3 ms·
> Gmail's fix was to cache the emails' images on their own server, so it's only hit once. That doesn't solve the problem; email trackers could just use a uniqu
by JoshTriplett 8y ago
> Gmail's fix was to cache the emails' images on their own server, so it's only hit once.
That doesn't solve the problem; email trackers could just use a unique URL per email.
- justinmchase 8y agoAnd they do that exactly. The fix is to disable images by default but every user has to manually do this.
- nerdponx 8y agoOr use an email client that disables images by default.
- dexterdog 8y agoI thought images were off by default
- Moru 8y agoNot in the Web client I'm afraid
- afiori 8y agoBut it does not matter, if google download all the images when for all your emails then showing them to you is just a fetch from their own servers. Similarly to the ad-blocking extension that clicked all ads on the page (in isolation) so that tracking would be useless.
- grifball 8y agoand then send many emails? is that an availability attack?
- ghayes 8y agoCouldn't google just hit the URL randomly themselves to throw off tracking, even if the email was never opened?
- babypuncher 8y agoThat would require Google to care about user privacy.
- callalex 8y agoCartels still like to take out their competition.
- eli 8y agoThis would actually be detrimental to users. Responsible email publishers use lack of opens as a signal to reduce volume of emails sent and, eventually, unsubscribing you automatically. Gmail causing a lot of bogus engagement would make it look like people can’t get enough of your content
- zbentley 8y agoI don't know why this is being downvoted. I work for an ESP, and this is an accurate statement. Whatever you think about marketing emails, you probably don't want gmail to simulate click traffic. Trust me.
- vxNsr 8y ago> Responsible email publishers I'd love to meet these people. I've yet to have a good email publisher experience. whether it's a fortune 500 co or the newest startup they all terribly abuse email. > unsubscribing you automatically What is this magic? I've never once been automatically unsubscribed from anything.
- judge2020 8y agoI believe mailchimp has something that automatically unsubscribes users if they haven't opened your emails for x time, but the amount of publishers that use this is probably pretty low.
- hamandcheese 8y ago> I've never once been automatically unsubscribed from anything. To be fair, this is the kind of thing where, if it had happened, it’s possible you wouldn’t have ever noticed.
- Thaxll 8y agoIt does solve the problem because Google download the image no mater what so you can't know if someone opened the image or not.
- forgotmypw3 8y agoGoogle's service delays downloading the image until the moment it is requested by the client.
- grifball 8y ago... and then do what?