5 ms·
> Healthcare is best managed as a risk pool. No, health insurance is best managed as a risk pool, which, as you say, should obviously be everyone. But much of
by pdonis 8y ago
> Healthcare is best managed as a risk pool.
No, health insurance is best managed as a risk pool, which, as you say, should obviously be everyone.
But much of health care is not health insurance because it doesn't deal with insurable risks. Your need to get an annual physical isn't an insurable risk. Neither is a one-time appointment with a doctor to see if your headache and runny nose is just a cold or an infection that requires antibiotics. The first isn't insurable because it's a predictable recurring cost; the second isn't because it's a routine service that shouldn't be so expensive that you can't pay it out of pocket.
Health insurance should be focused on the things that are insurable risks: emergency care, hospitalization, etc. Things that aren't insurable risks, like the above, should be handled differently. But our health care system insists on treating these very different things the same, which of course is going to lead to huge inefficiencies and high costs.
- ericpauley 8y agoWhile this may make sense from the perspective of why people get insurance (to mitigate a catastrophic loss), it doesn't consider the insurer's incentives. No insurance company will want to underwrite a plan that doesn't bundle routine services, since those clearly reduce risk of complications down the road. A yearly checkup is cheap compared to missing a disease and letting it get worse.
- pdonis 8y ago> No insurance company will want to underwrite a plan that doesn't bundle routine services, since those clearly reduce risk of complications down the road But current plans don't require you to get routine services like an annual physical; they just cover them if you get them. That doesn't make sense if the insurer's incentives that you describe are driving the plan. Also, these incentives don't seem to be operating in other insurance markets. For example, auto insurance doesn't cover routine maintenance like oil changes or tire rotation.
- epicureanideal 8y agoMaybe we should have two separate kinds of health insurance? One for true emergencies (like car accidents), and rare life threatening diseases (like cancer before 60). Another for routine things, but as others have said, routine things shouldn't be so expensive. I like the idea of structuring it like a term life insurance policy. If you die, you get money, and in some policies you even get some percentage before you die to have fun. So, if you get cancer or whatever, perhaps you'd have a pool of funds available to you to deal with the disease, and you can use that money how you want, and perhaps even keep the remainder (or a portion of it) to incentivize keeping cost down. Also, it would make sense for the pool of funds available to someone to be based on remaining years. If you get cancer when you 20 it makes sense to spend a million dollars trying to cure that. If you're 90, maybe it makes sense to treat it but not as aggressively or in as costly of ways. From the perspective of building a society that you would be willing to be in, assuming you were randomly born into that society without knowing to what parents, I still think many people would agree they'd rather spend heavily on younger people than older.
- danans 8y ago> Another for routine things, but as others have said, routine things shouldn't be so expensive. This is basically a subscription. But this is also how health insurance already works in part today. A certain portion of your premium is paying for routine doctor's office visits - the insurance company is basically just acting as a payment processor for this portion of your healthcare expenditure. You could separate it from health insurance, but it likely won't make a huge difference in costs or access to care.
- pdonis 8y ago> Maybe we should have two separate kinds of health insurance? I agree we should have two different types of "plans". The one for emergencies and rare conditions would be insurance. The other would not. :-) One key objective of the "other" plan (the one that's not insurance) should be to make the actual costs of services visible to the patients, who are the ones in the best position to assess the value of those services to them. One of the biggest inefficiencies in our current system is that people get all kinds of health care services without any idea of what they actually cost. That means nobody really knows whether those services are worth what they actually cost. That's a recipe for huge inefficiency and high costs, and so it's no surprise that that's what we have.
- astura 8y agoSorry, but annual physical exams for asymptomatic adults do not reduce mortality or morbidity and certainly do not "clearly reduce risk of complications down the road" https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/is-the-annual-physical-unnecessary/ https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/is-the-annual-physical-unne... https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/re-thinking-the-annual-physical/ https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/re-thinking-the-annual-phys... https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/questioning-the-annual-pelvic-exam/ https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/questioning-the-annual-pelv... http://www.clinlabnavigator.com/questioning-the-value-of-the-annual-physical-exam.html http://www.clinlabnavigator.com/questioning-the-value-of-the... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK82767/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK82767/ The idea of the "annual physical" in general is a little odd because there's no standard on what an annual physical actually entails. I've been to doctors that order every blood test under the sun and don't touch me AT ALL to doctors who order zero blood tests but feel up all my organs in detail.
- NotSammyHagar 8y agoyou need to go to both docs apparently, or find one who does both. So you are saying that detecting early that you have high cholesterol and treats it, or a doctor noting gastrointestinal problems and tells you to get a colonoscopy, or that you have a blood sugar problem noting early onset diabetes - none of these thing will save money long term?
- hkai 8y agoIs it? Here in Hong Kong, a health checkup once a year for 10 years will cost 5000 USD, which is also comparable with the cost of treating a moderately serious disease. Checkups are very expensive, and are not even remotely guaranteed to find some critical diseases. So I would suggest that prevention is not necessarily cheaper than the cure for insurance companies, and largely their health programs like free checkups or fitness coupons are just marketing.
- craftyguy 8y agoPreventative measures (e.g. annual physical) can be seen as a form of insurable risk management. It's arguably much cheaper to treat something if it is discovered early on.
- Matticus_Rex 8y agoIf only there were a way to measure that
- pintxo 8y agoI might be mistaken, but here (Germany), regular checkups are paid by the insurance on purpose. The alternative being people not doing the checkups and thereby delaying diagnosis until treatment get‘s really expensive as things get life threatening. In the end insurance has an interest in people taking regular checkups resulting in early (cheap) action.
- pdonis 8y agoAre people required by the insurance companies to get regular checkups?
- pintxo 8y agoNo. But insurances are (to different degrees) heavily promoting checkups and health/fitness improvement programs. Some are even handing out coupons and benefits for those joining fitness studies or sports clubs etc.
- lowercased 8y agothey do the same thing in the US too, to varying degrees.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 8y agoIt would also be pretty easy to incentivize. Have an annual physical and save $X a month on your premium. We do it for other things like smoking already. Plus many examples in the car insurance world.
- wjmao88 8y agoThe insurance company can still offer to pay the cost and/or lower premiums for the insured who goes to regular checkups.
- plandis 8y agoThat's no different than health insurance companies in the US.
- 8y ago
- victor106 8y agoThis is a very interesting perspective that I never thought of before. >the second isn't because it's a routine service that shouldn't be so expensive that you can't pay it out of pocket. This is a little dicey. What if my doctor thinks it’s just not a normal cold and he needs to order blood work and ct scan? And that leads to a insurable risk.
- jellicle 8y agoThere's no reason to try to draw the distinction you're trying to draw. You're starting with ideology and proceeding to practice, which is a bad idea. There's a tremendous benefit to society in providing clean water, and also in providing medical care, for the same reasons. Preventive medical care generally has a negative cost to society; treating diabetes from the beginning is cheaper than amputating limbs, transplanting kidneys, etc.
- eftychis 8y agoCheckups and preventative care are not there for fun. They save money as a whole and in the long run, as other commenters also note. Imagine everyone was disincentivized from doing a cancer-related checkup, get vaccinated, or check if they have a cold, the flu, or something worse. It is better to spend x now than deal with a crisis (either individual or epidemic related) spending orders of magnitude more.
- dredmorbius 8y agoInsurance works through both poolong *and8 mitigating risks. Standards of treatment, care, process, and product are all core risk-management practices. As are establishing preventive and public health regimes. These in fact account for the overwhelming majority of health and longevity benefits since the 19th century. http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-uTWEATUzgxk/TXQoTibILtI/AAAAAAAAAAM/eyirotYDmXo/s1600/2004_01_healthstat.jpg http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-uTWEATUzgxk/TXQoTibILtI/AAAAAAAAAA...