3 ms·
If you treat it as a war, was it really any different? SIGINT is generally considered legitimate military targets. So if you're explicitly hacking on behalf of
by int_19h 8y ago
If you treat it as a war, was it really any different? SIGINT is generally considered legitimate military targets. So if you're explicitly hacking on behalf of one of the parties in the conflict, and especially if you're hacking military targets, why shouldn't you be considered a combatant?
It's interesting that the tweet in this article makes this point:
> this is the equivalent of saying blowing up drone pilots at Ellis AF Base is okay too.
For a party currently engaged in military conflict with US - say, Taliban - why would it not be, in terms of international rules and customs of war? Drone pilots are definitely combatants - you don't get to lob Hellfires at targets remotely, but then complain when they find you in person and shoot back. Does anybody seriously thinks otherwise?
- WheelsAtLarge 8y ago>If you treat it as a war, was it really any different? It's a huge difference. It's a game changer. The rule has been to respond in kind. In the past cyber attacks were responded with cyber attacks. Now a bomb will be dropped on the attackers. Hackers haven't gone into war thinking they are direct targets. That's changed now. Of course, that means that the targets will get better defenses but don't expect to be a supporting player and be treated as such. At some level, it's a recognition of how much of modern society is managed in cyberspace and how much damage can be done with a cyber attack.
- int_19h 8y agoI don't think there was ever an "in kind" rule that is that narrow. I remember back in 1999 during the Kosovo war, NATO bombed the Yugoslavian Ministry of Defense, for example - and it was generally considered a legitimate target, even though the people inside weren't directly shooting at anybody. I think the broader context is important here. A cyber attack by itself does not justify this sort of response. But a cyber attack that is intended to bolster one side in a military conflict, carried out by people explicitly aligned with that side, is a part of the broader war effort. Responding to that with deadly force is still responding "in kind".