3 ms·
> Andrew Wakefield to any single specific case of parents forgoing vaxines. You're right, you can't because the anti-vaxx movement is as old as vaccines themse
by naasking 8y ago
> Andrew Wakefield to any single specific case of parents forgoing vaxines.
You're right, you can't because the anti-vaxx movement is as old as vaccines themselves. Wakefield's license was revoked for actually legitimate reasons. For his actions in falsifying data, not for expressing the idea that vaccines cause autism.
> I also think the ideas that Jones and Yiannopolous promote are easily seen to be harmful. Yiannopolous has promoted violence against journalists and associated himself with white supremacist movements.
Incitement to violence is a crime. We have processes for reporting crimes and seeing justice is done.
> I suppose it's up to you if you feel those ideas could cause harm - I feel they (and other ideas both have promoted) do.
"Ideas causing harm" is exactly the wrong way to look at it. Actions cause harm.
Sometimes ideas lead to action, but we should always police the action, not the thoughts. We start down a dangerous path to thoughtcrime as soon as someone is no longer permitted to think or express an idea.
- DanBC 8y ago> Wakefield's license was revoked for actually legitimate reasons. For his actions in falsifying data, not for expressing the idea that vaccines cause autism. It's useful to read the entire thing. https://www.scribd.com/doc/25983372/FACTS-WWSM-280110-Final-Complete-Corrected https://www.scribd.com/doc/25983372/FACTS-WWSM-280110-Final-... But imagine a doctor that merely says "Don't get vaccines, they cause autism" but doesn't falsify any data. That doctor is probably going to be erased from the English register.
- naasking 8y ago> But imagine a doctor that merely says "Don't get vaccines, they cause autism" but doesn't falsify any data. That doctor is probably going to be erased from the English register. Because that doctor is also falsifying data, namely, the data that they're presenting to their patient so they can make an informed decision.
- razakel 8y ago>But imagine a doctor that merely says "Don't get vaccines, they cause autism" but doesn't falsify any data. That doctor is probably going to be erased from the English register. No, but they would likely be censured. A doctor has to spectacularly screw up to get struck off. It's not done lightly. One obstetrician accidentally decapitated a baby during birth and kept her licence. Wakefield faked data, concealed two financial conflicts of interest, and ordered painful, invasive procedures (spinal taps and colonoscopies) on severely autistic children that were not clinically indicated and that he did not have the training to interpret. He even paid children at his son's birthday party for blood samples, then laughed about them crying during a later talk. That is not the sort of man I want practicing medicine.
- DanBC 8y agoHold on - I'm not defending Wakefield. I'm saying he did a lot more than falsifying data. The falsifying data alone would eb enough to strike him off, but he did a lot more than that. > A doctor has to spectacularly screw up to get struck off. It's not done lightly. One obstetrician accidentally decapitated a baby during birth and kept her licence. You're talking about medical error, and I agree you're right there. I'm talking about dishonesty, and doctors (in England) get struck off for dishonesty relatively easily. Mistakes happen, and can be remediated. Dishonesty is seen as harder to remediate. No patient harm, but over charging the patient: https://www.mpts-uk.org/-/media/mpts-rod-files/miss-susan-lim-mey-lee-17-april-2019.pdf https://www.mpts-uk.org/-/media/mpts-rod-files/miss-susan-li... False expenses claims, no patient harm: https://www.mpts-uk.org/-/media/mpts-rod-files/dr-kirsten-teresa-elizabeth-guest-28-february-2019.pdf https://www.mpts-uk.org/-/media/mpts-rod-files/dr-kirsten-te... Failure to report to duty; not paying back a debt to the employer (no patient harm): https://www.mpts-uk.org/-/media/mpts-rod-files/dr-chokkalinga-pandian-14-feb-2019.pdf https://www.mpts-uk.org/-/media/mpts-rod-files/dr-chokkaling...
- schmidtc 8y agoThe actions are policed and no one here is suggesting thoughts be policed. These individuals are free to shout their ideas in the public square. Facebook is a corporation not a government agency and they have the right to control their own products. Facebook isn’t refusing people based a protected status. Should a baker be required to make a cake promoting a hateful cause?
- naasking 8y ago> Facebook is a corporation not a government agency and they have the right to control their own products. It's always fascinating how quick people are to jump on the free market bandwagon when it suits their ends. Free speech protections also sometimes apply to privately managed public spaces, like malls. > These individuals are free to shout their ideas in the public square. Facebook is arguably the new public square, which is precisely my point.
- schmidtc 8y agoIt's always fascinating how quick people are to jump on the slippery slope bandwagon when it suits their ends. Your suggestion that privately held malls are subject to free speech protections is misleading. See Lloyd Corp. v. Tanner. There are counter examples of course, be these apply only in niche situations. Regardless, Facebook is not a public space. It's very much a private space. Suggesting that Facebook be treated as a public space is a pretty radical idea.
- naasking 8y ago> Your suggestion that privately held malls are subject to free speech protections is misleading. See Lloyd Corp. v. Tanner. Not misleading at all, I said it sometimes applies, which is true because some states recognize it as a right and some don't. > Regardless, Facebook is not a public space. It's very much a private space. A private space that anyone and everyone can freely access, and are, in fact, encouraged to frequent as much as humanly possible, and arguably has become intrinsic to the daily life of many, perhaps most, Americans. In fact, it's probably one of their primary means of socializing with friends and family, and definitely a medium for political discourse. Arguing it's a private space seems increasingly flimsy, frankly.