2 ms·
> Accurate time estimates need to be associated with specific individuals. Someone who is familiar with the relevant code is simply faster than someone who is n
by hnlmorg 8y ago
> Accurate time estimates need to be associated with specific individuals. Someone who is familiar with the relevant code is simply faster than someone who is not.
This is one of the many reasons why I disagree with giving projects to specific individuals. Not only do you end up silos of knowledge (which is a risk if that engineer should leave / get fired / die in a bus accident) but you also make it harder for yourself to make estimates for the reasons you've described. Sure there will always be a variance from person to person but you stand a greater chance of that averaging out if you discourage engineers "owning" code bases.
> Further, interruptions don’t just cost time, they also reduce productivity around them.
You missed my point regarding meetings. I'm saying if you estimate a project based on FTEs (different methodologies and frameworks will have different terms but they usually amount to the same concept) then time spent in meetings becomes a modifier you can easily adjust for, rather than a hidden time sink that you can't account for.
> Now, you can try and do effort estimates using hypothetical people. But, at that point you have already given up the possibility of an accurate answer.
You don't need to make the estimate on hypothetical people. You just need a system of tracking and reporting the hours people spend in a working day. For example in JIRA you can log time against a ticket and you can create generic tickets for meetings. Therefore after a week / sprint / arbitrary point in time you can view where your engineers have spent their time and if it's below the allocated time for that project you can then either:
- enforce a new policy (eg are all the engineers going to every meeting when just one or two representatives would suffice? Are some meetings just duplicates or redundant? etc),
- inform project managers that there will be a deadline slippage due to resource constraints
- hire more resource to compensate
- or all of the above
I agree estimates are never going to be 100% accurate but that doesn't mean there aren't better ways to estimate than just applying guesswork based on your current teams circumstance.
- Retric 8y agoI agree estimates are never going to be 100% accurate but that doesn't mean there aren't better ways to estimate than just applying guesswork based on your current teams circumstance. The entire dev team walks out, and yes this actually happens surprisingly often and could happen to you’re team tomorrow. Now, what happens to all your estimates? Well clearly anything short term is now worthless. You can build a new team and use older effort estimates as a guide, but with different skill sets and a massive learning curve they in no way translate into FTE hours. Effort estimates can survive those kind of transitions. But, time outside of a functional team is not meaningful.
- hnlmorg 8y ago> The entire dev team walks out, and yes this actually happens surprisingly often and could happen to you’re team tomorrow. Now, what happens to all your estimates? The estimate is still the same because, at risk of repeating myself, you estimate on FTE and not wild guesses at a project end date. Thus you then go back to your project managers following the steps I outlined in my previous post. Granted in the most extreme of situations you would need to factor in some upskilling time - maybe even get the team to re-groom the tickets (if you're following the agile methodology) but your method of making wild guesses wouldn't put you in any better a position should your edge case example happen. So you're not exactly winning any arguments by raising this point. When running projects, estimations are based on the required work to do, not the team itself. Teams can fluctuate (as you keep pointing out) where as the work required should be closer to a constant. Thus any feature creeping that happens - as often does happen in software projects - gets captured and costed before so budget holders aren't surprised by hidden escalations in costs. Delivery date is then derived from totalling up the required work. If you have a hard end date for delivery then it's up to management (eg yourself as a hiring manager, the companies board and the projects PM), to decide if you reduce the complexity of the project, do a staged release, hire more staff or even argue if the requested delivery date can be extended. The above is how software projects should be run when they're managed properly. Other places might do things a little more adhoc but in my professional experience that almost always ends up being a worse way of managing a project, budgets and teams.
- Retric 8y agoHiring more staff always slows progress in the short term. It has a habit of making late projects later. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks%27s_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks%27s_law I understand you’re desire for an FTE to be a meaningful measure, but imperially that’s not true. As I said several times effort estimates can be used, but after deciding to add staff progress slows down for a while. So, using effort estimates you would reduce progress over the next 3 months before expecting a longer term increase in rate of accomplishment.
- 8y ago