4 ms·
>allowing those views on your platform make you complicit Every faction since the dawn of history has said that the views of the other factions are objectively
by whatshisface 8y ago
>allowing those views on your platform make you complicit
Every faction since the dawn of history has said that the views of the other factions are objectively harmful. What is it that blesses SV neo-something-or-other as the one true faction that has finally discovered the objective truth?
- jesterman81 8y agoFinally somebody gets it!!!! This is refreshing!
- mindslight 8y agoRest assured many people do get it, but the mob rolls on. Power is one hell of a drug.
- aeturnum 8y agoI don't think I made a claim that SV (or anyone) is an objective arbiter of truth. I said: 1) At some point, if you allow a view to be expressed on your platform, you become somewhat implicated in that view spreading. 2) I believe (and I think FB believes) that the views these people promote are harmeful. Now, should we trust Facebook? No! Facebook has banned many people and groups for far less than these people were banned. The reason Facebook is pushing this news so hard is that they have been letting things slide again and again because these people were prominent figures (see also how Twitter keeps not banning trump despite his many threats of violence).
- avn2109 8y agoI am not the author of the parent comment that you're replying to, but I appreciate your civil reply in a flamebait-y thread. That said, his point seems to be that FB is banning e.g. Farrakhan without making any effort at disproving Farrakhan's claims, and furthermore that many of the commenters in this thread are similarly dismissive of Farrakhan's claims without offering anything resembling a good-faith disproof of those claims. (Note that the parent and I are not making any statement about Farrakhan's correctness or incorrectness, but are instead merely noting the widespread absence of proofs about this correctness). Personally I know essentially nothing about Farrakhan and his claims, but I like to believe that I can think critically enough to evaluate his claims on their merits, and do not need to be "protected" from hearing them by Facebook or anyone else. I (and perhaps the parent poster) would like to participate in an agora of ideas where everyone is welcome to promulgate his claims, no matter how allegedly outlandish, and the strongest ideas will win on their merits. Contrast this to a situation wherein the winning ideas win because their rivals are excluded from the agora. Of course I don't mean this just about Farrakhan. Similarly, I have never read the Protocols of Zion, which are mentioned several times elsewhere in this thread, and I have no clue whether they are related to a Jewish conspiracy for world domination etc. But many commenters here are asserting claims about the Protocols, without offering any attempt at a proof beyond a link to Wikipedia, which personally I find very unconvincing as a matter of principle, on this and any other topic. In general I am not convinced by assertions/bannings, and prefer evidence.
- objectivetruth 8y agoPeople on HN insert Wiki links so that readers can get a quick overview of a subject they may be unfamiliar with. None of us here owe you a curated list of academic journals explaining the history of specific instances of hate speech. If you really feel that conventional wisdom is wrong about the Protocols of the Elders of Zion being hate-filled trash, by all means, do the research and make a decision. And that relates to the bigger picture about whether Facebook owes Farrakhan any sort of explanation or reason for kicking him: to be blunt, we don't HAVE TO offer a reasoned, good-faith proof that every wackjob is a wackjob or that's all us non-wackjobs would be doing all day: countering wackjobs. I've never read Farrakhan but I don't have to read his writings to know that I disagree with him because enough people already have -- journalists, commentators, other people, the literati, the accumulated conventional wisdom of our society, whatever you want to call it. Same with the Protocols of the Elders of Zion -- it's propaganda filth that should have been left behind in the last century. I've never read it, don't need to. You can if you want. It's not outlawed and shouldn't be. But FB has decided they don't want that filth on their servers. Because sometimes, the people who post that filth also egg each other on and post things like "get a high score!" when one of their buddies starts livestreaming themselves shooting up a synagogue. So if you do want to read it, go for it -- you can find it in numerous academic studies of hate speech and propaganda, and I'm sure it's still available on plenty of websites haunted by the types of guys who collect Nazi memorabilia with a gleam in their eye. But don't be shocked that lots of us have heard of it and can instantly label it as crap without having to research it.
- losteric 8y agoFacebook is a corporation and their website is private property. You have no free speech.
- ben_w 8y agoI would argue that when a website get enough users, it should be seen as a government. The number is as ill-defined as “how many grains of sand makes a heap”, but FB is now defining the social interactions of more people than the largest single nation state. On the other paw, I don’t believe in absolute freedom of speech, because the very power which makes the freedom worth having also enables it to cause harm. I think the quote “If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him“ still applies today. I wish I had a solution to that rather than just a vague feeling. Vague inexpressible feelings are part of the problem.
- losteric 8y agoDo you mean it should be seen as a public space? I agree there is an argument for regulating large for-profit social media sites as a public utilities... but I can't see how they are "a government" in and of themselves.
- ben_w 8y agoNot quite. I mean that it has rules of behaviour, it hires people to enforce those rules, it has strategic objectives and engages in world events, and is an economic force just above the middle of the IMF 2018 list, roughly equivalent to Slovenia (assuming GDP ~= revenue), or North Dakota if prefer to compare against a state of the USA. Facebook is not a nation, despite all that, but not all government are national governments and I think it counts as a kind of government.
- root_axis 8y ago> I would argue that when a website get enough users, it should be seen as a government That's absurd. It's a website not a government; nobody is forcing you to use facebook, if you dislike how they operate their website don't use it.
- 50656E6973 8y ago>What is it that blesses SV neo-something-or-other as the one true faction that has finally discovered the objective truth? They are self-anointed by nature of being de facto gate keepers of the global information flow. Similar to how the Church used to be the gatekeepers of information, and were compelled to silence "blasphemous" ideas that they didn't like.
- munificent 8y agoThey aren't self-anointed. We anointed them by using their platform. They're only gatekeepers because we user keeping choosing to walk through their gate instead of choosing any of the many other paths onto the Internet.
- 50656E6973 8y ago>They aren't self-anointed. We anointed them by using their platform Nahhh, it's way more nuanced than that. They started as user friendly simple services with little to no purposeful mass censorship. Then the user base grew into the billions effectively creating captive audience due to the network effect. Then they became increasingly user hostile (i.e. switching from chronological timeline to a psychologically manipulative news feed) and got into the business of political mass censorship and electioneering; like a bait and switch.