4 ms·
MS was basically making money no matter what given the highly lucrative office + windows franchise that Bill Gates left behind. I wouldn't credit Balmer with th
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
MS was basically making money no matter what given the highly lucrative office + windows franchise that Bill Gates left behind. I wouldn't credit Balmer with that too much he just basically kept on milking that. The problem by the time he left was that there was increasingly less to squeeze.
Shareholders tend to look forward rather than backward and it was getting very clear that windows and office were increasingly less critical to users and that there were some serious revenue issues around that going forward. Windows on the server was basically getting less relevant by the day. Windows desktop was feeling a lot of pressure from Apple and increasingly Google. Office sales were suffering when companies started using alternative office tools from e.g. Google. Windows Phone was not working that great either and struggled to gain market share on Apple and Google. The Nokia acquisition that Balmer pushed through was sort of the nail in the coffin here. That was an expensive failure and that is 100% on Balmer.
The keyword in those strategies was windows. Under Balmer it absolutely had to be windows everywhere. Server, desktop, mobile, IOT, and all the rest. It wasn't working. That's why Balmer 'left' (i.e. was pretty much fired but in a nice face saving way).
Nadella killed that windows everything strategy and turned things around. Office is now liberated from Windows and making a lot of money for MS again. Cloud is growing more important as well, courtesy of mostly non windows software running on Linux in Azure. Meanwhile windows on the desktop seems pretty cool now that MS has added Linux integration, a non MS browser, and a few other things that make it a lot more attractive for developers and users and now that they are no longer forced to be in this windows everything walled garden. Even mobile is doing great for MS now that they can focus on treating IOS and Android as first class citizens.
- scarface74 8y agoIf you just look at the time between 2000-2007, the first half of Ballmer’s tenure. The stock wasn’t doing well, but revenues were steadily increasing. During this time: - Apple was still on PowerPC processors until 2006 and weren’t really any threat to Microsoft. - GSuite didn’t even launch until 2006 and even today, it’s really not that much competition to MS Office. It has less than a tenth of the revenue and only a few Fortune 500 companies (https://www.reuters.com/article/us-alphabet-gsuite-idUSKBN1FL3ZX https://www.reuters.com/article/us-alphabet-gsuite-idUSKBN1F...) - The iPhone didn’t come out until 2007 and really didn’t start gaining market share until 2010. Even today, Google’s “winning” with Android has only netted it less than $30 billion in profit since inception (https://www.theverge.com/2016/1/21/10810834/android-generated-31-billion-revenue-google-oracle https://www.theverge.com/2016/1/21/10810834/android-generate...) - Microsoft adding WSL only matters to a few techies. - Even the Nokia acquisition happened later during his tenure.
- ticmasta 8y agoIt's also not really fair to Balmer to only evaluate performance over his time as CEO - he played a huge role during Gates' tenure as well.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoBalmer missed the boat on all of this because he was out of touch. Android and Iphone indeed happened around the 2006-2008 time frame after having been rumored since about 2003-2006. They both were the logical conclusion from OSS and Linux emerging in the late nineties as a viable platform for development on embedded hardware. The difference between Balmer and Jobs is what they did in the nineties. Jobs ran a startup that produced the software that he later brought back to Apple that indeed also became the basis for the iphone. That's a decade plus of vision, R&D, etc. coming together. Balmer's vision meanwhile was Windows everywhere throughout this. When Jobs went on stage with the iphone, Balmer had nothing meaningful whatsoever to show. The little MS had was quickly forgotten. Once the iphone launched, Windows CE was dead as a door nail. Windows Phone was a nice effort but years late and bogged down in a continued windows everywhere strategy and aggravated by lousy execution combined with institutional arrogance. They initially launched it as a windows CE shell with severe limitations. Then they alienated their OEMs and users with a highly disruptive and backwards incompatible move to windows NT. Finally, they topped it up with the Nokia acquisition. Nokia had committed early to windows phone which because of the prolonged uncertainty around this platform proved to be a major disaster. I used to work at Nokia, I've seen them fuck this up close. It wasn't pretty and Balmer was right at the center of it. MS ultimately acquired it and then proved it did not know how to fix it either. I still believe they could have pulled it off but not with the leadership (or lack thereof) that they had. Balmer missed the boat utterly and completely, misread the market signals, and came up empty handed. The doomed Nokia acquisition was the proverbial nail in his coffin: the last in a decade long series of expensive failures. The Google thing a few years ago was an existential threat to MS. Google was pushing users to chrome books running google office in a chrome browser on cheap hardware that ran Linux. The existential threat was two fold: no windows and no office. Nadella turned that around by making office 365 something that runs well everywhere, including on Chrome OS. The recent reverse takeover of Chromium by making that the centerpiece of Edge, sort of solidifies this. Up until then MS strategy was charging loads of money for windows on expensive laptops. Small form factor laptops became a thing during the mid 2000s and one key problem with those was that the windows license was substantial cost factor. It sort of made putting linux on hardware like that inevitable. It's the same problem they had on mobile. Expensive windows licenses for cheap phones did not make sense. That's why Android happened. WSL indeed only matters to techies. But if techies pull their nose up for your platform, you have a long term problem because techies are the people that produce the things that make your platform long term viable. Five years ago, no self respecting engineer deploying on Linux would bother much with a windows machine. It was just too painful. Nothing worked and a typical README for developer tools on e.g. Github would be heavily mac/linux centric. Things like node.js, git, etc. barely even worked on it or only with a lot of workarounds and kludges. It was a big reason for Azure flopping in the market because MS sold windows in the cloud when the market was moving away from Windows. Nadella turned that around by embracing OSS, linux, and turning Balmer's mantra of "developers, developers, developers" into something that actually meant something to developers again. VS Studio Code and typescript now dominating the node.js and javascript ecosystem is quite a contrast with half a decade ago.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago"MS was basically making money no matter what given the highly lucrative office + windows franchise that Bill Gates left behind. I wouldn't credit Balmer with that too much he just basically kept on milking that. The problem by the time he left was that there was increasingly less to squeeze." No, this is not fair. Ballmer reconfigured sales channels, created an array of Enterprise offers including cloud - that's what enabled him to grow MS substantially during those years. "Office is now liberated from Windows and making a lot of money for MS again. " - it always was. The 'windows everything' strategy makes sense in the 2000's. iOS is pretty similar to MacOS - it worked for Apple. It even made sense early on in cloud. Satya is the right choice for the right time, and it was right in hindsight to go cloud-linux and other things ... But there's too much 'narrative' around this Satya thing.
- nojvek 8y agoThat’s not true. I was there in MS when the office teams had a great iOS app and they wanted to ship but Ballmer blocked it. When Nadella became CEO, they shipped it and it was a big deal. Nadellas chant was “Mobile+Cloud”. He came from Cloud & Enterprise. What he praised and asked everyone to focus on was very different from what Ballmer used to say.