3 ms·
> one that's seen more than a century of improvements Ah, I have tried quills a couple of times. And dip pens. It was interesting. ;) > movies [...] can't
by mncharity 8y ago
> one that's seen more than a century of improvements
Ah, I have tried quills a couple of times. And dip pens. It was interesting. ;)
> movies [...] can't help laughing about the ergonomics of it
Yes. Though they do seem to have an "outreach" role, raising awareness and interest that improvement over the familiar is possible.
And moving while working, like shifting from sitting to standing desk and back, and walking, can be nice.
> minimize cognitive load, eye strain and arm strain
Nod.
> focusing on a screen a couple of centimeters [...] eye strain
The focus distance is usually either around 1 m, or infinity. Downsides include being fixed, creating vergence-accommodation conflict. Prototypes, and the new Microsoft Hololens 2 (which paints the retina), variously improve on this.
> minimize cognitive load
One thing I've played with, is taking a downward keyboard-cam of hands on keyboard, and overlaying it on a 3D monitor. Raising it slightly in Z seemed to allow focusing past it, making it merely bothersome, rather than untenable. Upside is it reminded me of an old Lisp Machine, with the screen telling you what various keystrokes would do in your current context, so I don't have to remember them all.
> less hand movement
Yes. I really like the idea of keyboard as multitouch surface. Stroke a keycap, rather than moving to a touchpad. Touch a modifier key keycap, rather than having to actually press and hold it. And optical finger tracking allowing subtle hand gestures to be commands.
> read and write documents [...] 3D space or are projected in thin air in front of me is uninteresting to that end
Hmm. Sometimes it's useful to print out a document, and put it up on a wall, so you can see the big picture, or talk with someone about it. If one has a task which fills the available monitor space, it's easy and common to remember what it was like with a smaller monitor, and not want to go back, but harder to imagine whether the same might happen again with further expansion.
More generally, one thing that cheaper real estate might do is lower the barrier for tooling to provide speculative assistance. You're writing for an audience including someone from Great Britain, using a phrase that has different meaning there than in the US... checking that with a keystroke, or as part of a "I'm done, check it now" report, seems less attractive than "comments are available off to your side - glance if you care". Grammarly meets VR.
For myself, writing documents is often preceded by a lot of graph drawing, as I figure out the structure of the domain, concept space, and presentation alternatives. I very much look forward to moving that into direct-manipulation 3D.