3 ms·
> I keep reading about people predicting SSDs are going to hit the same price/capacity as spinning disks, but I just don't see it with the large >10TB volumes a
by wtallis 8y ago
> I keep reading about people predicting SSDs are going to hit the same price/capacity as spinning disks, but I just don't see it with the large >10TB volumes any time soon.
To elaborate on this: $/TB varies widely depending on total drive capacity. The fixed costs of hard drive spindle motors, actuators, etc. are higher than the costs of an SSD controller and PCB. Adding a platter to a hard drive is cheaper on a per-GB basis than adding more NAND flash to an SSD, but there's a crossover point below which SSDs have cheaper price per GB and small hard drives are no longer economical to manufacture. That crossover point has now risen to encompass the majority of consumer use cases, but it is nowhere near 10TB and won't be anytime soon. That crossover point also seems to be moving upward much faster than typical consumer storage needs, so we can expect this segment of the hard drive market to continue to wither.
- the8472 8y ago> That crossover point has now risen to encompass the majority of consumer use cases cheapest drives measured in price/capacity HDDs: 2TB @ 0.017€/GB M.2 SSDs: 2TB @ 0.1€/GB I see no crossover point here. SSDs are not even touching the the same order of magnitude.
- nicoburns 8y agoThe crossover point is currently around 256gb. 500gb is close. 1tb/2tb isn't there yet. But it likely won't be too long.
- the8472 8y ago2.5" HDD, 250GB @ 0.059€/GB 2.5" SSD, 256GB @ 0.108€/GB Still not seeing it. And I don't consider these ranges practical. But I guess some people must since they're still made.
- wtallis 8y agoPay a little more attention to the hard drives you're looking at. Almost all the product listings for tiny hard drives are for models that are several generations old, usually with branding that the manufacturers have long since retired (WD Caviar, Seagate Momentus). The cheapest listings are often grey market sellers of old stock with no manufacturer's warranty. Seagate has abandoned all capacities below 500GB, and they offer limited options for form factor and RPM at 500GB. Western Digital still lists one 250GB model and two 320GB models, but none of them are cheaper than a 480GB-class SATA SSD. Current 500GB hard drives start at $38-40, and 480GB SSDs start around $48-50. These capacities are sufficient for typical consumers.
- incompatible 8y agoMaybe you have to go a bit lower. Does the typical consumer use case need even 2TB?
- the8472 8y agoGames tend to gobble up a lot of space
- wtallis 8y agoMost of the consumer use cases for 2+ TB are well served by external drives or a NAS, which aren't part of the market segment that Nidec is predicting to crash this year. Backups and movie/photo libraries don't need to be on local internal drives. Large video game libraries just don't account for very much of the PC userbase. Every PC should have an SSD as primary storage, and with 512GB drives down to $50, very few PCs need any other internal storage.
- incompatible 8y agoYeah, I just noticed how cheap the SSDs have become. I just ordered a couple of small ones, even though I'm generally a cheapskate.
- reitzensteinm 8y agoIt's going to be a vicious cycle as well (or virtuous depending on your point of view). As demand for HDDs weakens, investments in R&D will be scaled back significantly. HDDs are in trouble even if you assume they'll follow the same capacity ramp they once did. If they slow down, they're toast. (Although SSDs may also hit a wall scaling down; the low hanging fruit may already be picked.)
- wtallis 8y agoWe're already past the point where hard drive R&D is driven solely by datacenter needs; nobody was working on 14+ TB hard drives with the expectation that consumers would be a non-trivial part of that market segment, except indirectly through cloud storage.
- reitzensteinm 8y agoTypically improvements come in the form of the density of the bits you're storing on a platter, which is just as relevant to a single platter or five (or even seven platter helium drives). SMR is an example of something that's relevant to all datacenter use, but only perhaps half of consumer use. And of course helium itself is pretty much datacenter focused only. The linked article has the datacenter share last year as 13.6% of all units (but growing shipments). Looking at Seagate's last filing, they had $601m gross profit last quarter, and an R&D spend of $238m had to come out of that. I don't see how you scale the company down to a fifth of its size and maintain anything like the R&D velocity it once had; and once it slows down, the band of competitiveness of HDD over SSD even for datacenter use is going to continuously narrow. A complete collapse of the HDD market after a decade is not unthinkable, unless SSD progress hits a wall. (Of course Seagate does make some SSDs, which I'm not accounting for, but taking the time to separate it isn't going to meaningfully change the picture.)
- wtallis 8y agoNidec divides the hard drive market into 5 segments: PC, External, Consumer Electronics, Datacenter, Enterprise. One of those five segments is crashing. External and Consumer Electronics are contracting slowly but will still be a cash cow for a while because those drives are still selling but don't require much if any R&D. Datacenter and Enterprise are basically the same for R&D purposes, and together are growing slightly. There's a big difference between Seagate suffering the loss of (half of) one of those five market segments, and scaling the company down to a fifth of its size. Yes, they'll have a harder time funding R&D, but they're quite a ways off from having to drastically slash their R&D budget.