3 ms·
Interesting. Baby boomers don't have the background life experience to see that politics actually matters, so they treat it like a game? Plausible, very plaus
by AnimalMuppet 8y ago
Interesting. Baby boomers don't have the background life experience to see that politics actually matters, so they treat it like a game? Plausible, very plausible. And politics recently (increasingly over the last 20 years, say) has come to resemble sports - people support their team, for no rational reason, but just because they are fans of that team.
But that leaves us with politicians (and therefore government as a whole) that is focused on winning, not on governing. And so they fight their trench warfare against each other while the country burns. (Not literally... yet.)
- AstralStorm 8y agoAdditionally the whole process of becoming a prominent politician selects not for the best administrators nor planners nor visionaries. It selects for people who are best connected, most charismatic and most ruthless.
- dr_dshiv 8y agoPolitics is entertainment -- sports teams. I don't think we can change that. Read the comments section in the WSJ -- always so depressing. I truly believe that philosophy is the answer. Unfortunately, modern philosophy has been stripped of rhetoric. And political philosophy is just sophistry.
- mattrp 8y agoI think you’re close in your perspective but I don’t think I would describe it as generational nor using the game analogy. Here’s my suggestion - coming from someone who spent a few years in the grassroots of a party’s infrastructure. First, the expectations of those who back a given party are way beyond reality. However the party elite sell this vision as achievable if only the party has the White House, both houses of Congress and the judiciary. Not only is this unreasonable, it completely unravels the minute all of these conditions aren’t met. Just look at all the executive orders and cornerstone legislation that Trump has been able to undo inside of a single term. Creating positions that requires an untenable, short-lived condition to be successful just doesn’t seem very smart to me. Yet both parties endorse this. At the same time, even when a single party controls everything it’s still not very good at getting what it wants — because there are a number of minority protections built in to the system. I think the first thing voters need to do is adjust our expectations. What can you compromise on? What positions can you live without entirely? What opposing policies might actually make sense over the next twenty or thirty years? I think it’s time we start thinking about how do we create laws that are sustainable when you don’t have all the power concentrated in one party.
- HuShifang 8y agoAgreed. I would note too that the closest thing to a broad-spanning "formative" experience for US baby boomers was the Vietnam War -- but unlike WWII, elites essentially sat that one out, afflicted as they were with "bone spurs" and the like, and not that many people actively participated in it. (And, it was a more politically and morally problematic conflict than WWII to boot.) Anecdotally, I find that the baby boomers I personally know who did serve in Vietnam tend to be more politically conscientious/open-minded and less tribalistic than those who didn't.
- Spivak 8y ago> people support their team, for no rational reason, but just because they are fans of that team You do realize that to be able to treat politics like a game and root for a team for no reason means you must be so socioeconomically privileged and insulated from the consequences that it doesn't matter what decision is made because it doesn't affect you. Do you really think this is the case for most people in the US? I can't vote Republican because their openly stated policy goals would wipe out my ability to exist. I would really like for my vote to be more nuanced but when I'm given only given two choices...