2 ms·
Balmer missed the boat on all of this because he was out of touch. Android and Iphone indeed happened around the 2006-2008 time frame after having been rumored
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
Balmer missed the boat on all of this because he was out of touch. Android and Iphone indeed happened around the 2006-2008 time frame after having been rumored since about 2003-2006. They both were the logical conclusion from OSS and Linux emerging in the late nineties as a viable platform for development on embedded hardware. The difference between Balmer and Jobs is what they did in the nineties. Jobs ran a startup that produced the software that he later brought back to Apple that indeed also became the basis for the iphone. That's a decade plus of vision, R&D, etc. coming together. Balmer's vision meanwhile was Windows everywhere throughout this. When Jobs went on stage with the iphone, Balmer had nothing meaningful whatsoever to show. The little MS had was quickly forgotten. Once the iphone launched, Windows CE was dead as a door nail.
Windows Phone was a nice effort but years late and bogged down in a continued windows everywhere strategy and aggravated by lousy execution combined with institutional arrogance. They initially launched it as a windows CE shell with severe limitations. Then they alienated their OEMs and users with a highly disruptive and backwards incompatible move to windows NT. Finally, they topped it up with the Nokia acquisition. Nokia had committed early to windows phone which because of the prolonged uncertainty around this platform proved to be a major disaster. I used to work at Nokia, I've seen them fuck this up close. It wasn't pretty and Balmer was right at the center of it. MS ultimately acquired it and then proved it did not know how to fix it either. I still believe they could have pulled it off but not with the leadership (or lack thereof) that they had.
Balmer missed the boat utterly and completely, misread the market signals, and came up empty handed. The doomed Nokia acquisition was the proverbial nail in his coffin: the last in a decade long series of expensive failures.
The Google thing a few years ago was an existential threat to MS. Google was pushing users to chrome books running google office in a chrome browser on cheap hardware that ran Linux. The existential threat was two fold: no windows and no office. Nadella turned that around by making office 365 something that runs well everywhere, including on Chrome OS. The recent reverse takeover of Chromium by making that the centerpiece of Edge, sort of solidifies this. Up until then MS strategy was charging loads of money for windows on expensive laptops. Small form factor laptops became a thing during the mid 2000s and one key problem with those was that the windows license was substantial cost factor. It sort of made putting linux on hardware like that inevitable. It's the same problem they had on mobile. Expensive windows licenses for cheap phones did not make sense. That's why Android happened.
WSL indeed only matters to techies. But if techies pull their nose up for your platform, you have a long term problem because techies are the people that produce the things that make your platform long term viable. Five years ago, no self respecting engineer deploying on Linux would bother much with a windows machine. It was just too painful. Nothing worked and a typical README for developer tools on e.g. Github would be heavily mac/linux centric. Things like node.js, git, etc. barely even worked on it or only with a lot of workarounds and kludges. It was a big reason for Azure flopping in the market because MS sold windows in the cloud when the market was moving away from Windows. Nadella turned that around by embracing OSS, linux, and turning Balmer's mantra of "developers, developers, developers" into something that actually meant something to developers again. VS Studio Code and typescript now dominating the node.js and javascript ecosystem is quite a contrast with half a decade ago.
- scarface74 8y agoMicrosoft not only saw mobile coming, Windows Mobile (CE/Pocket PC) was out years before Android and iOS and was decently popular as a smart phone OS. HTC made dozens of models under its own brand and for other manufacturers. But if techies pull their nose up for your platform, you have a long term problem because techies are the people that produce the things that make your platform long term viable. Techies don’t matter. The people that were making Windows viable were Microsoft themselves with Office, other major software vendors, and the dark matter developers writing bespoke software that never saw the light of day outside of internal use. There is a reason that VB6 still shows up in Stack Overflow rankings almost 20 years after MS abandoned it. What were developers going to do? Ignore 90% of the market and wait for the year of Linux on the desktop? IIS was used plenty for corporate Intranets and many low bandwidth sites. The dark matter developers who develop for the enterprise and go home at night and don’t post on HN or before that Slashdot are everywhere.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoMS saw it coming, enjoyed some brief success with OEMs like htc around 2004, and then Android and IOS steamrolled over it by the 2008-2010 time frame. Sitting ducks basically. I worked at Nokia back in the day. Nokia knew this as well (I read the internal mailing lists, this was debated and speculated on heavily) and they did not act in time either. 2005 was in retrospect the key moment to act. Neither Nokia nor MS managed to do the right things. Apple and Google did. This was not exactly a secret except it did not translate into meaningful action. Worse, Nokia actually shut down several projects that in retrospect could have saved their ass when it was handed to them by Apple in 2007 with the iphone launch. E.g. S90 (touch UI for S60) was killed in favor of S60 (no touch whatsoever until 2008) in 2005. Then in 2007 they went "oh fuck" and tried to bring it back on S60 ultimately resulting in a prematurely launched device that was everything the iphone wasn't (slow, ugly, unstable, etc.). Subsequent attempts to fix it yielded no results. Bringing in windows phone years later was an act of desperation. Likewise Debian linux on tablets and phones was a thing in 2005 already. E.g. the N700 and N800 tablets shipped with it long before the ipad or iphone were a thing. Google ff-ing prototyped Android on these devices even before they shipped their nexus phone. Also, the chrome browser that made Android so successful? Guess what, Nokia had a webkit port for S60 in 2005 already. Google literally built Android/Chrome ecosystem on top of R&D done by Nokia (kernel drivers and optimizations, browsers, and other low level linux stuff). I'm pretty sure MS has similar stories of death by management. Balmer was the key person in charge at MS throughout this. 2005 is also the same year that AJAX browser apps started displacing desktop UIs at a no doubt alarming rate for MS. By the time MS was trying to push windows phone, their windows only development stack was a huge part of their problem. They needed developers to write apps for windows phone; especially developers already successful on IOS and Android. Only problem: all the IOS developers were on Macs (because Apple). And many of the Android developers were too (because they were pretty awesome). A windows laptop was a really hard sell to developers at the time because, well, they kind of sucked. Google was actively trying to compete with MS and still best friends with Apple so, the two of them created a developer friendly ecosystem outside of the MS bubble. Because their developer ecosystem sucked, windows phone lacked apps, and therefore it flopped. Techies matter if you are a tech company trying to create and push new tech. If you are milking cobol, vb6, or some other ancient crap: fire all the techies. Basically, that's what IBM and Oracle did. Techies used to love IBM stuff. Not any more. Lets not talk about just how much they loathe Oracle at this point. So techies not only matter but losing them cost Balmer his job and regaining their trust is a huge part of Nadella's current success.