3 ms·
It would be an interesting experiment on this to see if a U.S. politician would be willing to propose raising the age to collect Social Security in order to kee
by bumby 8y ago
It would be an interesting experiment on this to see if a U.S. politician would be willing to propose raising the age to collect Social Security in order to keep it solvent for later generations. Maybe I'm too cynical but I doubt older folks would be turning out in droves to support that idea.
- skybrian 8y agoHere, "insolvent" would just mean taxes need to be raised. Which need not necessarily be payroll taxes.
- bumby 8y agoRight, there's lots of ways to solve it because it's a completely human created problem. I guess my larger point was that if we're trying to assess if an older generation would be more willing to sacrifice for a younger generation, it would need need to be a method that disproportionately affects the older generations. Raising the age gets you there, I think raising taxes does the opposite.
- user5994461 8y agoRaising taxes has little effect on the older generation but dramatically hurt the working class. Retirement benefits are barely affected by employment taxes or income taxes. Most of the old wealth come from capital and/or renting properties. That being said, I'm not in the US but I am pretty sure the US is not that different from here.
- bumby 8y agoI'm in agreement. That's essentially the point I was making, although the commenter specifically said it didn't have to come from income taxes. With that said, I would assume other forms of taxation like a value-added or consumption tax would disproportionately affect younger citizens to the same effect
- user5994461 8y agoI don't know about the US but it has already happened in France. Retirement used to be after 40-42 years of work and it's been increased to about 45. It's still unsustainable and it's expected to increase again to 47-49. The politicians are dragging their feet because nobody wants to be the guy announcing that, but it's going to happen, it's just a matter of time with the president rotating every few years until one will be painted in a corner.