2 ms·

Knew this comment would pop up. Some people genuinely want to live in the Judge Dredd universe..

dmix 8y ago
Nearly every news website's comment section for a serious crime has someone saying "we should just line them up and shoot thm, save everyone the time and money". As if this hasn't been said a million times and wasn't a terrible idea each of those million times. Anyone can spend 2min googling "wrongful convictions" and the number of people found innocent by the judicial process to see why. Not to mention the whole reason why "lynch mob" style justice is a terrible idea (it's a highly emotional process which gets it wrong wayyy more often than courts/police, the punishments are often way out of proportion to the crimes, no due process, etc, etc).
- luckylion 8y ago
  > Anyone can spend 2min googling "wrongful convictions" and the number of people found innocent by the judicial process to see why. This is just as good an argument against any form of law enforcement though. Don't imprison people because you will undoubtedly also target innocent people. Mind you, I'm not pro capital punishment, but "don't do it, because you will also hit innocent people" isn't a good argument against it.
conanbatt 8y ago
Can't see the original comment, but I think americans don't appreciate that their system is amongst the most brutally repressive in comparison to south america. In San Francisco you can walk down market and see people dealing drugs, but would never rob you. The former because the police have a no persecute policy, the latter because they have a no tolerance policy. In places like Argentina or brazil, the mere sight of people like this means 100% guaranteed robbery. I believe americans visiting the wrong neighborhood in Argentina or Brazil would have deeply false sense of security, which is why they are prime targets.
luckylion 8y ago
> Some people genuinely want to live in the Judge Dredd universe.. Pretty much everybody prefers that over total gang land chaos. Don't forget that "living in Scandinavia" isn't the usual alternative.

dmix 8y ago

Nearly every news website's comment section for a serious crime has someone saying "we should just line them up and shoot thm, save everyone the time and money". As if this hasn't been said a million times and wasn't a terrible idea each of those million times. Anyone can spend 2min googling "wrongful convictions" and the number of people found innocent by the judicial process to see why. Not to mention the whole reason why "lynch mob" style justice is a terrible idea (it's a highly emotional process which gets it wrong wayyy more often than courts/police, the punishments are often way out of proportion to the crimes, no due process, etc, etc).

luckylion 8y ago
> Anyone can spend 2min googling "wrongful convictions" and the number of people found innocent by the judicial process to see why. This is just as good an argument against any form of law enforcement though. Don't imprison people because you will undoubtedly also target innocent people. Mind you, I'm not pro capital punishment, but "don't do it, because you will also hit innocent people" isn't a good argument against it.

conanbatt 8y ago

Can't see the original comment, but I think americans don't appreciate that their system is amongst the most brutally repressive in comparison to south america. In San Francisco you can walk down market and see people dealing drugs, but would never rob you. The former because the police have a no persecute policy, the latter because they have a no tolerance policy. In places like Argentina or brazil, the mere sight of people like this means 100% guaranteed robbery. I believe americans visiting the wrong neighborhood in Argentina or Brazil would have deeply false sense of security, which is why they are prime targets.

luckylion 8y ago

> Some people genuinely want to live in the Judge Dredd universe.. Pretty much everybody prefers that over total gang land chaos. Don't forget that "living in Scandinavia" isn't the usual alternative.