4 ms·
> If you cut corners on the power supply or thermal management, LEDs will burn out much quicker than older lighting technologies Really? As an anecdatum, I rep
by taneq 8y ago
> If you cut corners on the power supply or thermal management, LEDs will burn out much quicker than older lighting technologies
Really? As an anecdatum, I replaced most of the lights in our house with cheap LED globes a few years ago and so far not a single one has failed. Maybe I'm just lucky. CCFL lamps, however, have been terrible while using 3x the power.
- RRWagner 8y agoMy anecdatum is that I bought CREE LED replacements about five years ago and I've had to replace more than a few already as they have started failing.
- foobarian 8y agoI had a few batches that failed at a high rate. The most interesting one was a fixture with 3 candle-format LED bulbs that all failed at the same time! Clearly some power surge/power supply related event.
- xbmcuser 8y agoLed tech has improved in the last 5 years. So experience with led of 5 years ago might no be the same as led of today or even 3 years ago. My boss converted his house to led 5-6 years ago I did around 2 years ago. We had a huge discussion about it when our office was being renovated recently. He had to replace about half in the first couple of years of install I have had to replace none so far.
- inferiorhuman 8y agoI put a variety of LED bulbs (Ikea dumb + smart, Philips Hue, some no-name brand of T8 drop in replacements) about four years ago and only one (an early Philips Hue) has failed — even that's a soft failure. Meanwhile I've lost one T12 and one T8 in that period (despite only having four FL bulbs in service). Plenty of the LED traffic signals around here have dead LEDs though. Those lasted a surprisingly short amount of time. The thing is, as bad as the waste is — I'd much rather chuck out LED bulbs than CFL/FL.
- taneq 8y agoHmm, mine were OMRON I think. Cost about AUD $5 each.
- apple4ever 8y agoAbout 3 years ago I bought a ton (~20) of Cree LED lights. Almost all of them have failed at this point. The GE ones and the later Cree replacements have faired much better however.
- nashashmi 8y agoI paid 50 dollars per bulb for two bulbs about 8 years ago. They are still running. And then I paid 8 dollars for a bulb 6 months ago and it failed. Or did it. I noticed that if you keep it on long enough after it turns off it will come back on. I think the fuse or something gets heated and it stops until it cools.
- war1025 8y agoWe had a loose connection of some sort in the electrical box to our house. Made for dirty power that fried probably 6 LED bulbs, and also the rectifier on our microwave.
- yason 8y agoLuckily, it was your LEDs that went. That's a very small problem to have if your house had a loose connection.
- Spooky23 8y agoI’ve seen both. My theory is that they test them in lamps upright. I’ve noticed much higher failure rates with fixture based and inverted bulbs.
- dreamcompiler 8y agoOrientation can have a big impact on thermal profile and should be a consideration of thermal engineering.
- CydeWeys 8y agoFortunately, the ~10W LED bulbs commonly used in households don't put out enough heat to be a huge problem. The streetlights are putting out a lot more power (and thus heat), and thus need much better thermal management, which it appears they don't actually have.
- bdamm 8y agoPlenty do. Just not the ones in Detroit. Presumably the problems extends to all users of the E-Cobra system. But I don't think this is a general industry problem in LED streetlighting. It surely is a problem in consumer LED fixtures.
- benj111 8y agoJudging by the contents of the bulb bin at the recycling centre, its recessed light fitting that do the damage to leds, which makes sense I suppose. I've had 2 led failures since I went fully led 8 years ago, one went soon after purchase and looks like a manufacturing defect, so that leaves one that could potentially be heat. Most of them are no names, most recent are Phillips though.
- Gibbon1 8y ago> its recessed light fitting that do the damage to leds Heat is really ungood for LED's and the drive circuits[1]. With a recessed fixture there is no place for the heat to escape. [1] I've noticed excepting electrolytic caps electronics that doesn't get warm, basically lasts forever.