8 ms·
I'm continuously surprised how we're not in full-on panic mode because of climate change.
by adrianN 8y ago
I'm continuously surprised how we're not in full-on panic mode because of climate change.
- mirimir 8y agoA common response to "full-on panic mode" is denial. Especially when it all seems inevitable. As this arguably is.
- fsloth 8y agoWe're fully dependent on hydrocarbons and no one has any idea how to replace those in any foreseeable future. https://www.ft.com/content/73650984-135a-11e9-a168-d45595ad076d https://www.ft.com/content/73650984-135a-11e9-a168-d45595ad0... "...renewables (including biofuels, waste and hydro) are responsible for almost the same share of energy today (14 per cent) as supplied in 1971 " We can shave of percentages by stopping eating meat and so on but fossil fuels are still the major culprit in carbon emissions. From economical point of view it's catastrophe today (just stopping using fossil fuels cold turkey will destroy the economic structure of our civilization) versus catastrophe tomorrow.
- adrianN 8y agoThe first official warning by an expert panel to the US President was 1965. We did pretty much nothing since then to reduce our dependency on fossil fuel. We could have for example switched all electricity generation to nuclear with 1965 technology and changed building standards to require proper insulation and electric or district heating. That would have bought a lot of time that we don't have now. We could also have instituted a carbon tax and slowly (over the course of the last fifty years or so!) pinned it to the cost of extracting carbon from the atmosphere.
- ahje 8y agoCoulda, woulda, shoulda. We're here now, we can't change the past, and blaming previous generations is a waste of time when we need to act now. Most of us know what to do. We just need to start doing it.
- adrianN 8y agoWhat do we need to do? I don't see how we can reduce carbon emissions by 18% per year for the next ten years. Right now we don't even get the second derivative right, emission rates are still on the rise. It doesn't really look like our politicians worldwide will start an effort comparable to ramping up the WW2 war industry to decarbonize the economy in the next decade. On the contrary, conservative climate denialists are on the rise. https://mobile.twitter.com/rahmstorf/status/1070717050430070787 https://mobile.twitter.com/rahmstorf/status/1070717050430070...
- ahje 8y agoWhat we can do is to skip unnecessary travel, use public transport whenever we can, stop buying fairly useless consumer products for our own leisure, and the most important ones: realise that reducing our collective carbon footprint will result in considerable reductions of one's individual standard of living. We, as individual consumers, need to reduce the carbon emissions ourselves as much as possible no matter what the politicians say. Deniers are going to be a problem until shit hits the fan for real, and waiting until everyone is convinced will simply be a waste of time. So, in other words, focus less on what others do, more on what you do, and make sure to prepare as much as you can for whatever the future holds. Not saying everyone should become a prepper (although it's a fun hobby!), but the fact that people blindly believe that the future is a straight line is scarier, regardless of where they believe that line is pointing.
- mattmanser 8y agoSpitting in an empty swimming pool to try and fill it? It's a governmental problem, not an individual one, only way it's going to change is if you start campaigning and voting differently.
- ahje 8y agoI am. I doubt anything but direct action will have an effect though.
- 8y ago
- rebuilder 8y agoCatastrophe today vs. extinction tomorrow, I fear.
- jacobush 8y agoExtinction won't happen. 99.99% could die and that would leave seven million people.
- glaurung_ 8y ago7 000 000 000 * .01% = 700 000 Still, you make a very good point. Homo Sapiens will stick around. Advanced civilization might not.
- username223 8y agoThat's the endgame I expect: climate refugees leading to (possibly nuclear) war. With a much smaller human population (and perhaps a bit of nuclear winter), atmospheric CO2 will return to pre-industrial levels, and things will return to normal in a couple millennia. The remaining humans will migrate down from Alaska and Siberia, and build new cities on top of the ruins. Climate change is a "solved" problem, but the solution isn't something I would want to live through.
- devereaux 8y ago> Climate change is a "solved" problem, but the solution isn't something I would want to live through. The good news is, unless you are part of the lucky 0.01%, you won't have to live through it!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- username223 8y agoIt's still a wretched way to die. Most of us posting here will die of old age before things really get ugly. It's our children or grandchildren who will suffer.
- fit2rule 8y agoSwitch to electric transportation as quickly as possible. Change your mind about needing a personal automobile, and share it with as many people as possible. Use public transportation if you have it, and insist in your community investing in public transportation systems if you don't.
- mises 8y agoWhat of cities, like Houston, which are too spread out and flood too often for good mass transit?
- fit2rule 8y agoIt'll be up to the good citizens of Houston to work out how to solve this problem. I imagine electric transportation would still work there. But, I do also think that a lot of American cities are going to have to work out how they're going to stay inhabitable without requiring a massive refactoring of their landscapes.
- fulafel 8y ago> From economical point of view it's catastrophe today (just stopping using fossil fuels cold turkey will destroy the economic structure of our civilization) versus catastrophe tomorrow. I think this is a false dichotomy, and so do many economists [1]. We can start phasing out out the non-essential use of fossils and come up with replacements for the remainign parts in the coming decades. Painting it as this kind of desperate dichotomy is generally playing into the hands those who don't want us to address climate change. Remember that the changes aren't only chilling on the economy - the energy overhaul is an enormous global public works project. We are using energy and energy-intensive products in really wasteful ways because of their low cost in our everyday lives (consider oversized cars and low occupancy, available savings from turning heating & cooling to lower levels, going veggie in food, cutting air travel, not to mention all the wasted energy in commercial/industrial side due to low energy costs). [1] See eg https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/19/opinion/paul-krugman-could-fighting-global-warming-be-cheap-and-free.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/19/opinion/paul-krugman-coul...
- fsloth 8y agoSure, you are quite right. I think the biggest hurdle is that the incumbent investments in hydrocarbons have quite a lot of future profits to tied up to continued usage of said resources. The negative externalities of hydrocarbon eceonomy should be tied more forcefully directly to their usage. But even that would not discourage investors from doing all they can to keep up the demand for oil.
- gambiting 8y agoI think it's 100% because the changes are so slow(in human terms). Vast majority of people don't yet see anything that would make them go into this full-on panic mode, so....they don't. Yeah the permafrost is melting, but I have bills to pay this month. What am I going to do? Go and protest all day? What is my kid going to eat in the meantime? And I think this slowness of reaction is also what will make any sort of solution extremely difficult to implement - people will complain that they are feeling the impact of any solution right now(like, if plastics were banned tomorrow), while the climate won't improve for a long time - even if we stopped our emissions entirely the climate would keep getting worse for decades until any meaningful improvement would be observed.
- circlefavshape 8y agoI'm in full-on panic mode, but ... well, what can I do that I haven't been doing for 20 years? Nothing, as far as I can see
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoMake inaction too expensive to contemplate by causing enough ongoing civil disruption. https://rebellion.earth/ https://rebellion.earth/
- altitudinous 8y agoCivil disruption just highlights the problem over and over. We all know there is a problem. Absolutely no-one denies it. Rather than stating the problem over and over - what is YOUR solution? Renewables are not efficient enough to replace coal - if we switch off coal then we equally destroy civilisation and economies just like climate change because renewables are far more expensive and not as efficient as coal. We would effectively be turning off all electricity. I propose nuclear and pumping money at electric cars because they are solutions that you can pump at a government and are efficient, and bring major change quickly! Protest about that, don't pretend we don't know about climate change - we all do!!! I've come up with some - WHAT IS YOUR ACTIONABLE SOLUTION??!!
- weavie 8y agoI would question your assertion that we all know there is a problem. I imagine the vast majority of people don't. They may be vaguely aware of climate change, but most people just think surely it can't be serious and it'll be ok, we'll work it out when it does become a problem. Just the other day the UK courts have dismissed any attempt at blocking an extra runway at Heathrow airport. We need this runway to increase the number of flights out of the UK. Good for the economy etc.. If that isn't a symptom of the vast majority of people being in complete denial I don't know what is. Actionable solution no. 1.. don't build more runways.
- NeedMoreTea 8y ago
- mongol 8y agoWhat would we do if we were in full-on panic mode?
- crispinb 8y agoRebel.
- tomjen3 8y agoUndeniably something stupid.
- adrianN 8y agoSpend double digit percentages of our annual budget on decarbonizing the economy. Have for example a look at how much the Iraq war cost over seven years and imagine how many batteries and solar panels could have been build with that money and how many homes could have gotten improved insulation. And that was really just a minor blip compared to the efforts that went into WW2.
- dls2016 8y agoI'm not. This article is a perfect example of how the overall climate change narrative is one of averages (9F temperature increase by 2100) but the impacts are "spiky" (localized in time and space, much greater magnitude than the popular narrative). People are really bad at rectifying these two concepts. See also: structural racism/white privilege doesn't exist, because I have experienced bad things X, Y and Z.
- _pmf_ 8y agoCountries like the Maledives invest in land; that's a sensible thing to do that will save existences. What's not sensible to do is restrict fossil fuels in Europe wile China is still ramping up; it's symbolism that does not help a single person.
- adrianN 8y agoEvery ton of carbon counts. Every Euro invested in carbon neutral alternatives makes it cheaper for poorer countries to switch. A EU wide carbon tax that is also applied to imports would perhaps also sway China into putting more effort into reducing their emissions.
- jnurmine 8y agoThere is a benefit in starting to restrict fossil fuels early. It has to be done at some point anyway because the backing resource is limited and contributes to the human-hostile terraforming of our planet. Continuing with burning coal and oil is simply a losing proposition. Also, while defossilizing the industry base, it makes sense to enhance, increase and automate local factories to make it viable to produce things locally and not half a world away. Add a functional and effective system for recycling materials to use for new production, etc. and the long term trend is clear: China's role as the production hub of the world will diminish dramatically. From this perspective I do not understand why China does not seem to be racing like mad to restrict fossil fuels.
- altitudinous 8y agoBecause panic does not bring about solutions. Nobody is disagreeing that there is an issue. Nobody. I believe there are a number of people pointing out the problem, over and over, civil disobedience etc, but there is nobody pointing out a viable solution. I believe that is why nobody responds to civil disobedience. I think if people came up with a viable solution we would be all over it. Technological change is probably the answer (as it was to the ozone hole). I think electric vehicles eliminating fossil fuel powered vehicles as sure as flat screen TV's eliminated CRT's is an answer. I think a lack of acceptance of nuclear power is an issue, and nuclear power is an efficient viable solution. Solutions have to be socially acceptable and able to deliver mass change - a solution of turning off coal plants is not an answer as it would destroy civilisation, economies and populations in the same way that climate change would - no equally efficient and inexpensive replacement. Activist groups have not realised that Civil disobedience is not an answer, it is just pushing the question over and over. Solutions are what is required!!
- ablation 8y ago> Nobody is disagreeing that there is an issue. Nobody. Actually, I think one of the key issues is you still have powerful, vocal pointing out there is no issue. For example: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-46351940 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-46351940
- altitudinous 8y agoSO WHAT? The USA doesn't rule the world. What is your solution? Convincing everyone that there is a problem is not a solution. We just end up with everyone convinced there is a problem. Wasted energy. What is the solution?
- ablation 8y agoWhat an unnecessarily hostile response. I'm not trying to convince anyone of anything - one of the issues is that you have people who not only deny it's happening, but are trying to convince people it's not happening. Regardless of your assertion, the evidence is there that the issue is extremely polarised. I was pointing out that it's not as simple as wanting to believe that everyone is on the same page, here. It's not easy to even get people to recognise the issue, let alone starting from a point where we're all pulling in the same direction. I don't have a solution.
- crispinb 8y agoThe more people know about it, the more they are. Talk to academic ecologists. It's also very gradually dawning on the general population, but slow-motion catastrophes are hard to address with urgency given the many demands on peoples' attention. Add to the mix a firehose of lies and propaganda from the Murdoch media which has given many a false impression that climate collapse is scientifically controversial. There are signs of panic amongst the very young. A widespread rebellion is the only thing that could move fast enough to save us at this point, and I can't see where that could come from other than our youth. The chances aren't good, but if there are signs of hope, that would be where to look.
- mistrial9 8y agoplease do not encourage panic try https://exponentialroadmap.org https://exponentialroadmap.org
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoI think humanity has a built in "we'll figure it out" belief. I've seen people even here go "well, we'll just get used to the new normal". I think that, as things aren't immediately catastrophic they aren't that bad, and we'll figure it out at the 11th hour, like the race of superheroes that we are. Because nothing has ended the world so far, this one won't either. We'll just figure it out. I don't know about this one. I really don't.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]