2 ms·
There are a lot of structural reasons why this happens. In the US one of the major ones is that the US government was not constitutionally intended to be large
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
There are a lot of structural reasons why this happens.
In the US one of the major ones is that the US government was not constitutionally intended to be large.
As a result, for example, there is one elected position in the entire executive branch. We don't elect the Secretaries of Health and Human Services, Housing and Urban Development, Transportation, Energy, Education, Veterans Affairs, Homeland Security, etc. We don't elect the head of the FCC or the director of the FBI. They're all appointed by the President.
Then we use FPTP voting instead of something sane like approval voting, which gives us two parties, which hypercharges the "team sport" dynamics that make everything worse. So not only do you only get to elect one member of the executive branch, you de facto only have a choice between two people.
And it's really the same for Congress. There is more than one Congressman but you only get to vote for one and it's still FPTP. We don't have separate committees with separate members who are voted on independently.
But fixing this would presumably require amending the constitution.
Of course, another way to fix it would be to stop trying to do everything at the federal level to begin with. Because a lot of states and cities do make many of the equivalent offices elected positions.