5 ms·
The math in the article is a bit off when it claims the "sprawl tax" makes up the difference in higher travel costs when located in sprawling lower cost housing
by ineedasername 8y ago
The math in the article is a bit off when it claims the "sprawl tax" makes up the difference in higher travel costs when located in sprawling lower cost housing markets. They estimate increased travel cost at $3k/year, $250/month
They take Houston as an example, which is on the opposite end of the housing cost/sprawl spectrum from, say, San Francisco, but the "sprawl tax" math doesn't work here. Given average apartment costs and 30yr mortgages at about 4%:
Houston Avg House Cost:about $300k or $1400/month
SF Avg House Cost: about $1.3 million or $6100/month
Difference: about $54,000/year
Apartments aren't much better:
Houston Avg Apt: about $1100/month or $13k/year
SF Avg Apt: about $3500/month or $42,000/year
Difference: $2400/month or $29,000/year
The sprawl tax doesn't begin to cover these differences. The numbers above are similar for NYC. For Seattle it's less drastic, but still well in excess of $3k/year. Boston is on par with Seattle. On the other hand, Chicago is semi-sprawlish with it's suburbs, and prices are significantly cheaper. About the only place I could find where this "sprawl tax" concept applies successfully after looking at a few randomly picked cities is Hoboken, NJ. A small city twice as densely populated as SF, very popular through proximity NYC and a mini tech hub in its own right. There, buying a house is still not going to even out the sprawl tax, but an apartment will just about do it. (The average cost of apartments vs. houses there is oddly divergent from other cities I looked at.)
- komali2 8y agoMaybe try a city like Taipei or Tokyo? I think unfortunately there's too much noise from factors like weird regulations and anti-housing hyper activists in cities like San Francisco to get a good comparison.
- moate 8y agoBut isn't that part of the problem? You can't make these sort of blanket "one size fits all" statements because every local is a new mix of problems. The types of solutions and regulatory changes that solve the bay area would be useless in Tokyo and laughable in New Jersey.
- CydeWeys 8y agoI think the point is more that you should be comparing far-out exurbs to closer-in suburbs of major cities. Of course property in San Francisco or NYC is going to be significantly more expensive than far-off sprawl around Houston. As they say in real estate, it's all about location, location, location. Living in the city is highly desirable for many reasons beyond just having lower transportation costs.
- ineedasername 8y agoYes, of course. But that wasn't the point being made by the article. Though even then the math doesn't always hold. I live outside of NYC. A close suburb house costs about 50% more than a mid suburb, which in turn is about 50% more than a further out suburb. That increase in housing costs for close-in is still an order of magnitude more than the decrease and money saved on transporting costs. Just look at the data table the author provides: As housing costs increase, transportation costs decrease, but the total cost of living still increases dramatically