8 ms·
I didn't "get" PDF's until I started doing academic research. But the ability to collect papers, books, documents, etc. all in a single format that I can read
by crazygringo 8y ago
I didn't "get" PDF's until I started doing academic research.
But the ability to collect papers, books, documents, etc. all in a single format that I can read on any device, and mark up with highlights and notes, has been a game-changer.
Yes it's a lowest-common-denominator format. And it's designed for human reading and manual office tasks, not computer processing of data. But it works. And it's supported everywhere.
Doesn't matter if I'm on the Apple or Google or Microsoft or Adobe stack. Doesn't matter if the PDF is 20 years old. It just works.
- whenchamenia 8y agoExcept for many, it doesen't. Why glorify a closed format that we spent decades trying to aviod just because its common now? The inherent issues persist.
- boshomi 8y agosince ISO 32000-2 there is no proprietary technology included[1] [1] https://www.iso.org/standard/63534.html https://www.iso.org/standard/63534.html
- throwaway2048 8y agoNot all PDFs are standards compliant, plenty are filled with acrobat only JS, embedded flash and form filling crap.
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoAs e.g. the fine men and women of Int. J. POC||GTFO have demonstrated, it's possible to embed all sorts of weird and wonderful things in a PDF. I think a format where it's possible to include as much as possible is better. Just look at HTML. Would you rather have it be impossible to extend beyond text, images and stylesheets?
- na85 8y agoI would. The modern web is a rich-get-richer hellscape of surveillance and advertising.
- jimjimjim 8y agohtml can include acrobat only JS and embedded flash and form filling crap.
- icxa 8y agoForm filling is part of the standard, specifically, the process of applying an XFDF to a PDF, which even allows you to do things like present a remote web form and then inject the data into the PDF.
- starsinspace 8y agoPDF has been released as an open standard since 2008.
- thro_away_n 8y ago198 CHF to obtain ISO 32000-2:2017 from ISO, however.
- Arkanosis 8y agoThat's the same price as C++ (ISO/IEC 14882:2017) and much cheaper than the entire languages codes standard (ISO 639-1:2002, ISO 639-2:1998, ISO 639-3:2007, ISO 639-4:2010 and ISO 639-5:2008). I get your point, though.
- nikofeyn 8y agoit would be much better if the djvu format, wholly superior to pdf for large files, wasn't locked behind a license.
- jonathanyc 8y agoPDF has extremely developed vector graphics support as well as adequate compressed image support (e.g. you can compress using a bunch of methods as good as what DJVU uses for your purpose, including PNG and JPEG2000.) AFAIK DJVU is a much simpler format primarily for scanned images, not vector graphics (which includes LaTeX-generated documents, mind you.) Could anyone with more knowledge about DJVU comment?
- jwilk 8y agoYes, DjVu has raster images under the hood.
- jwilk 8y agoWhat do you mean by "locked behind a license"?
- hcs 8y agoThere are a few patents involved: http://djvu.sourceforge.net/licensing.html http://djvu.sourceforge.net/licensing.html
- mikeash 8y agoI wish it really Just Worked everywhere. Unfortunately, the fixed layout and tendency to target 8.5x11 means they’re basically unreadable on smaller screens.
- jlarocco 8y agoThat's true, but not unique to PDF. Any longer document is "basically unreadable on smaller screens".
- mikeash 8y agoNo way. A Kindle is great for reading books, but text in a typical PDF is too small to read. Reading on a phone is a bit more annoying but totally reasonable with dynamic text layout.
- _emacsomancer_ 8y agoKoreader[0] can be sideloaded on Kindles, Kobos and other devices, and is good at making PDFs readable on such devices. [0] http://koreader.rocks/ http://koreader.rocks/
- mikeash 8y agoThanks, I’ll have to check this out.
- mwfunk 8y agoSadly PDFs are usually just a series of graphics instructions for drawing stuff (including text) at specific sizes and positions, on a page with a defined size. It's an inherently hostile format for reflowing text, although I think some PDF viewers can do that to an extent. The PDF accessibility spec defines an optional, more DOM-like document structure that a compliant viewer could use to reflow text, but in my experience even the apps that produce that structure don't populate it with enough data to make reflowing reliable or easy to implement. Pretty much every format is way better for reflowing text than PDF (Kindle, ePub, HTML, etc.).
- diffeomorphism 8y ago> and mark up with highlights and notes, has been a game-changer. What are you using for that? In my experience annotation support is very spotty, not user-friendly and not cross-platform, so I rarely use it for collaboration. Even fill-in forms one gets for reimbursements often seem badly done with too small or too large boxes or missing boxes. Thus, pdf seems fine for read-only, but making changes afterwards is not a good experience.
- arcticbull 8y agoSome features, not all of them. Forms in particular are poorly supported in the Apple stack, and specifically, it can't generate QR codes from form fields in documents like Reader can. Fonts are usually inconsistent and wrong in forms. Letter spacing is all wrong. I'm sure there's tons of other things missing, the spec is ginormous and includes it's own version of JavaScript that's similar to -- but not quite -- ECMA which is a huge attack vector [0]. For instance, check out the Canadian passport simplified renewal form [1]. The upper-right corner on the first page is "$FORM$054(06-2018)$V$1.4$CS$0$C$0" on the Apple stack and a proper QR code which changes as you fill in the application in Reader. The big blue "Read Instructions" buttons don't work on the Apple stack either. It may be important, but it's a waking nightmare of a spec. [0] http://mariomalwareanalysis.blogspot.com/2012/02/how-to-embed-javascript-into-pdf.html http://mariomalwareanalysis.blogspot.com/2012/02/how-to-embe... [1] https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/ircc/migration/ircc/english/passport/forms/pdf/pptc054.pdf https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/ircc/migration/ircc/englis...
- sfkdjf9j3j 8y agoNot that you're wrong about the PDF spec being monstrously complex and not universally supported, but why would someone want to generate a QR code from form fields? Who actually wants to use QR codes?
- dd36 8y agoA machine that scans forms.
- arcticbull 8y agoHaha, fair, that was just the first painpoint that sprung to mind. They're fairly common on visa and passport applications, and some other government forms. I guess if you're accepting paper submissions for whatever reason not having to transcribe the contents is a big win.
- gibolt 8y agoAnyone in Asia, they are hugely popular and super useful. Adding friends on WeChat, making payments to vendors, getting discounts, installing an app, etc
- burtonator 8y agoYou guys might like this project I've been working on for the last six months: https://getpolarized.io/ https://getpolarized.io/ It helps you manage your reading by keeping all your PDFs and web content in one place. It's open source, cross platform (Linux, Mac, Windows, + web) and free. The main issue I have to focus on right now is explaining why it's so powerful. I'm going to create a video here shortly. Basically , it supports suspend and resume of reading, text and area highlights, and spaced repetition via Anki. I'm working on a big new release here shortly and also applying for grants over the next few weeks. Also, one thing, it's mostly a geek tool and I'm still working on fit and finish and usability. If it's awesome please let me know. If something is broken, please ALSO let me know - I'll fix it!
- blairbeckwith 8y agoMan, this is so annoying.
- mbreese 8y agoIn what way? It seems interesting to me.
- mkl 8y agoYes, it's neat and interesting, but burtonator posts basically the same comment in almost every thread about PDFs, academic papers, etc.
- Sabinus 8y agoHe's not spamming, he made it himself, and I could really see it helping people.
- llao 8y agoThen why would they hijack the top comment about widespread PDF support instead of making a separate top-level post when the whole submission is about PDF?
- 8y ago
- 3xblah 8y agoI could say all the same things about text files or JPGs. PDF is not the "lowest common denominator". That would be the format that can be most easily converted to other formats. With text and images, I can easily create PDFs and documents in myriad other formats. Alas, PDFs do not convert as easily to other formats. To this day, no one has a PDF-to-text converter that is 100% reliable in preserving the proper line lengths. Not even a company with Google's resources.
- swiley 8y agoHTML (sans javscript) would have been so much nicer though. All of the machine readable structure and separation of style from content would have been just absolutely wonderful. But we'll never have that (not in the sense we have PDF.) Either it's an image or an application, no one really understands how to handle anything in between.
- aabbcc1241 8y agoAnd you can get better accessibility with html: reflow, adjust font size, adjust color, e.t.c. I only found a few PDF reader can display the content well on the mobile phone, but still worse experience when compare to the web.
- rowanG077 8y agoDoesn't HTML also provide this feature? While being vastly more powerful and the only downside it cannot be printed accurately?