3 ms·
> What does "people being in control of their own stuff" even mean? It means that Facebook et al don't have it to begin with. > How do you force people to use
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> What does "people being in control of their own stuff" even mean?
It means that Facebook et al don't have it to begin with.
> How do you force people to use software that doesn't do this?
Why do you have to force people to do anything? That conclusion requires some major cognitive dissonance.
There are two options here. One is that people are rational in not caring, and in that case there is no problem and nothing needs to be changed, so what are you complaining about? But let's suppose that's not it.
Then it's that privacy is important and people should care about it but they don't understand, in which case you don't have to force them to do anything, all you need is for them to learn what is happening and why they should care about it. It requires information, not regulations.
You can't regulate a fox in a henhouse, you can only teach the farmers why fences are important before they learn it for themselves.
> It's also unclear whether in practice people being in control over their devices better protects the users - back when that was the case, malware was a bigger problem than it is now.
We need to give all our data to Facebook because malware? How does that prevent malware at all? What is Facebook's server going to do that your phone couldn't do for itself?
"But malware" it seems is the new "but terrorism" or "think of the children" as a generic excuse for every authoritarian policy in the book.
- orcthwy012 8y agoSo what do you mean by "people being in control of their own stuff" - why even bother talking about something that will never happen? I mean other than maybe Richard Stallman, who even does anything remotely close to this? Wrt: malware, what's definitely helped here is that people spend more time on centralized platforms that are able to tackle problems at the source, as opposed to visiting random unsafe websites and downloading random software. Likewise, telemetry in OS almost certainly helps greatly in fighting malware. Centralization in terms of both data and usage helps greatly.