4 ms·
Prop 13 was heavily pushed by businesses under the guise of “saving your grand parents from excessive taxes”. What it actually is, is a tax cut for businesses
by olliej 8y ago
Prop 13 was heavily pushed by businesses under the guise of “saving your grand parents from excessive taxes”.
What it actually is, is a tax cut for businesses (they don’t generally sell property, and so don’t ever pay tax on the actual property value), and land owners who rent/lease out property (because they can increase revenue in line with market value, while only paying taxes on increasingly far from market value properties). Given property taxes are generally used to fund a lot of public services (police, fire, schools, roads, etc) and a lot of those have costs determined by market value of property (eg cost of rent/mortgage is a significant determining factor for income), you end up necessarily pushing those costs on to individual tax payers. Businesses can easily incorporate out of state and so choose yet another cheap tax rate, pushing all of the costs into individuals.
Prop 13 must be revoked.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Prop 13 must be revoked It might be easier, politically, to add carve-outs. Not your primary residence? Assessed value rises with CPI. Renting it out? Assessed value increases capped to e.g. 5% per year. Businesses with more than X in revenues or Y in employees? No price protection. Home value more than Z? No price protection. Et cetera.
- deepakhj 8y agoAlso we could defer taxes for elderly and charge the deferred taxes when they pass away. That way they don't lose their home.
- shereadsthenews 8y agoThat's what we always did before Prop 13. Nobody was being turfed out of their homes. The counties were just putting liens on properties.
- pascalxus 8y agoor simply ask them to take out a second mortgage. with everything their house is worth, i'm sure their net worth is high enough to afford it.
- twblalock 8y ago> Not your primary residence? Assessed value rises with CPI. Renting it out? Assessed value increases capped to e.g. 5% per year. Businesses with more than X in revenues or Y in employees? No price protection. Home value more than Z? No price protection. Et cetera. You'd need a CPA to figure out your annual property tax, and the exemptions would make tax evasion much easier.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> You'd need a CPA to figure out your annual property tax, and the exemptions would make tax evasion much easier If you own a a second residence, are a landlord, are a large business or own an ultra-high value home, you probably need a CPA (or would be fine with this level of mechanical complexity). Yes, complexity makes evasion easier. But that still beats the status quo where everyone is underpaying. Given how concentrated homeownership is in California, at least by value, it wouldn't be difficult to prioritise prosecution to yield a good bang for buck.