3 ms·
On the other hand many countries have successfully introduced recycling and pollution reduction measures currently and in the past. Germany's attempts to move t
by simonh 8y ago
On the other hand many countries have successfully introduced recycling and pollution reduction measures currently and in the past. Germany's attempts to move to renewable power have largely failed, but it does show large scale economic measures are possible. France demonstrates that a switch to nuclear, if others choose to go that route, is viable. There are ongoing efforts to reduce the use of plastics, particularly in it's forms most likely to result in pollution. Our switch to electric vehicles is well under way.
We are still screwed, I'll give you that, but the degree to which we are screwed and how fast is something we can influence, and that does matter.
- fao_ 8y agoRight, and these are state-backed efforts. But these efforts mean literally next to nothing if companies like Amazon, Microsoft, etc. do not get off their asses and do something. The biggest cause of climate change is not something that state actors can do anything about unless they are willing to enact and enforce strict, massive, unprecendented restrictions on coal, gas, and oil companies. Something that no government outside of the top ten richest countries in Europe, is willing to do. Currently Amazon, the richest company in the tech sector, is dedicated to putting only 6% of it's datacenters on renewable power. By 2020. It also services a couple of hundred coal, oil, and gas companies that are deeply harmful to the environment. See, this public letter, which has not been acted on: https://medium.com/@amazonemployeesclimatejustice/public-letter-to-jeff-bezos-and-the-amazon-board-of-directors-82a8405f5e38 https://medium.com/@amazonemployeesclimatejustice/public-let... [Amazon] recently ordered 20,000 diesel vans whose emissions will need to be offset with carbon credits [13]. Offsets can entail forest management policies that displace Indigenous communities, and they do nothing to reduce our diesel pollution which disproportionately harms communities of color and [Amazon] donated to 68 members of congress in 2018 who voted against climate legislation 100% of the time [20,21]. and [Amazon has] set a goal of at least 50 solar installations in warehouse facilities by 2020. This represents only 6% of buildings in [it's] global fulfillment network and a fraction of our overall carbon footprint [22].
- freeflight 8y ago> Germany's attempts to move to renewable power have largely failed, but it does show large scale economic measures are possible. I keep reading this, yet nobody bothers to actually explain how it supposedly failed? > France demonstrates that a switch to nuclear, if others choose to go that route, is viable. France didn't "switch" to nuclear, in the 70s they spent $330 billion of public money to build their nuclear fleet. Since then the reactor fleet has been aging, due to a lack of private investments, and a lack of funds for decommissioning is also a very real problem, not just for France [0] but across to the EU [1]. Which is one of the reasons why France is also considering to phase out nuclear reactors, at least in part [2]. [0] https://www.powerengineeringint.com/articles/2016/04/france-underestimating-costs-of-nuclear-decommissioning.html https://www.powerengineeringint.com/articles/2016/04/france-... [1] https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-europe-nuclear/eu-short-of-118-billion-euros-in-nuclear-decommissioning-funds-draft-idUKKCN0VP2KN https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-europe-nuclear/eu-short-of... [2] https://www.france24.com/en/20170710-france-hulot-could-close-nuclear-plants https://www.france24.com/en/20170710-france-hulot-could-clos...
- simonh 8y agoThe problem in Germany is that energy costs have spiralled out of control. They have greatly expanded renewable energy sources, but have not been able to decommission a lot of fossil fuel plants because they still need them to serve peak demand at times when renewable sources are not on-line. However lack of investment in fossil plants, which they hoped to decommission, means they are ageing and prone to outages. It's only buying nuclear power from France to plug the gaps that's keeping them operational. It's unfortunate, but such mistakes are far from inevitable in the policies of other countries. The will was there, but hard lessons had to be learned. Yes France's nuclear power is going to be expensive long term, but French per capita greenhouse gas emissions are incredibly low. About 2/3 of the EU average and a bit over a quarter of the US. Factor in any kind of reasonable carbon tax cost, then combine it with an increased contribution from renewable, and French nuclear starts to look quite viable.
- _ph_ 8y agoEnergy costs in Germany haven't spiralled "out of control". Yes, electricity is quite expensive for private and small business customers, but that is, because large industry does not bear any of the transitioning costs. The coal plants are kept operating, because it is profitable to the power companies and so far no one has stopped them. This has somewhat improved in 2018. There are no "power outages" because of lacking energy supply. Equally wrong (but often told by certain people) is the story of French nuclear power supporting the grid. It is actually the opposite, when for example in warm summers German solar power delivers critical support to the French grid. Due to the lack of cooling water, nuclear energy often is challenged to match the requirements. On top of that, Germany is a net exporter of electricity (mostly due to the too high coal production, but that hopefully stops soon).
- _ph_ 8y agoSorry, but what makes you claim that Germany's attempts have "failed"? We have a strong growth in reneweable energy production, over 40% of all electricity produced was reneweable. The total of 2019 is 45% so far. All of this in the presence of obvious coal protectionism. If anything, all of this is encouragement to push harder for a quicker transition.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoParent is right though, these things could have been done decades ago and are only being done now because it is relatively convenient. On the whole, people seem unwilling to make any significant sacrifice for the sake of our future. As a result we will suffer catastrophically as a species. If we're lucky, we will learn from it and in the far future we'll be able to progress while avoiding such shortsightedness.