7 ms·
Trying to understand the subculture here, and failing. If I understand correctly, during a very important bike race the author made a verbal deal with his compe
by tomcam 8y ago
Trying to understand the subculture here, and failing. If I understand correctly, during a very important bike race the author made a verbal deal with his competitor near the end of the race, and the competitor broke that verbal deal.
Let me hasten to say that had I made such a deal, I wouldn’t have broken it.
But shouldn’t the author have assumed that his competitor was playing mind games? If I understand correctly there are no rules against deals like this. And I imagine there are no rules against lying to your competitor.
I would feel if I were in the author’s place that I had allowed myself to be taken advantage of, that I had trusted a competitor, which is generally speaking not a good idea in a race like that.
It seems to me this is the author saying he trained physically for the race but got hoodwinked by someone he by nature should not trust.
Or is there something about the subculture I’m missing?
- drenvuk 8y agoYou're not wrong. He is a sore loser who assumed there were certain rules in play and failed because of it.
- brazzy 8y agoYes, he is wrong and so are you, because those rules do exist even if they are unwritten. They are part of the sport, and they have to be because while placements are awarded to individuals, it is impossible for an individual to perform well with cooperating with others.
- quadrangle 8y agoIt's not just the subculture. It's like any trust game. You violate trust, you won't get trusted in the future. There's long-term reputation. And that's just some of the factors behind how subcultures come to basically honor agreements like this. The concept of such agreements would be discarded and laughed at in a context where they were rarely kept. Just knowing that the concept exists is enough to know that it must have gained trust and deference in the subculture. Listen to the This American Life episode linked elsewhere in the comments to get the context. The guy who broke his promise actually meant the promise when he said it and then felt privately ashamed of breaking it (and breaking the promise was itself a spur-of-the-moment, wasn't-thinking decision). That's not what happens if it's just mind games.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hawaiian 8y agoThat sounds about right. For whatever reason, the author, who is also the stronger cyclist, agreed to pull his competitor to 2nd place. The weaker racer also did some pulling. I think the author allows his bias to show too much, because even having a weaker racer pull you for short intervals is a huge advantage compared to riding solo. More importantly, the author obviously factored staying ahead of the pack while agreeing to the deal. As far as I can tell, we wouldn't know if the pack would have caught the author and whether they would have all attacked, leaving him in 8th or 9th place. If the author wasn't likely to get caught by the pack, why even agree to the deal?
- usrusr 8y ago> As far as I can tell, we wouldn't know if the pack would have caught the author and whether they would have all attacked, leaving him in 8th or 9th place. Kind of ruins the story but it's true. They were in a game of oxygen-deprived prisoner's dilemma, not in a death-before-dishonor chivalry contest.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> But shouldn’t the author have assumed that his competitor was playing mind games? It’s not like a tactical feint as you’re suggesting - it’s unsportsmanlike behaviour in the norms of the game. It’s like mocking someone’s dead mother during a game - I guess it may not contravene any written rule but you’re a pretty rotten person if you do it and you’d be better off not taking part if that’s your approach to things. It’s such a basic contravention of civility that it’s cheating.
- ken 8y agoIt's universal to not mock someone's family, but that's pretty universal in everyday life, too. As for the rest, well, different athletes often have very different ideas of what they consider unsportsmanlike. Runners like Ron Clarke and Steve Prefontaine called it "chickenshit" to not race as hard as you could right from the start, but the cyclists here apparently have no such compunctions.
- CydeWeys 8y agoYou won't win a bicycle race with that strategy. Won't even get close. You'll burn up all your energy being in the lead, not able to take advantage of drafting in a peloton, and you'll be far behind in the end. Cycling is a different sport than running. It's a lot faster, and air resistance scales with velocity squared. And secondly, if Ron and Steve say they're going to race all-out, and then do so, then they're being honorable. They're not violating their word. Big difference between that and then giving your word you're going to take a different tack, but then betray the other person when it's advantageous to do so.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- knappe 8y agoThere are a lot of agreements like this in cycling. They're even regularly exercised in the Tour de France. http://theconversation.com/unofficial-rules-of-the-tour-de-france-matter-most-28841 http://theconversation.com/unofficial-rules-of-the-tour-de-f... Whether or not they're official rules, they do exist to a degree. While I've never heard of someone brokering a deal to not attack, I wouldn't be surprised if they do happen.
- maxxxxx 8y agoFor example the rider with the yellow jersey won’t try to win a stage if other drivers are around that are not a threat in the overall standing. You see that often in mountain stages.
- jeffrallen 8y agoOr, "we'll all take performance enhancing drugs and just not talk about it because anyway everyone does it". Talking about honor and sportsmanship in the context of pro cycling is just incomprehensible to me.
- indymike 8y agoBoth riders had a conscience and were trying to be honorable. That is admirable, but for a one day race like a National Championship, both riders had an obligation to win for their team, not to appease some unwritten code of honor. A deal in a stage race where both riders win is different because both riders are winning for their team (i.e. Weaker rider gets the stage, stronger rider picks up time in the overall standings).
- roelschroeven 8y agoThe thing is: without such a deal, they probably wouldn't have continued cooperating, and the pack would have eaten them. With the deal, both of them ended up on the podium. Also, making a deal and then not honoring it is not what I call trying to be honorable.
- indymike 8y agoThe usual deal is not "you win, I come in second." It is usually, "Let's work together and get to the last 1km or 500m." Honestly, I feel really bad for both the author and subject of the article. Having so much of your life defined by a moment on time where everyone has huge regrets... The author did a wonderful job telling the story.
- outside1234 8y agoThere is a pretty strong culture in bike racing of making deals like this and sticking to them, because in a break like this, if two people work together, they have almost literally twice as good a chance of winning. For example, Lance Armstrong and Marco Pantani on the famous Alpe d'Huez in the Tour de France: Lance offered him the stage win if he would work with him so he could make time on his rivals for the overall 23 day race general classification: http://www.cyclingnews.com/features/armstrong-if-i-was-the-carpenter-pantani-was-the-artist/ http://www.cyclingnews.com/features/armstrong-if-i-was-the-c... In top level professional riding, if you renege on a deal like this, you will have a seriously hard time making another deal like this in the future and that will seriously impair your professional prospects, because these deals are everywhere because of the multi-goaled nature (stage vs. overall vs. mountain points vs. sprint points) of the sport.
- sundvor 8y agoRe Armstrong link; that was a great read, thanks very much. Armstrong comes across with complete honesty, which is great to see - I just like when people write in an unfiltered, open way. "When you name all the other winners from those days, all the riders, he was geared up in just the same way"!
- JauntyHatAngle 8y agoI agree that candor can be refreshing, but Armstrong (in my opinion) is a bit of a sociopath that knows how to manipulate the truth to cast himself in the best light possible. It may appear unfiltered and open, but he's obscuring a lot of the truth there.
- ethbro 8y ago> sociopath I assume most people who are world class (in anything that takes practice) and appear honest and/or normal are somewhat "sociopathic." Driving towards a goal with that kind of monomaniacal focus isn't normal. Ergo, if someone seems to be, they're probably acting the part. Not that I hold that against them: their achievements are mind-bogglingly amazing, and I imagine it's easier to pretend to be normal in social situations.
- dahart 8y agoSome of the sting here was that the guy who won publicly denied what he did at the time. That’s separate from and unrelated to whether you consider breaking an agreement to be acceptable or not. Your comment reminds me of a great article a few years back from the New Yorker about the full court press in basketball, and how (according to the story) it used to be somewhat socially unacceptable, but teams that pressed aggressively could win. Some other interesting examples of breaking social norms in games in the article too... https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/05/11/how-david-beats-goliath https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/05/11/how-david-beat...
- brigandish 8y agoVery interesting read. It made me wonder if I'd have been happy to be coached to use the press and win or take the easier route when I was at school. I must get round to watching Lawrence of Arabia…
- anigbrowl 8y agoBut shouldn’t the author have assumed that his competitor was playing mind games? No. Assuming that is why we can't have nice things. If you give someone your word, it has to mean something.
- fergie 8y agoOn a practical level, if you are known for being a "wheel sucker", then people wont go on breakaways with you. Likewise, if you are known for breaking promises then you will struggle to make the ad-hoc pacts and deals necessary to win at the pro-level (although u23 is essentially "every man for himself").
- wjnc 8y agoIt's a coming of age story whether you understand cycling or not. A young man makes a mistake and harms another young man and it haunts them for many years. Growing up they reflect on the moment many times with different mindsets and ultimately meet up and make good as best as they can. It's a timeless story. And it has wheels.
- gpsx 8y agoWhen I was running track in high school, we were doing a workout that was 10 200m sprints. One of my best friends Erik was running in the same group as I was. We were about the same speed. But during these 200's, he was just sitting back while I was going all out. On the ninth sprint, the coach said whoever wins the group doesn't have to do the 10th one. Erik said to me, "Dave, you can win this one" because he knew I was working hard and was tired. And he is also just a quality person. But when we were running that ninth 200, I was just completely spent. I was in slow motion. He had to run past me. I don't recall what we said when he passed me, but something along the lines of him apologizing and that he had to go, and I said it was ok. I had to run the 10th sprint even though coach knew very well had happened. I didn't have any hard feelings towards my friend. He wasn't trying to take advantage but I am sure he still felt bad. (Now, I may have had some hard feelings toward the coach...) This is quite a bit different stakes between high school track practice and a national championship cycling race. But I wonder if something similar happened. The author, being trashed from working so hard, may have been going pretty slow and this may have helped the eventual winner say "Forget this I'm just going to go". I'm not saying its OK, I just wonder if it was a factor.