6 ms·
> It's important to know who is crossing the border, in both directions. Why? And if there exists an important reason to know that someone is exiting the coun
by gumby 8y ago
> It's important to know who is crossing the border, in both directions.
Why?
And if there exists an important reason to know that someone is exiting the country does that same criterion not also apply to exiting a state or city or neighborhood?
I am not being sarcastic; I am genuinely unable to come up with a reason it's important to track who leaves almost any place, except in highly unusual cases (e.g. "OK guys, chatmasta has gone; let's get to work planning the surprise party for when he gets back")
- chatmasta 8y agoSo that next time chatmasta comes back, you know when he left. Otherwise how do you know how long he stayed in the country, and therefore how many days he should be allowed on this next visit? Currently, I assume the countries without exit controls have access to the entry databases of the destination countries, so they forego exit controls as redundant.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kalleboo 8y ago> Currently, I assume the countries without exit controls have access to the entry databases of the destination countries I believe the US exit controls are currently based on airline passenger manifests (not entry databases of other countries).
- rayiner 8y agoBorders are different. There is a right to free movement within a country. Not so across borders.
- antpls 8y agoThere is a right to free movement in the country because it would be impractical to check movements of people at this level of granularity. With this development of technology, it becomes possible to even check who is crossing your neighborhood, and you may lose your freedom inside your own country, if a government decided to go in that direction
- gumby 8y agoThere are numerous countries without unlimited right of free movement. China, Burma, and (to a much lesser extent) India come to mind. Also de facto limitations in highly violent places like Syria, parts of Iraq, Somalia et al, but I assume you were referring to a de jure right
- simonh 8y agoI don't know if they still do it, but in the 90s if you drove between provinces in Egypt there were police checkpoints reviewing ID, reason for travel and levying a fee although I don't know how official that last part was.
- unreal37 8y agoMost countries of the world have maximum visit lengths as part of a visitor visa. And those maximum visit lengths are counted on an annual basis. So you can only visit the US 179 days out of 365. So they need to know when you came in and when you left. It's not good enough to just leave and not tell anyone.
- jacobolus 8y agoThey don’t “need to know” for reasons which are of significant practical benefit to citizens/residents. But institutions like governments only “see” via data collection, and in general are happy to collect whatever is technically and socially feasible, and people involved in setting up databases seldom stop to think about the risks or trade-offs involved in collecting various types of data, or whether that data is meaningful or useful. https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2010/07/26/a-big-little-idea-called-legibility/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2010/07/26/a-big-little-idea-call...
- irrational 8y agoIt seems to me that being opposed to someone breaking the law is not equivalent to being a sadistic xenophobe. Finding people who rob banks at some point and punishing them is of great interest to people fearful of robbers who like disrupting robbers’ lives for no practical purpose because they gain sadistic satisfaction from cruelly exercising power over other people.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 8y agoI think the robbers argument isn't directly applicable because mere physical presence without committing a crime doesn't hurt anyone -- does it? I think Congress for all its flaws agrees, as simply being present and out of status in the US isn't a criminal matter, it's civil, and congress has repeatedly, and even recently, refused to change that classification. You punish a robber ostensibly to stop them from robbing again, lest you end up the victim of a robbery. What does being the victim of someone's unlawful presence even mean?
- chris_wot 8y agoI can. If someone commits a crime in the country and then they leave, then it's important to stop them. In Australia, a number of men have kidnapped their children and so knowing they were leaving would have prevented them from leaving with the children illegally.
- URSpider94 8y agoIts worth pointing out that the US is literally the only country in the world that I have visited, in my recollection, that does not have passport control upon exiting the country.
- jackweirdy 8y agoThe UK does not check passports outbound at airports either
- warp_factor 8y agoyou would have passport control if you exited the country through some other non conventional ways. The airlines are giving out all the information, that's why there is no need to do an exit passport control.
- oasisbob 8y ago> you would have passport control if you exited the country through some other non conventional ways. From the US? I can't think of any outgoing passport control at all; not by land in a private vehicle, nor by boat.
- biztos 8y agoI know it's not quite the same thing, but most countries in the EU have no passport control upon exiting or entering the country as long as it's within the Schengen zone. So France has basically no idea who shows up from Germany or leaves via Belgium. The countries on the external borders are supposed to handle all that. Now I suppose it's possible there is a lot of data exchanged in real time and so on, but it's also possible that is a complete mess and nobody really knows anything, especially about citizens (GDPR).
- oblio 8y agoIt's far from the same thing. For all intents and purposes the Schengen Area works like a big country, regarding border control. That's like being surprised that Iowa doesn't check your passport when you head over into the neighboring US state :)
- sombremesa 8y agoNorth Korea has an exit visa, and the associated processes. Obviously a great country to emulate.