4 ms·
> There's no incentive to win 90% of the vote. There is also no path to get 90% of the vote across the entire US population. As soon as a politician takes a st
by Spivak 8y ago
> There's no incentive to win 90% of the vote.
There is also no path to get 90% of the vote across the entire US population. As soon as a politician takes a stance on a polarizing issue, and they're not allowed to not take a stance, they lose half the vote.
One could try and blend the tribes by choosing stances evenly-ish across them but it's practically impossible because you need tribal backing to have a successful run and that backing comes with a promise of loyalty. It probably wouldn't really work anyway -- people don't really tally positive stances, they vote for whoever has the fewest bad checks so everyone would end up hating you.
Our electorate is, sans cheating, a reflection of ourselves. As long as we are divided about issues that are important to us so too will Capitol Hill.
If there were a best solution there would be nothing to argue about unfortunately.
- AstralStorm 8y agoSo according to your idea, a politician who would not flag many bad boxes while getting a few common issues nailed down would be a winner? Unfortunately, this is not what we see. We get politics playing to respective power bases and not the actual electorate as an aggregate, and politicians that are a reflection of these power bases and not electorate.
- Spivak 8y ago> not flag many bad boxes while getting a few common issues nailed down would be a winner Easier said than done when you have to take a stance on a bunch of polarizing issues, and any choice you make will be a bad check for half the population. Not messing up the issues people generally agree on is the easy part.
- everdev 8y agoSorry, 90% was a bit of an exaggeration, but 60-70% might not be unrealistic if someone came out and said they respect both sides of a controversial issue and want to find common ground.