6 ms·
I believe this is an incredibly dangerous attitude. Kudos that you're doing your part, and leading by example is important. However, systemic change is possib
by bryanlarsen 8y ago
I believe this is an incredibly dangerous attitude. Kudos that you're doing your part, and leading by example is important.
However, systemic change is possible. We have numerous counter-examples: the UN, the Montreal protocol, free trade deals, et cetera.
So why don't we have systemic change for climate change, because people like you and I let our politicians get away with it! If it was obvious to politicians that doing something about climate change was required to get re-elected, they'd do it.
It's an incredibly difficult task, which means we need to try harder, not that we should just give up on the planet.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoThe next U.S. federal election is an excellent opportunity to address climate change. Ensure that the Democratic primary chooses a leader with a good plan, and then ensure that he/she wins in 2020.
- tenpies 8y agoExcept it's also not. As a continent, Asia is the largest polluter by far. What's worst, they're exporting those practices to Africa. Meanwhile, the Anglo-West is hyper-focused on the US because there's a president they don't like. This has been a blessing (now the average Anglo-Westerner at least pretends to care about the environment), but also a curse (they think the US is the only country that can save humanity).
- _Microft 8y agoThe per-capita emissions in the US are about twice to 2.5 times as high as that of a british citizen. Maybe it's just that there are the low hanging fruits? It's easier to reduce 1 ton of annual CO_2 emissions when you're producing 17 tons per year and person (like in the US) than when you're at 6 tons like the Brits. In either case, it would be 1 ton saved per year but it's only a 6% reduction for someone in the US but a 17% reduction of their yearly emission for a Brit.
- MiroF 8y agoThere's actually a whole body of literature out there on climate justice, if you want to take a look for answers. One of the primary ones is that most of the developed world has gotten to the quality of life it has today through very high historic emission levels (and continues to have higher per capita emissions). Additional emissions in the West go towards maintaining our very, very high quality of life - emissions in the developing world (like Asia) go towards bringing millions of people out of poverty. Asia may be the largest polluter by far, it also happens to be the continent with the most people and the most people in poverty. Nobody thinks that the US is the only country that can save humanity (even if the US cut to 0, that wouldn't be sufficient, although it'd be approaching it), but if the US, which easily emits 4-6x more than most people per capita is unwilling to cut, than we are totally FUBAR on a global scale.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Except it's also not. As a continent, Asia is the largest polluter by far. That doesn't mean that US policy can't address the problem; US policy—on climate as well as most other things—need not be limited to domestic policy.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoExactly. For example the US could collect a "carbon duty" at the border on all imports. If the source nation has already collected a carbon tax or equivalent, it avoids the carbon duty.
- selimthegrim 8y agoSome people were hoping Trump’s proposed Border Adjustment Tax could have done double duty of this sort
- zajd 8y agohttps://wriorg.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/uploads/cumulative_emissions.png https://wriorg.s3.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/uploads/cumulati...
- bryanlarsen 8y ago- US per capita emissions are more than double China's. - China is taking concrete steps to reduce emissions: capping coal production, switching to electric buses, et cetera - For better or worse other countries are far more likely to say "why should we reduce emissions if even the US won't" than to say "why should we reduce emissions if China won't".
- perfunctory 8y ago> As a continent, Asia is the largest polluter by far. Don't forget that a lot of that pollution is due to production for western consumption.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoHow much of that is as a result of them manufacturing the vast majority of our stuff? Essentially we outsourced a proportion of our emissions. USA is doing terribly thanks to having by far the largest emissions per head, dramatically in excess of anywhere else. Asia is doing poorly thanks to having larger populations, developing apace and being home to much of the world's manufacturing. UK is just about world's worst for historic cumulative emissions thanks to being home of the industrial revolution. Shall I go on? It's everyone's problem, and needs addressing everywhere, at every election. Anything else is just finger-pointing excuses not to act.
- mikeash 8y agoThe US gets the attention because they’re the only powerful country fighting against the sort of collective action we need to take.
- zaroth 8y agoWould you mind substantiating that claim a bit? It seems false on the face of it, but I don’t want to strawman your argument just to shoot it down if there’s more to it. Russia and China are not fighting against the sort of collective action we need to take?
- mikeash 8y agoRussia is not powerful and China is not fighting it.
- mempko 8y agowhat is an anglo-westerner?
- TheBeardKing 8y agoPer capita, North America is 4.6x worse than Asia: https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2018/10/CO2-emissions-by-income-and-region.png https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2018/10/CO2-emissions-by-...
- dredmorbius 8y agoThe US can play a leadership role. It's abdicated that position presently.
- MiroF 8y agoI'm not confident any of the Democratic candidates have a good plan and even if they do, voters would not support it. Even with mild assumptions about a duty to not harm future generations (say if we substantially discount the livelihood of our children and their children in favor of our own), we would need to take action that dramatically reduces our emissions. American voters will not vote for anything even remotely of that magnitude. Most Americans would be unwilling to see their electrical bills rise $10 if it meant averting climate change.
- francisofascii 8y agoUnfortunately you are correct. If you ever read the comments section of news piece regarding gas taxes or steps to reduce carbon emissions, the average American voter freaks out at the mere suggestion of increasing energy prices just a little bit.
- newnewpdro 8y agoDemocrat vs. Republican is the politicized version of Good cop vs. Bad cop. The two-party system is a farce, it's not like past democratic leaders made any meaningful systemic changes to prevent climate change.
- perfunctory 8y agoMaybe I wasn't very clear. I am not against systemic change. Surely we need to keep pushing for it. It's not either/or. We should use every method we can. On the other hand, recently I've been thinking about this. According to some theory it takes about 3.5% of the population to take part in active resistance to cause change (https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1&v=YJSehRlU34w https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1&v=YJSehRlU34w). Now, 3.5% is clearly not a majority required to vote in the right politicians. Which leaves you with direct action. Something like that.
- jlokier 8y ago> According to some theory it takes about 3.5% of the population to take part in active resistance to cause change If that's true, it should be made more widely known. I think that would be cause for hope for many people who despair at democracy and collective idiocy, and it would change their behaviour because of hope and belief in the effect of personal actions. If the 3.5% is actually true, that change of behaviour caused by knowing it might tip serious balances.
- rjf72 8y agoConsider the very foreseeable 'unforeseen consequences' of suggestions such as this. Think of all the views you may find undesirable. Now how many of them do you think could round up 3.5% of people to engage in disruptive behavior if they believed it would let them 'win'? You end up in a situation where you want people you agree with to engage in disruptive behavior, but not people you disagree with. Yet messaging like this would fully motivate everybody. It seems likely to ultimately do little more than encourage fringe extremism because you have to remember everybody always seems themselves as the good guy. Let them think they can win with a negligible minority of disruption, and you're strongly motivating extreme behavior from fringe groups. For that matter you even motivate people who like to play puppeteer. Imagine you're a billionaire and you now believe you can achieve near anything you want if you can just get 3.5% of people to start misbehaving. Getting your way by misbehavior is exactly what we aimed to move away from with democracy. And I completely agree with you on the failings of democracy which does seem to be trending towards idiocracy. At the same time, I think this is the sort of solution where the cure is far worse than the disease. You keep the same idiocracy, but now you convince them that they can get whatever they want if they start trying to break down normal civil order. And the current establishment in politics would use it, similar to 9/11, as an excuse to greatly expand domestic surveillance and further strip away privacy and various civil rights. You know, for 'your' protection.
- newnewpdro 8y agothey're not mutually exclusive