6 ms·
Microsoft launches a drag-and-drop machine learning tool
- sgt101 8y agoBecause drag and drop ML is so new. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SPSS_Modeler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SPSS_Modeler I remember using this in NINETEEN NINETY FIVE (it was called clementine then). Interestingly one of the leads (Rob Milne) sold up (to IBM , forced sale I guess due to a cash squeeze and no investors) and went to Everest, where he got to the bottom of the Hilary step, had a massive heart attack and died. Makes ya thunk.
- hawaiianbrah 8y agoA major company launching something doesn’t mean it’s a new idea?
- alvatech 8y agoI agree. The headline didn't say that Microsoft invented drag and drop ML
- leblancfg 8y agoI was taking a look at H2O.ai's autoML dashboard yesterday, which they call Driverless AI. Broader in scope, includes an interpretability feature, and seems a little less white box-ey than what I could see from MS. Plus, great looks. Haven't tried it first-hand, but I did take a mental note. https://www.h2o.ai/products/h2o-driverless-ai/ https://www.h2o.ai/products/h2o-driverless-ai/
- kerng 8y agoNice. Microsoft has been doing some great work the last couple of years with ML - especially for beginners its great to get started with their tooling. I always like their UI and workflow parts in Azure ML. I still use their free Jupyter Notebooks service also.
- pazimzadeh 8y agoIs this related to their acquisition of Lobe? https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/13/microsoft-acquires-lobe-a-drag-and-drop-ai-tool/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/13/microsoft-acquires-lobe-a-... https://lobe.ai/ https://lobe.ai/ If not, it looks like they have parallel projects working on basically the same thing. I’ve been waiting for Microsoft to open Lobe to the public..
- ickler9 8y agoNo, it's not. And agreed, Lobe has always looked great. Hopefully there will be announcements about it at Build next week.
- ABeeSea 8y agoLooks closer to the open source R tool from revolution analytics which they acquired awhile back. Either way, node/graph based ML workflow tools aren’t new. SAS has had a pretty good one for well over a decade. Although it definitely shows its age these days.
- dlphn___xyz 8y agobut why...?
- archgoon 8y agoMachine Learning pipelines are at their core a sequence of data transformations. Having a concrete visualization of said transformations may make developing ML pipelines easier, and also allow for clearer communication between developers (and their managers, and potentially future auditors) as to what components they're working on and how they fit together. Also, by using input output blocks (as opposed to generic functions that can potentially access global state), the data dependencies of different components is made explicit, and can make tooling around that easier. (I don't know how strongly this is enforced in this implementation). Granted of course, one's mileage may vary.
- behnamoh 8y agoI wonder who their target market are. ML requires a solid math background and the ability to customize every detail of the process which drag-and-drop tools never fully provide. I understand that it's always beneficial to have more user-friendly tools, but I still think ML experts - at least those who don't just copy-paste code snippets from SO - would still prefer the more professional R and Python packages. Maybe Microsoft aims at teaching ML to beginners, which still would be detrimental if they get used to just that.
- bdod6 8y agoI had this exact same thought when I read the headline. It seems like MS and others are viewing ML as a similar opportunity to Big Data/BI ten years ago. You saw the "democratization of data" as people with little technical skills could suddenly create analytics dashboards within tools like Tableau. In my opinion, it's far too easy to make a critical mistake during design/implementation of ML to follow this same path. And what's more, if you mess up making an analytics dashboard, it's usually fairly obvious. In ML, there are MANY ways to mess up a model and you have no easy way to tell. If someone doesn't have the technical experience behind creating these models, I would not trust any output they give me from using one of these tools. And if they do have the experience, they would certainly not be choosing to use one of these tools either.
- whatshisface 8y ago>In ML, there are MANY ways to mess up a model and you have no easy way to tell. What about all those businesspeople who only hire analysts to tell them (and their peers) what they want to hear? Now they can tell themselves what they want to hear, having laundered it through a computer.
- streetcat1 8y agoCan you please elaborate more on what kind of critical mistakes a machine can make, while someone with math background would not make. I am building a competing tool, so I am not affiliate with MS, but I do think that auto ML has value. Machine learning is different from imperative programming in such that most of the "programming" is done by experiments and not with actual "program", hence there is an opportunity to replace programming with compute. I.e. an automl platform can create 100's of models/pipelines and just try them all. Also, why would you trust a model which was created manually and not a model which was auto created. When a model is created in auto ML it pass the same validation process as manually created model, so in both cases the quality of the model should be judged independent from the way that it was created. In addition, all models (regardless of how they were created - human / not human), should be monitored for predictive performance. I.e. I will not "trust" any model without continuous verification.
- dlkf 8y agoHow many people are there that satisfy both of the following criteria: 1. They want to build, train, and deploy a machine learning model into production. Presumably as a microservice, part of a web application, etc 2. They don't know how to program I honestly can't imagine a less useful product than drag and drop ML.
- vonnik 8y agoYears ago, someone said something about what we were building that I've never forgotten: "Anyone smart enough to use this isn't dumb enough to need it." Those were the words that come to my mind everytime I see stuff like this. Clickers want solutions, not complicated toolkits in a GUI.
- darkerside 8y agoExcel has proven there's a market for tricking people into designing complex technical systems without realizing that they are programming a computer.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago'tricking'. Such typical tech guy condescension. Excel provides a ramp all the way from "put numbers in boxes" through complicated multidimensional calculations to... well game development if you're crazy enough. It's a good tool for the tasks it was designed for, and it can be used by people of all skill levels.
- darkerside 8y agoHeh. Didn't mean to condescend. I do think many powerful Excel users don't think they are programming, so I stand by my statement.
- archgoon 8y agoThere was a post yesterday about how it is desirable for Fortran to be preserved as opposed to porting Fortran code to C++, because scientists want to focus on expressing the science and math, not on the low level details of passing arrays around and performing safe array access (which Fortran compilers are more strict about and will emit errors for). I haven't used this tool, but it seems reasonable that the people who it might be useful for (regardless if Microsoft PR recognizes this or not) are for scientists who have an idea for an algorithm, but don't want to spend too much time thinking about how to write and deploy python/C++ code to their clusters. Sure, it may not seem like that much effort to many programmers, but as the Fortran discussion stressed, just because you can code and think logically, doesn't mean you're a programmer.
- calewis 8y ago“No-code” = snake oil
- dessant 8y agoIs downloading the trained model for offline use possible?
- simmers 8y agoThat iris data set is perhaps the most prolific data in the world.
- blackflame7000 8y agoThe problem with this approach is that so much of machine learning is dependent on the datasets you choose to give it. If people need their hand held through setting up a basic Neural Network, I foresee a lot of garbage in garbage out
- marshray 8y agoThis sentiment gets expressed every time programming is made more accessible. It always turns out that the difficulty of "setting up a basic [hello world application]" is entirely unrelated to the essential complexity of the problem space and attracting a broader range of new users is later viewed as a valuable advance.
- king_magic 8y agoYeah, but... the sentiment exists for a reason. Look, I’m all for growing programming talent, but I’ll leave the toy visual/drag and drop interfaces to those who are interested in using them to build intuition (absolutely nothing wrong with that). But beyond that, I’m going to use the grown up tools to build real things (and get paid for doing so).
- marshray 8y agoUse whatever works for you. That's the point. I'm a fan of plain text and source control myself.
- blackflame7000 8y agoWell for example if people don't understand the difference between continuous, discrete, and unrelated values then they will have major flaws. For example, say they are trying to build a NN to predict customer orders by geographic area. If they treat zip codes as continuous or discrete values they're going to get really strange results because ML is ultimately just interpolation/extrapolation. Idk how well drag and drop can convey those principles
- 8y ago
- ungzd 8y agoNothing shocking. GUI for machine learning existed for decades, for example Weka and Rapidminer. I don't see "drag and drop" in screenshots, however; it's just awful gadget journalism lingo, common for this site with reviews of gaming mouses. ETL-style dataflow pipelines are more natural for such tasks than imperative programming, it's not just "for people who can't code". Rapidminer is dataflow-based too. Actual links, if you want to avoid gadget news website: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/machine-learning/service/how-to-create-portal-experiments https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/machine-learning/serv... https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/machine-learning/service/concept-automated-ml https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/machine-learning/serv...
- scottlocklin 8y agoYann LeCun and Leon Bottou had one of these in Lush ... I think back in the 80s. It's still in there!
- streetcat1 8y agoThe techcrunch headline is misleading. The drag and drop is the OLD version. What is new is the automl capabilities. In general the holy grail is an autonomous ML system. with no input from the user but a data set schema.
- stratosgear 8y agoMice!
- cwyers 8y agoSo, I clicked on the link to understand how this was different than their existing drag-and-drop machine learning tool, and... > This tool, the Azure Machine Learning visual interface, looks suspiciously like the existing Azure ML Studio, Microsoft’s first stab at building a visual machine learning tool. Indeed, the two services look identical. The company never really pushed this service, though, and almost seemed to have forgotten about it despite the fact that it always seemed like a really useful tool for getting started with machine learning. > Microsoft says this new version combines the best of Azure ML Studio with the Azure Machine Learning service. In practice, this means that while the interface is almost identical, the Azure Machine Learning visual interface extends what was possible with ML Studio by running on top of the Azure Machine Learning service and adding that services’ security, deployment and life cycle management capabilities. The answer is "not much."
- hestefisk 8y agoImagine the auto ML built into Excel. Now that would be awesome.
- hestefisk 8y agoBy the way, I can see a massive adoption of this in consulting. Often we develop ‘quick and dirty’ model to test variables or do a high level regression / predictive model. Having this without the need for Python code is extremely useful, especially when you work in short term, high burn projects and just need an 80/20 answer.
- siliconc0w 8y agoI think an ideal generalized ML service is more like - you give it a CSV and then add another row with missing column(s) and it guesses what should be in those column(s) along with some human readable explanation of how it got there.
- cbHXBY1D 8y agoAzure Machine Learning actually does this: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/machine-learning/service/how-to-transform-data https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/machine-learning/serv...
- visarga 8y agoSo it's like Scratch for ML? You 'draw' a program with a unwieldy graphical interface, and when it inevitably becomes a visual mess of complexity what can you do?