3 ms·
> don't involve any math [and so is] ... unfalsifiable A theory involving math is only better than the alternative if it is also correct. Theories can be falsi
by roenxi 8y ago
> don't involve any math [and so is] ... unfalsifiable
A theory involving math is only better than the alternative if it is also correct. Theories can be falsifiable if they don't have math either.
For example, I might have a theory that water always flows downhill. Then I am confronted with a pump, and my theory is now falsified. Fitting a mathematical model involving gravitational constants and laminar flows will be a better theory because it fits the observations very well.
A theory that I have porridge for breakfast in a way that can be modeled with an iid normal distribution is a terrible theory, because if I find out about it I'll start playing with my breakfast just to spite the modeler. The inclusion of a precise mathematical model just paints a bigger target for me to hit. Economics is much more in that vein of things - the people being modeled can respond to the models themselves.
The mainstream economics theories are all going to be based on non-mathematical assumptions that link reality to a math-y model. Those assumptions are the weak point of economics. We can trust the academics to get the math right once they've finished making assumptions.
- SantalBlush 8y agoYour interpretation of my statement isn't accurate. Austrian theory's lack of mathematical formalization is what makes it unfalsifiable. It's not your water example; if it were, then you would be correct. Again, it is easy and often valid to criticize the methodologies associated with mainstream econ, but the question is whether one can offer a demonstrably superior alternative. You have not done that here.
- roenxi 8y ago> but the question is whether one can offer a demonstrably superior alternative That isn't the only question. There is also a question "is there something here that we can model?". There is no requirement to provide a better model if the existing model is inaccurate enough. I've never actually seen an economic model that uses maths beyond accounting balances or basic calculus/timeseries so I'm certainly not qualified to critique them - whatever they are. But the Austrain critiques seem to be something like that if you blow a credit bubble then manipulating accounting identities isn't enough to avoid having to pay back the credit at some point and taking an economic fall where the credit gave you a boost. That is a falsifiable position. The Americans and others are running a big experiment that has so far provided potentially falsifying evidence. They can still be proven wrong even though they havn't published an equation, so their theories are obviously falsifiable.
- SantalBlush 8y ago>There is no requirement to provide a better model if the existing model is inaccurate enough. We disagree here. I think this notion is what allows people to arbitrarily dismiss theories that they personally don't like.