4 ms·
High-deductible health plans were always designed to benefit employers. My company switched us to one with a big PR campaign highlighting how everything would b
by paxys 8y ago
High-deductible health plans were always designed to benefit employers. My company switched us to one with a big PR campaign highlighting how everything would be better (contributions to HSA - free money!). The only "advantage" is that companies have to pay smaller premiums and employees are greatly discouraged from getting care due to high costs.
Funny enough, employers are rethinking this now since employees not getting basic preventive care is actually more expensive for them in the long run - https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2018/06/26/493273.htm https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2018/06/26/49....
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoIf you spend a lot on healthcare (i.e. have a family) then a HSA works fine since you hit your maximums really quick and then only pay some small % of the sticker price after that. For everyone who isn't gonna spend a few grand in healthcare every year it totally sucks and is a massive incentive not to have routine care done.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThat doesn’t make sense. If you spend a lot on healthcare, then why would you want to spend it out of pocket from HSA instead of letting insurer pick it up with a non HDHP?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoYou only spend out of pocket until the various out of pocket limits kick in.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThere is only one out of pocket limit: https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/out-of-pocket-maximum-limit/ https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/out-of-pocket-maximum-li... Healthcare costs whatever it costs, no matter what the premium / deductible is. The more of it that is used, the more someone has to pay, and you can be sure the insurance company is going to adjust the premiums or deductible or coinsurance/copay to make sure it's not them (in the long run). The HSA/HDHP option just lets you gamble that you won't need enough medical care in the year to offset the investment and tax gains of contributing to an HSA. And if you're lucky, you'll make it all the way to Medicare eligibility. Although I'm pretty sure we'll see Medicare start being means tested in the next decade.
- maxxxxx 8y agoTotally agree. All “innovations” like HSA and 401k are designed to make life easier for employers but are sold as benefit for employees.
- lotsofpulp 8y ago401k are tied to employers, but I don’t see what HSA has to do with employers since they’re just as easy to have without an employer. It’s just a savings account with tax advantages for people with HDHP.
- maxxxxx 8y agoare you saying that if your employer offers a high deductible plan without HSA you can open one for yourself? I don’t think many people know that.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoYes. https://www.fidelity.com/open-account/all-accounts https://www.fidelity.com/open-account/all-accounts (best option, it's free and has access to great investment options) https://healthaccounts.bankofamerica.com/individuals-families.shtml https://healthaccounts.bankofamerica.com/individuals-familie... I'm sure there are others. Edit: In fact, the employer's HSA custodian (unless it's Fidelity), probably charges you a few basis points for investing your HSA funds, so it's actually much better for you to transfer the funds out into your own Fidelity HSA immediately.
- maxxxxx 8y agoGood to know!
- golover721 8y agoYes however it is definitely a way for employers to save a bunch of money while convincing employees that they are better off too. The whole smokescreen of we will give you a bunch of money "for free!" that goes to your HSA and somehow that is better value for you than a traditional PPO. In much the same way that 401k contributions are better than a pension.
- rb808 8y agoObamacare also added an extra tax on the best health insurance. The problem when no one has to pay anything is that people don't care about price. > an annual 40% excise tax on plans with annual premiums exceeding $10,800 for individuals or $29,500 for a family starting in 2020 (delayed further) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cadillac_insurance_plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cadillac_insurance_plan
- tptacek 8y agoThis has nothing to do with HDHPs. (Additionally: the tax was delayed to 2022).
- smacktoward 8y ago> The problem when no one has to pay anything is that people don't care about price. And yet somehow the U.S., where we expect people to pay for their health care, spends twice as much per capita on health care as the average industrialized country: https://www.pgpf.org/chart-archive/0006_health-care-oecd https://www.pgpf.org/chart-archive/0006_health-care-oecd
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The only "advantage" is that companies have to pay smaller premiums and employees are greatly discouraged from getting care due to high costs. In principle the advantage is that employees are greatly discouraged from paying too much for care. If the insurance pays for everything then what do you care if your doctor is charging $1000 for a physical instead of $50? If you're paying out of pocket, now you care. The problem is we also have a lack of price transparency, so it's arduous to actually determine the price you'll be charged for routine care and avoid the places who are overcharging, which correspondingly becomes nearly everyone. The states would do everyone a favor to pass and enforce some price transparency laws. And the advantage of lower premiums is that it allows you to receive that money. If your employer is raising your plan's deductible and giving the balance saved in premiums to you, that's the advantage -- you get the money. If they're not, go ask for a raise or find another employer who will pay you more, in the same way you would if they lowered your compensation in any other way.
- kristjansson 8y ago> price transparency And even list prices themselves are typically starting points for negotiations when a provider is dealing with a large payor whereas an unwell individual (y'know, one who is about to spend a lot of money on healthcare) is not in a great position to bargain with her caregivers, and so is forced to negotiate after the fact, from an artificially inflated starting point, under the guise of bill reduction, or worse, debt relief.
- WorldMaker 8y agoA lot of the issues with pushing price negotiation to the individual also seem to be assuming (or worse, lying about) that most medical professionals, procedures, facilities, et al are entirely fungible. Even if individuals had full price transparency, that doesn't change the fact that certain facilities will always be closer to home, certain procedures inescapable, certain medical professionals decades or life-long relationships to build, etc. Medical services aren't just interchangeable factory goods on a retail store shelf that you can easily pick based on price alone and then slot it right into its widget shaped hole, and never will be.
- vagab0nd 8y agoRegardless of whether it benefits employers, it makes sense for healthy young people, no? If your health care spending is low, you get free money every paycheck. Also last time I looked at my HSA account, it's both pre-tax contribution and tax-free growth. So you get double tax break.