3 ms·
Variety of thoughts on this - We're governed by incompetents because we elect incompetents. We elect them because voting has become more of an emotional/cultur
by rndmize 7y ago
Variety of thoughts on this -
We're governed by incompetents because we elect incompetents. We elect them because voting has become more of an emotional/cultural decision than a logical one. And this is largely because the big problems everyone could agree on have been solved - we're not under threat of attack from other countries; social security and medicare and other social welfare programs have taken care of much of the visible suffering in society; regulation has taken care of others.
As a result we're left with issues that are harder to pin down and harder to solve (why are medical costs so high? how do we legislate on privacy?) and issues that have been turned into culture war elements by cranking up the emotional component and discarding the evidence and effects (abortion, Brexit, the wall, etc.)
Also, I'm tempted to say that blaming this on boomers is a causation/correlation error - I'd look at the changes in media, starting with the TV debate between Nixon and Kennedy. It feels like since then, policy has mattered less and less, and appeal has mattered more. TV news feels like it has become ever more emotional over time - Fox appeals through fear, MSNBC through anger/frustration, CNN through surprise (breaking news alert!)
- bilbo0s 7y ago>We're governed by incompetents because we elect incompetents... Money quote. You're also right about this not really being the Boomers' fault.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago"The fault lies not in our politicians but in ourselves."
- SmirkingRevenge 7y agoIts unclear to me if we have more or less competent people in power than in the past... but maybe its become more complex to govern, as society scales up and becomes more complex itself?
- pintxo 7y agoMy take on this is that the relation between politics and the public has changed massively over the last 100 years and this seems to shape the sort of politicians we get. Today - as a politician - you need to be a media person, else you will easily look incompetent. This drives out mostly everyone who is not willing or able to handle the pressure of maintaining a public persona.