4 ms·
I don't believe that this is a function of age. There's quite a bit of behavioral economics research to support this that was done on undergraduates, for exampl
by bumby 8y ago
I don't believe that this is a function of age. There's quite a bit of behavioral economics research to support this that was done on undergraduates, for example.
- JohnFen 8y ago> that was done on undergraduates There aren't a lot of old undergrads (and undergrads themselves are not terribly representative of the entire population within the same age group -- this has been a known problem with tons of university research for a long, long time). This implies that the research you're referring to wouldn't necessarily speak to what drives older generations.
- bumby 8y agoAh, sorry, I think I missed your point (or reversed it). To my knowledge, I'm not aware of any research that can support that bias is function of age. Was the claim that it's a function of age based on research or your personal opinion?
- JohnFen 8y ago> Was the claim that it's a function of age based on research or your personal opinion? A bit of both. There is research that suggests, but does not prove, as far as I am aware, that this is a function of age (or, more accurately, a function of having children). And my personal observations are in accord with that. The underlying hypothesis is that when you're young, the priority in terms of species preservation is personal preservation: you have to stay alive and healthy enough to reproduce. That encourages short-term thinking. After you've had children, though, the priority in terms of species preservation becomes the preservation of the children: they need to stay alive and healthy enough to reproduce, not you. You've already done your reproduction bit.
- bumby 8y agoWhat's interesting is that humans are unique in their early-onset menopause. One theory is that it's to help foster investment in later generations (i.e. help raise the grandchildren rather than continuing having your own). I think the trade-off to protect your offspring rather than yourself is different than the present-bias argument I was making, though. I'm still not aware of research that speaks specifically to the present-bias though in terms of it changing as one ages. If you have research related to it, it would be something I would be interested in reading.
- JohnFen 8y ago> What's interesting is that humans are unique in their early-onset menopause. It is! IIRC, the thinking is that the usual reproductive strategy is to have as many babies as possible, so that enough will survive by chance to reproductive age. Humans veered away from that as a result of the need to give birth far earlier in the development process than other animals (because of our huge skulls). This increased the cost (in terms of time and energy from the parents) of children significantly, making it impossible to have huge numbers of offspring. Thus a different species survival strategy was needed, involving increasing the chances that any single child will survive. This, the thinking goes, led to social structures such as the continued involvement of grandparents, etc. If you look at other animals that have "expensive" children (such as, for example, elephants), you see similar effects. The whole subject is really fascinating. > If you have research related to it, it would be something I would be interested in reading. Me too, actually. I came across this stuff a long while ago while working with a researcher in a closely related field, and haven't kept up with it much since. I may have a list of the related research papers in my archives somewhere. I'll see if I can dig it up.