4 ms·
I wonder if the solution is remarkably simple: Make phone calls expensive again. Get rid of unlimited/free/super-cheap rates and make all callers pay by the mi
by reaperducer 8y ago
I wonder if the solution is remarkably simple: Make phone calls expensive again.
Get rid of unlimited/free/super-cheap rates and make all callers pay by the minute again. Especially inbound international calls.
Let people who want free communication use FaceTime and SMS and Email and whatnot. But make phone calls expensive enough that you know if someone is paying to call you it must be important.
I got my first document scanner in 1997. Because of that I still have all of my phone bills going back to that year. I just looked up my April 1997 Cincinnati Bell bill. A five minute call from Cincinnati to Charleston, West Virginia cost $1.45 ($2.31 in 2019 money).
If we can raise the cost of customer acquisition there will be far fewer scammers.
Incidentally, my total bill for that month was $104.34 -- almost the same as what I spend for cell service today. Except that now I'm paying for unlimited texts and minutes that I never use. The only advantage my phone has today is its mobility, which feels more like a burden than a benefit.
- kumarharsh 8y agoYes, because Nokia 3310 has FaceTime.
- kalleboo 8y agoI believe this is one reason why spam calls are less of a problem in Europe - in Europe the caller pays the higher rate to call mobile phones (vs the north America system where the cell phone user pays for incoming "airtime"). Just looking at skypeout rates and an example, UK landlines cost 2 cents/min vs 10 cents for mobiles
- gruez 8y ago>in Europe the caller pays the higher rate to call mobile phones (vs the north America system where the cell phone user pays for incoming "airtime"). So in Europe, is receiving calls on a mobile phones free? Or do you still have to pay for minutes?
- detaro 8y agoAt least in the countries I'm familiar with it's free, unless you're in a different country and have to pay roaming charges. (Gotta be careful with "in Europe" claims)
- martin-adams 8y agoIn the UK it's free to receive calls. When travelling abroad you have to consider people leaving you a voicemail costing you if it rings you phone first, then they go to your voicemail. The downside is you can't really get free services that forward to your mobile.
- sschueller 8y agoIf you are at your home location incoming calls are free. The caller pays. US carriers double dip by charging the caller and the receiver.
- kalleboo 8y agoYes, receiving calls (and text messages) is free. (unless you are roaming and then you pay the international sector of the call) As far as I know this is true not just in Europe but everywhere outside of North America. It's certainly been true in the Asian countries I've been to (I get prepaid SIM cards everywhere I visit). It comes down to the numbering plans - in the NANP (north american numbering plan), landline and mobile phone numbers are mixed together and you can't distinguish them without a database. In other countries, mobile phones have their own "mobile phones" area code which is non-geographic and applies to all mobile phones. This means that callers beforehand know if they're calling a mobile phone or a landline.
- cesarb 8y ago> In other countries, mobile phones have their own "mobile phones" area code which is non-geographic and applies to all mobile phones. Here in Brazil it's slightly different. The area codes are the same for fixed and cell phones, but if the first digit of the local part of the phone number is in the 7-9 range, it's a cell phone (if it's in the 2-6 range, it's a fixed phone; 1 is reserved for special services like emergency, 0 is the interurban/international/toll-free/etc prefix). So a number like +55-11-9xxxx-xxxx is a cell phone in the São Paulo region (area code 11), while a number like +55-11-2xxx-xxxx is a fixed phone in the same region.
- jgowdy 8y agoI'm disinclined to damage communication to stop bad actors. And I believe that this type of solution completely ignores the largely disproportionate economic impacts that reverting to those prices would have on different socioeconomic tiers. Human communication is a good thing and largely responsible for the positive aspects of where we are today. Respectfully, diminishing it to provide relief from an inconvenience seems short sighted. Your thoughts in light of that?
- daniel-cussen 8y agoIt's not about paying by the minute. It's paying by the annoyance: there should be a fixed fee for dialing someone that doubles if they hang up in some brief number of seconds. It's not about the total time I spend talking to robocallers, it's the interruption they represent and the effort to screen them out.