3 ms·
Sorry, but environmental impact is really important to consider. Party of why I've been a bit bullish on Tesla and the Prius is the destruction for rare Earth
by tracker1 8y ago
Sorry, but environmental impact is really important to consider. Party of why I've been a bit bullish on Tesla and the Prius is the destruction for rare Earth metals and shipping everything all over the world is not insignificant.
The problem is, as soon as you bring a bigger picture or talk about the economic offset to Green anything, you're labeled anti science.
Politically I'm libertarian and conservative leaning centrist, I refer to myself as a pragmatic libertarian.
I absolutely am in favor of some policy to protect the environment. Not to the point that some would extend things though. All the same, it's very concerning to me the amount of ewaste produced, badly disposed of and restrictions on end user maintenance and right and ability to repair.
I'm also surprised how far the left has gone away from classic liberal values.
- SECProto 8y agoMassive carbon taxes would create a nice environmentally accurate way to account for externalities. If you need some taxes on lithium, cobalt, etc to account for same, I assure you $20/gallon gasoline would still ensure the electric car to come out on top. The difference is relatively minor externalities during manufacture of electric vehicles, and massive (difficult to conceive) externalities of use of fossil fuelled cars
- tracker1 8y agoIs building all the parts for a Tesla, including mining and shipping less environmental impact over 10 years than a gas car getting 35mpg at 10k miles per year considering the additional impact of battery replacements and proper disposal? How about against natural gas, even considering fracking vs lithium mining? Also, I never suggested using taxes for either.
- SECProto 8y agoThat's a difficult thing to calculate - taxes on the manufacture of different inputs makes that transparent to calculate. Shipping is almost inconsequential - I bought my $16000 Yaris and it was shipped from Japan to eastern Canada. If the carbon cost of the fuel to ship is included, manufacturers will self-select where to manufacture (or will charge appropriately to deliver) I fundamentally feel that disposal of lithium ion battery packs from cars should be viewed as a cheap source material, not a cost. Side note, if you drive 16000km/year... Maybe you don't need a Tesla? That's only 40-50km a day. Get something much cheaper with 100km range, and rent a car the half dozen times you need more. Edit: responding to your edits: carbon is carbon, does it matter if it comes from natural gas or a different source?
- tracker1 8y agoCarbon isn't the only factor damaging the environment.
- King-Aaron 8y agoI've seen the electric car lifecycle vs ICE car lifecycle trope get rolled out quite often, but neither parties (those for or against) can ever provide sufficient modelling on either side of the argument. I'd be interested to see a study done into it however, if ones been done. Mostly it seems to be based on perceptions rather than facts. It can be noted however that the components in an electric vehicle can be more readily recycled than parts in a traditional ICE vehicle.
- mehrdadn 8y ago> I've seen the electric car lifecycle vs ICE car lifecycle trope get rolled out quite often, but neither parties (those for or against) can ever provide sufficient modelling on either side of the argument. I'd be interested to see a study done into it however, if ones been done. Mostly it seems to be based on perceptions rather than facts. This is just a reason to continue research, not a reason to avoid what the vast majority agree is likely to be the better approach.
- King-Aaron 8y agoI completely agree.
- tracker1 8y agoI think in the end there's room for some diversity in approach. I just tend to resist the tropes that state X is absolutely better when it absolutely isn't backed by sufficient evidence. A lot of things that feel good aren't.
- tracker1 8y agoRegarding recycling... Batteries an electric motor are more recyclable than meeting down some mostly but metal slabs? The main difference is the engine and batteries. An ice engine is probably much easier to recycle than li batteries.
- dnautics 8y agoI think the basic premise that propertization schemes (e.g. nox or sox permit markets which are empirically successful or catch permit based fishery management) would keep environmental destruction in check is correct... but we also have an economy where governments stimulate consumption to get good metrics.
- Tade0 8y agodestruction for rare Earth metals and shipping everything all over the world is not insignificant. Actually, comparing to the lifetime emmisions of a regular vehicle it is. For example a container ship full of hybrids from Japan arriving in Europe or the US is responsible for emissions in the order of what a full tank of gas per each of those transported vehicles would create. Meanwhile your typical hybrid over its lifetime saves more than its weight in gasoline - thrice that in case of taxis. I blame Top Gear for over-dramatizing how much shipping and production matter. Most of the environmental impact always did and will come from the usage of a vehicle.