2 ms·
I’ve always considered the existence of “Type 2 fun” as a bug in our brain hardware: it’s the same mechanism that makes your brain believe that experiences like
by derefr 8y ago
I’ve always considered the existence of “Type 2 fun” as a bug in our brain hardware: it’s the same mechanism that makes your brain believe that experiences like “playing a slot machine for hours with a negative rate-of-return (both average and total)”, or “taking a drug that you’ve long grown habituated to and don’t experience a high from any more”, were still rewarding-enough experiences to reinforce their addictive potential.
- penagwin 8y agoThere's the reverse side too. Many experiences are unpleasant but I'd consider important for people to "enjoy". I don't have kids, but I think raising kids is a good example? No the direct experiences of being awake 24/7 picking up poop isn't fun, but the overall experience is what people are after?
- derefr 8y agoIMHO people are often (not always) after specific things that having raised kids provides—posterity, people who will take care of you when you’re old, etc.—and are actually not interested in any aspect of the experience of actually raising them. For people with such perspectives, I would say that what they experience is less like “something that was no fun in any part but still fun as a whole”, but rather “an input of a non-fun activity that is expected to pay out in happiness down the line”—in other words, the same kind of experience that working at a job to earn money is. As such, people (for whom this calculus works out) don’t actually have to be irrationally drawn to having kids by addictive brain signals. They have perfectly rational reasons to do so!
- jlokier 8y agoI think in many ways, you have just describe most jobs.
- mbostleman 8y agoYes. It is often likened to short term memory loss too. The general idea of the activity seemed like it would be fun prior to doing it. Then after doing it when it was actually horrible, you still have the same feeling about its potential fun that you had in the beginning, but you fail to modify it with the pain of the actual experience - as if you forgot already.
- JKCalhoun 8y ago> I’ve always considered the existence of “Type 2 fun” as a bug in our brain hardware Not the way I see it. Adversity followed by salvation gives you confidence that you can overcome future challenges.
- snarf21 8y agoInteresting point of view but it seems like the opposite to me. The reason we remember and recollect these "type 2 fun" events is that they generally did not go as expected. When you go to the beach, swim, have a beer and go out to dinner, etc., the day was enjoyable but also went exactly as planned. In 5 years, you are unlikely to remember any details of this day. If you had the same plan on an unusually warm day in November and then the weather changed on a dime and starting hailing, you will definitely remember that in 5 years and maybe longer. It also is a lesson that you should remember, that going to the beach in late fall might go badly.
- intertextuality 8y agoThis argument doesn't work if you believe that not everything has to be type 1 fun- that is, we don't always need to be doing things that are pleasurable in the moment in order to be "happy". For example, learning a skill to an advanced degree. Moment by moment it's not type 1 fun, but as you progress and look back, you realize that you've grown and improved. It -does- make me happy to see how far I've progressed in the hobbies/studying that I've invested a lot of time in. Conversely, seeing how much time I wasted doing "type 1" things all the time a few years ago makes me somewhat sad. Consistently playing the slots [highly engineered products designed to be addictive] has to do with addiction and dopamine rushes when you get a hit. I wouldn't categorize that as the same as doing things like hiking or whatnot.