3 ms·
> This doesn't get mentioned often enough when talking about the "1-percenters" and the wealth gap in Western countries, i.e. that most of the capital behind al
by WorldMaker 8y ago
> This doesn't get mentioned often enough when talking about the "1-percenters" and the wealth gap in Western countries, i.e. that most of the capital behind all of the current economic and social system is directly or indirectly held by part of the general populace itself.
I think the keyword there is indirectly. It's still easy to blame the 1-percenters for the proportional lion's share of the blame when the majority of the general populace's influence/control over their investments is intentionally gatekeeped and/or obfuscated by "professional finance" people, many of whom are 1-percenters or wish-they-were.
In the case of legitimate pensions that is top-to-bottom controlled by finance people with almost zero control from the average pension.
In the case of the modern faux-pension, the 401k, while most individuals could take direct control of how they invest those funds, and that's supposedly a feature, very few actually do/will, because the game is rigged (401k providers have a lot of vested interests in promoting their investment products where they make the most fees) and also a full time job that the 401k "owner" doesn't need on top of their existing job that pays into the 401k in the first place (again, giving the 401k providers the benefit of defaulting people their investment products with the most fees).
Even further, the push to "personal responsibility" to the individual in a 401k system also removes a lot of power of the general populace to collectively bargain as investment holders. Under the regime of traditional pension systems a lot of hedge funds were checked by pension managers when employee/pensioner interest was kept in mind (especially in the cases where pensions were managed by Unions rather than employers or outsourced to professional finance firms; there's a good history of hedge funds versus Unions on the books some of which used to stop leverage buyouts).
> And the real numbers tell the story of a society divided in two, a part that will manage to enjoy its pension and the other part that has no clue how will pay for its old age.
Even when federally mandated pensions existed there was always an interesting line between pension-earning work and the rest. It's not an entirely new worry, it's just continuing to get a lot worse.
Even worse is how much the breakdown of the earned pension system to the "privatized" 401k system is creating a weird muddy ground in between the extremes of people that sort of have retirement investments, but no longer have collective bargaining power, often have more middlemen eating their share of the pie, and everything is much more of a gamble.
- sokoloff 8y ago> the 401k...is also a full time job that the 401k "owner" doesn't need on top of their existing job that pays into the 401k in the first place Really? I can't imagine how to spend 20 hours per year on 401(k) related topics, let alone 40 hours per week on it. If you're under 40, buy a broad-based stock fund and forget about it. (Probably true if you're under 50.) Use the 40K hours you save by not having this extra "full time job" however you like.
- dingaling 8y ago> buy a broad-based stock fund and forget about it The stock fund is a product designed by a third-party to make money for them, which was the poster's point about you not being in control of your pension in that case.
- sokoloff 8y agoIn my 401K, I have access to FXAIX (broad-based, S&P 500 fund), for which I pay 1.5 bpp of fees (0.00015 of AUM). If I had a million dollars in my 401(k)'s FXAIX (I don't of course), that would come to $150 in fund fees annually. If I wanted exposure to a broader index of mid-cap stocks, I have FSMAX (Fidelity Extended Market Index), at 4.5bpp (0.00045 of AUM). $1MM in that fund would cost me $450 annually. As I get closer to retirement, Vanguard's Total Bond Market (VBTLX) is available at 5bpp (0.0005 or $500/year for the notional 401K millionaire). It's true that mutual funds pay the managers of those funds, but you don't have to pick the 50 or 100 bpp funds. On average, it's unlikely that population of 401K investors will outperform the population of professional money managers before fees. Not that many people have a 7 figure 401K account. Not all 401Ks allow individual share investments. There's a pretty limited upside to spending even 100 additional hours on 401K investing in an attempt to beat the pros out of their $150-500 in fees.
- WorldMaker 8y agoBut circling back to the point from above in the conversation: a broad index fund is still delegating moral authority to the index. How do you lodge a complaint with any company in that index? Do you have any power to voice an opinion against a leveraged buyout? You are not a shareholder of that company, you are a shareholder in an index fund that holds that company. You've delegated whatever possible votes you may have to Fidelity or Vanguard. Do they really have your moral and ethical priorities at heart? Can they?