2 ms·
Personally, I'd have stuck with facts. There's quite a lot of unattributed quotes and conjecture in this, which makes it read more like retaliation. It does s
by tyingq 8y ago
Personally, I'd have stuck with facts. There's quite a lot of unattributed quotes and conjecture in this, which makes it read more like retaliation.
It does sound like the author has a legit complaint, but the embellishments don't help.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Personally, I'd have stuck with facts. There's quite a lot of unattributed quotes and conjecture in this Unattributed quotes are facts, even if they aren't easily verifiable by third parties. But then, most facts someone observes and reports aren't easily verifiable by uninvolved parties. And there is very little conjecture where the factual basis isn't presented so that one can judge whether the conjecture is warranted given the stated basis (of course, generally one must also deicde whether or not to trust the description of facts.) > which makes it read more like retaliation. It doesn't read like retaliation to me at all, nor is there any apparent thing to be retaliated for unless you accept the account itself, in which case it's just an account of the facts and not retaliation.
- tyingq 8y agoAnonymous quotes like "he is such a fucking narcissist power broker" are over the line for me. If you can't stand behind that, it's better left unsaid.
- LyndsySimon 8y agoI completely agree. I feel like this quote in particular is intended as a personal attack, and that its inclusion dilutes the actual potentially valuable criticism and suggestions to the point that they’re basically irrelevant. That’s a shame, because I also believe that all projects like this have room for improvement.
- 0815test 8y ago> I feel like this quote in particular is intended as a personal attack In context, it's clearly meant to hint at a purported pattern of problematic behavior, the specific instances of which the author is unwilling to get into, for whatever reason. While gossip is always unsavory to some extent - anonymous gossip all the more so - I think we should be respectful of the author's choice here and not take what they wrote as being by definition a violation of civility norms (as a personal attack would be).