5 ms·
You're forgetting the structural flaws in the existing welfare system. The way things are right now, if you qualify for benefits, you can get thousands of doll
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
You're forgetting the structural flaws in the existing welfare system.
The way things are right now, if you qualify for benefits, you can get thousands of dollars a year in free stuff. If you take any full time job, you immediately lose most of the benefits.
If you give people the choice between free stuff where they can do whatever they want all day vs. working 40 hours to get substantially the same thing, no kidding there aren't a lot of takers for the option to work full time in exchange for what amounts to a gain of only around $5000/year.
The point of a UBI being universal is that you don't get that perverse incentive. There is no means testing, you don't lose the benefit from taking the job, so a job that pays $20,000/year after taxes gives you $20,000 in additional money, not $5000 because taking the job costs you $15,000 in benefits.
- ido 8y agoI disagree with the parent you replied to but still think there are other solutions that may work better than UBI. My idea (disclaimer: not an economist, sociologist, etc just some guy on the internet): Free (i.e. public funded) education at all levels, healthcare, mass transit & access to public housing at restricted cost (we already have that in many western countries but means-test who can get into public housing & do not build nearly enough of it). stuff like unemployment payments can stay but all other benefits are no longer required as they are provided to everyone. And make sure that each 1$ you earn reduces your benefits by less than 1$ (maybe 50 cents) so that you're never disincentivized from taking work. The chronically unemployed in socialist Western Europe will remain at a situation more or less the same as they are in now but will have lower bureaucratic overhead & be less disincentivized from searching even part time work. It's the working poor to lower/middle class that just about keep their head above the water that will be in a much better position. And for the well off it will be more or less the same as now only they'll pay some more taxes (but also benefit from the services above, like free education).
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Free (i.e. public funded) education at all levels, healthcare, mass transit & access to public housing at restricted cost (we already have that in many western countries but means-test who can get into public housing & do not build nearly enough of it). There are two possibilities when you provide stuff instead of money. One is that people actually need the exact specific stuff you're providing. They want to live in government housing and eat government cheese; it's what they would choose if you just gave them the money. But then there is zero difference between that and giving them the money. You're not keeping them from using the money to buy drugs or whatever because giving them $500 worth of housing means they have $500 of their other money they didn't have to use for housing that they can go use to buy drugs. The other option is that they wouldn't buy the same stuff, in which case the restriction is waste. You give them government housing 30 miles from where they work even though the non-government housing across the street from their job is higher quality and has a lower underlying cost. You deprive them of the option of living in a smaller space in order to use the money for something more productive -- or the other way around, renting a place slightly larger than the allocated government housing unit so it can be used as a studio or home office. You're basically assuming that the government can do better than the market. That may actually be true for things like mass transit with huge up-front costs and trivially small incremental costs per rider, but there is no reason to expect it to be for things like housing and education. (In practice, existing government involvement in both of those markets has done nothing but inflate costs dramatically.) > And make sure that each 1$ you earn reduces your benefits by less than 1$ (maybe 50 cents) so that you're never disincentivized from taking work. 50% is still crazy high. There is no reason the poor should be paying higher marginal rates than the rich. > It's the working poor to lower/middle class that just about keep their head above the water that will be in a much better position. This really has more to do with how redistributive a policy is than what (as opposed to who) the resources are allocated to. The ways to help lower/middle class people are to give them more money (independent of which form, but very expensive and hard to pass) or to use the specified amount of money more efficiently so that the same dollar goes further, which is what you get from a UBI instead ordering people to buy specific stuff.
- ido 8y ago> (In practice, existing government involvement in both of those markets has done nothing but inflate costs dramatically.) here in Germany education is (mostly) government funded and for the majority of students studying in public universities is free or very cheap. The American model of just providing backing for student loans is the broken one. When I did my M.Sc. in Austria I paid €350 per semester for another example of publicly funded higher education not making education expensive.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The American model of just providing backing for student loans is the broken one. I would agree with that assessment. Convincing the government to subsidize loan interest for education and housing is one of the nastiest tricks the banks pulled on the American people. But the point is that those markets would be more efficient if the government had left them alone. > When I did my M.Sc. in Austria I paid €350 per semester for another example of publicly funded higher education not making education expensive. That's the out of pocket cost, then how much did it cost in tax dollars on top of that? I assume still less than in the US, because the banks did such a number on the US, but I doubt any better than schools in ordinary markets without that level of crazy.
- ido 8y agoBut the point is not just the total cost (tax payers & own money) but that shifting this cost to the public means everyone will be able to afford it (including poor kids who currently aren't & just remain "uneducated" instead). The argument is that society as a whole benefits from a better educated/more healthy/etc population so even tho it will cost you some tax money in the greater scheme of things as a whole we will benefit. If this means e.g. a 20% premium on the cost of education or healthcare I'd be willing to accept that. If it's 10x the cost that's obviously a different story. But we don't actually know the scale of the effect.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- strken 8y ago> And make sure that each 1$ you earn reduces your benefits by less than 1$ (maybe 50 cents) so that you're never disincentivized from taking work. This is more or less how Australian dole works, and when you hit the income band where your payments start decreasing you lose anywhere up to 70 or 80% of marginal increases in income to the government, if you include tax. At that point a rational person could and does question whether working an extra 6 hour shift for $4/hr take home pay is worth it.
- solatic 8y agoThe question is whether even $20,000 is sufficient motivation for someone living that kind of lifestyle to return to work. There's an old parable about a fisherman taking on debt to start a business to grow a fishing fleet so that he can eventually sell the business and retire to spend his days fishing. The paradox at the center of UBI goes like this: by definition, UBI would pay out an equal, base minimum to everybody; it cannot pay out different amounts to different people. That base minimum will be a comfortable minimum to some (who will spend their days playing video games or similar) and an uncomfortable minimum to others (who will choose to work to earn beyond the UBI). Where do you draw the line? Should UBI be a comfortable minimum for 50% of the population? 20%? Less? How many people do you "write off" from participating in the economy? If the number is too low, and UBI doesn't really provide enough people with enough money to live a basic lifestyle, have you really made a difference at all with UBI?
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The question is whether even $20,000 is sufficient motivation for someone living that kind of lifestyle to return to work. Suppose that it's not, at scale. Then the work still needs to be done, so wage rise until it is enough for enough people. That seems like more of a benefit than a problem. > There's an old parable about a fisherman taking on debt to start a business to grow a fishing fleet so that he can eventually sell the business and retire to spend his days fishing. That's kind of the point. You want to go fishing but you don't have a boat. Boats are expensive and you don't have enough money. So you borrow money to buy five fishing boats so you can make enough back to own one of them outright. Then you do and you can go fishing. If you give the fisherman the first boat to begin with, he doesn't go out and build a fleet, but he's still a fisherman. But there is nothing wrong with being a fisherman. This is the basic trade off in having social programs at all instead of pure ruthless capitalism. Presumably the real problem is with the people who choose to do things that are totally useless/harmful rather than the people who choose to be fishermen. But is that really a novel problem? Is it "optimal" for people to go home after work and play video games instead of working more? What about developing video games? What about growing tobacco, or mining coal, or building bombs? There are a lot more counter-productive things than sitting in a room and effectively doing nothing. > How many people do you "write off" from participating in the economy? If the number is too low, and UBI doesn't really provide enough people with enough money to live a basic lifestyle, have you really made a difference at all with UBI? Your assumption seems to be that the purpose of a UBI is to provide people with a basic lifestyle with zero supplemental income. But it doesn't need to do that at all. There is no inherent requirement that it provide any given level of support. It would be a great improvement if all it did was provide exactly the same level of support as existing welfare, but provided it in cash instead of with strings attached, and had no phase out so that low and middle income working people received a little more at the expense of the rich. It could provide enough to live a basic lifestyle for some percentage of people, but the number depends on how many people you actually need to work. If more jobs get replaced by robots, the number of people we need to provide all the necessities of life goes down, and why shouldn't we allow more people to only work if they want to? The amount can start off modest and increase to the extent that things actually go that way.