3 ms·
>MCAS wasn't designed because "autopilot systems cannot cope with AoA disagree." MCAS couldn't handle AoA disagree, that's the whole crux of the problem. >- MC
by salawat 8y ago
>MCAS wasn't designed because "autopilot systems cannot cope with AoA disagree." MCAS couldn't handle AoA disagree, that's the whole crux of the problem.
>- MCAS wasn't enabled at all when autopilot was. Only manual flying
Correct.
- MCAS was designed to simulate the non-Max 737's thrust curve to maintain a similar type rating FOR PILOTS. It had nothing to do with autopilot at all.
Incorrect. Ish.
MCAS has squat to do with thrust curves, it has to do wit control force curves. Namely bringing the amount of control column force at high AoA needed to achieve further increases in AoA in line with the expectations of a trained 737 pilot. The rest of that point is accurate though.
>MCAS used trim to counter-act an overeager upwards angle during key parts of the flight like take-off. It used electronic trim to accomplish this and a single AoA sensor to determine when.
Incorrect-ish.
Yes, take-off would be one of the more likely places to run into an MCAS activation, but generally speaking, even that rotation doesn't come anywhere near the AoA MCAS was meant to deal with, and to boot, flaps being engaged disables the MCAS system.
>This forced the Ethiopian Airline pilots into a difficult choice; and they ultimately decided to re-enable electronic trim and use the yoke trim switch (which is more powerful) to fix the trim. Unfortunately MCAS trimmed the aircraft further, they lost control, and the aircraft crashed.
Trim switch is higher priority, but not more powerful per se. the trim switch was clearly overwhelmed in terms of MCAS's ability to command trim changes in 2.5 degree increments five seconds after the release of the yoke trim switch as long as it detected the high AoA. Not sure whether those trim switches are continuous direct drive (I.e. jackscrew turned as long as the switch is held down) or discrete (updates the jackscrew motors to move to next position over time, only to be overridden by MCAS five seconds later).
Other than that, that looks like a fairly good summary.