have the drawback of that choice. Except you can, and these guys are doing exactly that. They're not
by onion2k 8y ago
You cannot choose one thing, but then still expect to not have the drawback of that choice.
Except you can, and these guys are doing exactly that. They're not doing anything criminal. They're not doing anything immoral. They're not doing anything wrong. They're living entirely within the bounds of what society has decided is acceptable. They're living exactly how society allows them to live.
You may believe that welfare is a bad thing, and that society would be better if we just let people who don't have jobs starve to death or something, but society has decided as a collective group that we don't want that. Consequently we allow people to choose not to work. We pay their bills. That's how society works - the majority decides what is or isn't acceptable and enables that behaviour.
My belief if that society is richer by a long way if people can live life on their own terms. I would much rather people lived life on welfare playing video games all day than force those people to work jobs they hate. Sometimes you're just not in the right headspace to work. I took a couple of years off once and lived on my own money because I just didn't want a job any more. If I need welfare to do that again in the future then I will be very glad of it, and I will happily use it without any guilt that I'm not contributing.
And if the majority of people would not work..
Then the system would break down. But please note that hasn't happened. Most people choose to work, because living on welfare kind of sucks. Most people want more than that life affords them. The "what if!" argument doesn't work here because if it was going to happen it would already have happened, and it hasn't.
- adwn 8y ago> You may believe that welfare is a bad thing, and that society would be better if we just let people who don't have jobs starve to death or something, but society has decided as a collective group that we don't want that. You're conflating two groups here: A) people who are unable to work or can't find work, and B) people who would be able to work, but choose not to work. Most modern societies have decided to provide welfare to group A, but not group B. > The "what if!" argument doesn't work here because if it was going to happen it would already have happened, and it hasn't. You're wrong: No such experiment has been tried (i.e., a UBI guaranteed over many years, to a diverse set of people, sufficiently high to live on), so you can't claim "it would already have happened".
- onion2k 8y agoMost modern societies have decided to provide welfare to group A, but not group B. Most societies haven't put measures in place to stop people in group B living on welfare. That is accepting them. No such experiment has been tried The "what if" in question was "what if everyone decided to live on welfare", not "what if we had UBI". Everyone could just decide to live on welfare right now, but they haven't.
- koonsolo 8y ago> Most societies haven't put measures in place to stop people in group B living on welfare. That is accepting them. Yes they do. They have laws and services in place to track down these people. In practice it's now always easy to make the distinction between someone who can't find a job, and someone who doesn't want a job. Your "it ain't a crime if you don't get caught" theory is not really accepted by society, government or law.
- adwn 8y ago> Most societies haven't put measures in place to stop people in group B living on welfare. Uuh, yeah, they have – that's what "means testing" is all about, and that's also what UBI proponents demand: welfare without means testing. > Everyone could just decide to live on welfare right now, but they haven't. No, they couldn't – again, because auf means testing. Sure, there are some people that successfully trick, outsmart, or otherwise circumvent the means test, but it's not as simple as "just deciding to live on welfare right now", as you put it.
- koonsolo 8y ago> Except you can, and these guys are doing exactly that. They're not doing anything criminal. In Belgium that would be considered criminal (fraud), since you can only receive an unemployment fee when you cannot find a job. You have to prove that you are looking for jobs. If you put yourself out of the job market, that means you are not entitled to receive an unemployment fee.
- ido 8y agoI would guess it's just a poor choice of words and the guys he talks about are probably on welfare rather than unemployment. At least in Germany & Austria you can be on welfare your whole life.