4 ms·
I don't know how this normally works. But isn't "air pollution" an overly ambiguous cause of death? Could be lung cancer, injury, asphyxiation, etc. It seems
by paulddraper 8y ago
I don't know how this normally works.
But isn't "air pollution" an overly ambiguous cause of death?
Could be lung cancer, injury, asphyxiation, etc.
It seems a bit like listing "sugar" as the cause of death.
- Funes- 8y agoWell, if it is confirmed that it had a decisive role in this unfortunate event, I guess it would be fair to say that air pollution is one of the primary causes of the development of the subsequent ailments she went through, which ultimately lead her to her death. If removing air pollution from the equation would have saved her life, I think it's reasonable to say that it was, if not the sole cause of her death, one of the causes.
- maxk42 8y agoAsthma was her cause of death. It may be due to a genetic disorder, a disease, or some other cause. But air pollution was not definitively shown to be the cause of her death. This is a political move committed by Stephen Holgate, the former chair of the U.K. government's advisory committee on air pollution. The article pretty much spells that out.
- chabes 8y agoSounds like politicians are trying to cover their asses after an entirely preventable (under their own legislation) death
- briandear 8y agoSo are Pepsi or hamburgers listed as a cause of death when someone dies of a heart attack due to obesity? Calling air pollution a cause of death is a stretch.
- jefflombardjr 8y agoPepsi and hamburgers are not shared resources. Air is. Asthma is induced by both genetic and environmental factors. [0] So air pollution causing asthma is hardly a stretch. Especially if you've been exposed 1/3 of your life at such a young age. She was 9 years old. Having developed lungs and going into that area is majorly different than developing lungs in that area. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21799018 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21799018
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoNo. Example: If a person made to ingest something that leads to immediate cardiac or respiratory failure we call it "poisoned to death". Same for "being stabbed" rather than "cardiac failure due to blood loss"
- paulddraper 8y agoThose are causes of death. ICD-10 has X85 "Assault by drugs, medicaments and biological substances" and X99 "Assault by sharp object". [1] But it is unprecedented (AFAIK) to specify an external cause that is so far removed from the point of death. E.g. assuredly people have died from the long-term effects of tanning, but "sun tan" is not considered to be a cause of a death. [1] http://apps.who.int/classifications/apps/icd/icd10online2005/fr-icd.htm?gx85.htm+ http://apps.who.int/classifications/apps/icd/icd10online2005...
- wbl 8y agoBritish law is not medical coding. Misadventure isn't a medical code and could cover many of the bizarre ones like whale ingestion.
- ppseafield 8y agoOK, what about lead poisoning? An environmental hazard, especially effects children, preventable, mostly affects poor folks and developing nations. This seems like it's pretty analogous.
- briandear 8y agoBut she lived in that street for years. Just like someone might have eaten cheeseburgers for years and died of a heart attack. You don’t say that someone died from chronic cheeseburger ingestion.
- libraryatnight 8y agoNot being snarky, but perhaps we should. It wouldn't be untrue. When people drink their livers to death we often say they died of alcohol abuse even if we note they died of liver failure - seems reasonable if someone ate tons of cheeseburgers we could say they died of cheeseburger abuse etc. It's a bit dramatic, but could also be useful?
- chabes 8y agoFrom the article: “Ella lived near a busy street where pollution levels were consistently recorded at above the legal limit between 2010 and her death in 2013.” It seems there was legislation, enacted to protect people, that was ignored for years. The child’s death was not of their own doing, so I’m not sure why folks are even mentioning sugar or cheeseburgers.
- paulddraper 8y agoThat has nothing to do with it. Irrelevant to cause of death if child was to force-fed or self-fed cheeseburgers.