4 ms·
I don't really buy the slippery slope argument. People have to draw an ethical line somewhere, and I'd say there's a huge gap between using a pirated copy of P
by dasil003 16y ago
I don't really buy the slippery slope argument. People have to draw an ethical line somewhere, and I'd say there's a huge gap between using a pirated copy of Photoshop when you have no revenue and lying to customers and investors about product capabilities and financials. It sounds like the OA had an experience with a crooked founder, and now feels like pirating software is an early sign of serious ethical flaws. Well, it's a firm moral stance and I respect him for it, but the fact that most junkies have smoked weed before doesn't mean that anyone who smokes a joint is destined to become a junky.
- alain94040 16y agousing a pirated copy of Photoshop when you have no revenue If you read the original HN threads, it sounded like the pirating was systematic, on lots of software, not just one copy once. And it seemed to bother no one. That's a serious sign. It would have been slightly different if, when handed pirated software, the new employee was told something along the lines of: "I know it's a terrible thing to do, but it's just temporary before we figure out what to do". That was not said. How do you know, as the new employee, that agreeing to use pirated software will not get you in trouble with the law? So your boss is effectively telling you to do something illegal and doesn't care at all what may happen to you? What does that tell you about your boss?
- smithbits 16y agoThere's a quote that I can't source at the moment to the effect that "In any reasonable sized group of people there are 10% that are incorruptibly good and 10% that are irredeemably bad and the other 80% will do what the leaders do." If you've got an organization where the leaders think it's okay to pirate software then you've also got an organization where it's okay to not pay suppliers on time or be honest about how much runway is left or any number of other things. It means you can't trust those people. Now there are plenty of monetarily successful organization that run on fear and paranoia and some people can excel in that world. But if you're expecting a bonus or a promotion because someone looked you in the eye and promised it, well, get used to disappointment. The article isn't making a slippery slope argument, it's saying that you're already there, you just might not know it yet.
- dasil003 16y agoThe article isn't making a slippery slope argument, it's saying that you're already there, you just might not know it yet. I'm sorry but you think that anyone who pirates software regardless of the circumstances is also a person who routinely looks people in the eye and makes false promises? This is a ridiculous premise that should require no refutation.