24 ms·
Tesla Model 3 Effect – Chevy Dealers Discount 2019 Bolt by Almost $10k
- BrentOzar 8y agoThe cause and effect here makes no sense. The authors say one reason for the discount is the Tesla Model 3 is selling at $36,200, but "Tesla hasn't actually delivered any yet at that price point" (article quote, not mine) and that's why Chevy needs to discount the Bolt to $18,995. That's like saying wireless chargers on Amazon have to discount down to $13.99 because Apple promised to sell the AirPower someday. Those two things are just unrelated: it might be plain old supply and demand. My guess: Chevy has to discount the Bolt because it's simply not selling that well. They already had to discontinue the Volt, their plug-in hybrid.
- kmonsen 8y agoBolt is getting outdated, and I think for example the Kona EV is more competition. And I don't really see any good reason to get the Bolt.
- brianwawok 8y agoAt 10k off, it might be a fine EV grocery getter. Right now a lot of people buy 4-5 year old leafs for like ~10k as EV grocery getters
- madengr 8y agoYep, I bought a 2 year old one with 19k miles for $8,500.
- bogomipz 8y agoWow, is that a normal price though for a 2 year old Leaf? Was it so cheap simply because they depreciate that much? I imagine much of it would still be under warranty too as well no?
- brianwawok 8y agoThey were fairly cheap to begin with. A new battery is like 6k so that’s s big chunk of the price drop. If you can deal with old battery though you are golden.
- jdhn 8y agoIs there a catch to this? I know that Leaf batteries aren't liquid cooled which degrades them a lot quicker than liquid cooled batteries, but still that's an absurdly good deal.
- ip26 8y agoMight just be the fact that they are quickly getting dated, especially the models with less than 100 miles of range new. Like back when you upgraded your computer every 18 months.
- brianwawok 8y agoIn 4-5 years tour range is half if rated. Half that in winter. Should get you to the grocery store :)
- madengr 8y agoNo catch. A 2015 base model with fast charger option. Bought it in 2017. A ton of these 2015 were coming off 2 year leases in 2017, and I bought it off a guy who re-sells then from auctions. So I wonder what he got it for at auction?
- davidrm 8y agojesus christ the us market is amazing. (yea yea there are trade offs)
- madengr 8y agoWhy would it be outdated? It has 200+ miles range.
- RankingMember 8y agoI don't think it's outdated, but it just doesn't have the features (semi-autonomous driving, slick minimalist if controversially-so interior, OTA updates, etc.) you get with a Tesla. It's like comparing an original 2007 Apple iPhone to a 2007 Palm Centro.
- dmitrygr 8y agoRandom and uncontrollable shuffling of the software in your car is a FEATURE?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- RankingMember 8y agoI would definitely consider having your braking/acceleration/navigation/security upgraded without a visit to a service center a feature.
- dmitrygr 8y agoUntil a bug disables them, Yes. Raise your hand if you know of someone who writes bug free code.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- willhk 8y agoYes, nobody writes bug free code and that's why having a car that can't update software OTA is a good thing. Got it. I do enjoy knowing that if a bug crops up I have to schedule an appointment at the dealership and take a day off work to drop it off to be upgraded instead of waking up to a bugfix having been already deployed.
- rayiner 8y agoAlso, the cars are competing in completely different markets. A better reference might be that a base 2019 leaf is now $23,000 or so with tax credit: https://www.motortrend.com/cars/nissan/leaf/2019/2019-nissan-leaf-plus-first-test-review https://www.motortrend.com/cars/nissan/leaf/2019/2019-nissan....
- slg 8y ago>"Tesla hasn't actually delivered any yet at that price point" (article quote, not mine) The article is wrong. The first $35k models started being delivered a couple weeks back.
- CarVac 8y agoThe article is also dated from April 1… which makes it a little out of date on top of being suspect in other ways.
- slg 8y agoMy fault, I should have checked the date of the article. I do wonder why this month old post from this amateurish looking car blog is currently the second highest post on HN.
- symlinkk 8y agoYeah but a couple weeks after that Tesla changed the trims you could get and made the cheapest one $39.5k.
- leesec 8y agoYou can still call the dealership and have them discount your car and get a software limited version of that vehicle for less.
- slg 8y agoYeah, they obviously want an opportunity to upsell you so they make you speak to a person to get the $35k model. It is a bad business practice from a consumer perspective, but if you have ever purchased a car from a dealer you know this type of upselling is unfortunately standard for the industry. At least Tesla won't try to sell you on rustproofing and tire warranties.
- jsgo 8y agoI'm curious, can you "upgrade" your car after the fact? Buy it and then later on call Tesla and pay for the software-controlled 'upgrade' you declined before? Is there any negative financial impact to it (are there fees attached or is it basically the difference you didn't pay prior)?
- bwanab 8y agoI'm not sure it makes no sense. I bought a Model 3 because I didn't see enough of a price difference to be worth the difference in the cars. I would have been willing to go with a less capable car if I'd felt the price was right. When I was evaluating, a tricked out Bolt was over $40,000 and still wasn't as capable as a Model 3 which was admittedly more expensive but, to me, worth it.
- PButtNutter 8y agoI think it's maybe more likely a result of car sales being down in general. Nisan light vehicle sales are down 7.8% (~35,000 vehicles) when comparing the first 4 months of 2018 to the first 4 months of 2019. https://www.autonews.com/sales/sales-fall-saar-dips-1641-million https://www.autonews.com/sales/sales-fall-saar-dips-1641-mil...
- throwaway55554 8y agoHow do you get people to read your article about Chevy? Mention Tesla.
- lostmsu 8y agoHere I applaud Chevrolet for being ingenious. Tesla PR techniques literally cost people lifes.
- dragontamer 8y agoHeh, worked on me. So I can't really complain about the strategy. Still, it is annoying clickbait.
- throwaway5752 8y agoThey discontinued the Volt because they closed the only plant that built it (Lordstown). That also included the Cruze, the Impala, two Cadillacs, and a Buick.
- csours 8y agoAlmost - Lordstown only built the Cruze. Detroit Hamtramck builds the others. Disclaimer: I work for GM
- throwaway5752 8y agoSorry, hard to keep track of unallocations between there, Oshawa, and Detroit. Per your sibling comment (if you can answer) - was it the plant closure that led to the Volt being discontinued, or was that just coincident with it being discontinued because of the ZEV/PHEV credit rule change?
- WorldMaker 8y agoThe Volt was discontinued with the plant closure and the decision to stop making all sedans, according to shareholder PR at the time of the plant closure. (Still six degrees of stupid that made me as an extremely minor shareholder somewhat dissatisfied. The Gen 1 Volt was a hatchback and near the cross-over border line. An intent at building it at Hamtranck was to push the plant towards cross-overs. The Gen 2 retooled the Volt to a more traditional sedan and more clearly Cruze relative, which presumably was a cost savings at Hamtranck, but put the Volt right on the chopping block for the plant closure a couple years later. Even ignoring that GM probably only closed Sedans because they were playing shareholder-peer-pressure follow the leader since Ford did it, throwing away the Volt was so many orders of magnitude of stupid. Expect GM to announce a new cross-over in one or three years looking almost just like the Gen 1 Volt and with an entirely new name because that would be less confusing to consumers than not discontinuing the Volt at all.)
- csours 8y agoI'm sure this is the sort of thing I'm not supposed to comment on, but fortunately I also don't have any inside knowledge. One may gain some insight from looking at sales numbers.
- sgustard 8y agoI look forward to the day when there are enough EV models that it's not assumed all EVs are interchangeable. You wouldn't see an article suggesting that BMW 330i sales are cannibalizing Honda Civics.
- benj111 8y agoIf the 330i were the same price as the Civic, then wouldn't that be possible? Although it may be difficult to establish cause and effect. I think it's more the case that EV pricing is in flux at the moment, so you get situations like this where 2 cars from different segments were priced the same.
- drb91 8y agoI thought the primary advantage tesla cars have over others is the charging network—these cars are already easily differentiated. I’m also sure people are enthused about quality and self driving but that doesn’t do much for me.
- heurist 8y agoI charge my hybrid for free at a ChargePoint station near my office. My wife likes to charge her electric car at an outlet mall when she goes into town. I don't take my car on long distance trips so I'm not sure if there would be a benefit to the Tesla network for that, but I've never had an issue finding a place to charge.
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoWhen driving five hundred miles or so, taking a quick break ever few hours to take a bio break and something to eat, is perfect for me. When I get back to the car it is ready to go again. No problems with payments, hardly a broken charger, not crowded (in Sweden). Friends who have other electric cars have big issues with these things. The Tesla Network makes a huge difference for me.
- mohaine 8y ago
- dragontamer 8y ago> My guess: Chevy has to discount the Bolt because it's simply not selling that well. They already had to discontinue the Volt, their plug-in hybrid. All auto-companies are showing declining sales. Ford, GM, Toyota, and Tesla. I think your supposition here is most correct. The car market is declining, so the various car companies are now cutting prices and competing on price even more strongly. Some car models will be cut out and discontinued as a result.
- close04 8y agoCars are more and more reliable so people can hang on to them for longer. We're also at a milestone, crossing from ICEs to EVs and this may discourage people from actually committing to a new car.
- dragontamer 8y agoSimpler than that. The car market is cyclical. When people buy a car, it takes another 5+ years before those people decide to buy another car. It seems the last "boom" cycle was 2018 or so. So we're now entering the years where most people are NOT buying cars. In 2023 or so, all of the buyers from 2018 will be buying cars again. There's nothing mystical about this behavior, its just how the crowds work in general. https://www.autonews.com/sales/sales-fall-saar-dips-1641-million https://www.autonews.com/sales/sales-fall-saar-dips-1641-mil...
- londons_explore 8y agoI don't see any self-synchronising effect in crowds... In fact, if anything, instant supply and demand would reward those who buy out-of-phase with the majority.
- dragontamer 8y agoIn theory, there's no difference between theory and practice. But in practice, there's a big difference. The car auto cycle is well known and well documented. I don't think there's any good economic theory to describe why it exists... it just... exists... for whatever reason. > instant supply and demand Instant supply and demand certainly doesn't exist in practice, even if we assume it to exist in theory. It takes over a year for factories to be built, and when people hear news about a new car, it can take months (or even years) before they decide they want that particular car. Humans work on a monthly time-scale, even if we assume in economics that their decisions are made instantaneously.
- gordon_freeman 8y agoOne of the big concerns for buying an electric car for someone like me is the range anxiety and not practical enough if I could not take it to long drives (SF to LA for ex). Tesla has actually solved this problem on 3 fronts: having its own charging n/w around the majority of US highways, having more energy efficient batteries that can drive to 300+ miles on a single charge, and making the charging process speedier with superchargers. Until other car manufacturers do this, I am not convinced to buy anything except a Tesla.
- myself248 8y agoThat's just it. My daily commute is quite normal, easily within the range of a Leaf or whatever, but I also enjoy frequent roadtrips to Chicago, Cleveland, Dayton, Toronto, occasionally Kansas City or Washington DC. Most of those are weekend jaunts, but there are longer trips too – I drove to Eagle Harbor last summer and Orlando over the holidays. I’ll probably drive to NYC this summer, as I have in 4 of the last 10 years. I love roadtrips and consider them a wonderful part of the American experience. The standard EV-evangelist response to this is “take the train” or “rent a car for the weekend”, but I’m sorry, those just aren’t comfortable for me – the train lacks the freedom and sense of adventure, and rentals usually smell funny, among other things. Altering my lifestyle to suit the car’s limitations means it was the wrong car in the first place: The car should serve me, not the other way around. The Tesla’s longer range and presence of Supercharger stations along the routes are totally irrelevant for my daily commute, but they completely change the game when you include my other driving. With any other EV, I would need a second car to address the other part of my usage, and that means twice the insurance, twice the registration cost, twice the driveway-space, and the chance of forgetting something important in the one car while I’m using the other. And feeling like a glutton for owning an “extra” vehicle. That being said, I still haven't bought a Tesla for a handful of reasons, but nothing else even comes close to meeting my needs.
- dragontamer 8y agoI'm curious, why aren't you looking into PHEVs? Prius, GM Volt, and Honda Clarity? With 50 mile all-electric range available, these cars can be pure electric in most daily-driver situations. In fact, Volt drivers are reporting 85% electric to 15% gasoline usage, typically (with those gasoline usage being those long trips that rack up a lot of miles). With Gen1 Volts hitting 100k miles, its more or less proven itself as a methodology and as a general technology. Unfortunately, Volt has been discontinued, but the Honda Clarity is basically an identical vehicle (albeit offered by a different car company).
- lowdose 8y agoAccording to Elon the model 3 will have a ROI of 200k if customers decide to participate in the robotaxi fleet. So it could be that this 10k is the robotaxi discount.
- TuringNYC 8y agoNot saying Model 3s are vapourware, but this is a pretty common result of exciting promised releases on competitors.
- thrill 8y agoThis is no particular surprise. The BMW i3 is being discounted about the same. The real takeaway of the article to me is that "Tesla hasn't actually delivered any yet at that price point" (the $35K Model 3). Tesla's cash starved, as has been discussed here, and that could easily push any such deliveries far down the road. The industry shakeouts will be interesting to watch.
- colordrops 8y agoExcept they are selling the 35k model.
- danmg 8y agoDelivery is prioritized by price paid. The only way to get delivery on a tesla model 3 is to add every option which can basically double the cost of the car.
- mjamesaustin 8y agoThat's not true at all. I ordered the SR+ as soon as it was announced, and they were ready to deliver before I was ready to receive it! Got mine on March 30th, and love it.
- kylec 8y agoI suspect this has more to do with losing the federal subsidy than competition from Tesla
- cwt137 8y agoI agree.
- make3 8y agoI'd really like to give the Bolt a chance, but isn't the Chevy Bolt's design really unappealing? Especially compared to the Tesla model 3. I wonder why they made it this way. It's a matter of personal taste but I find it less appealing than even a Honda Civic.
- GiorgioG 8y agoThere's a single Model 3 in my neighborhood and I don't understand the appeal aesthetically. I'm glad there are so many adopters for EVs (Tesla or otherwise) willing to put up with all the downsides until the technology and infrastructure matures to a point where it is competitive (price, charge time, range, charging station at every gas station, etc.)
- newsoul2019 8y agoWhere do you live? There's 1 or 2 in every driveway around here (South Bay)
- GiorgioG 8y agoRaleigh, NC.
- asark 8y agoBasically anywhere not unusually rich? They're no longer Maserati-uncommon around here like they were a few years ago (Maseratis: also rare most places) but they're still pretty uncommon. Might see one, maybe two a day on the road on a commute into the city and back. Some days a couple more, lots of days zero. I think I've seen one ever in my neighborhood of 100+ houses, and I'm not sure it belonged to anyone who lives here. And this is not an actually poor neighborhood, or even close. Just not rich.
- tyfon 8y agoNot OP, but I live outside a satellite city to Oslo and I feel like every 5th car I see on the road is a tesla and every other car is an EV of some kind. Many E-golfs, leafs and a ton of other ones. So there are some parts of the world where there are popular. Not having to pay "pollution tax" that can be up to 100% of the initial value of the car nor 25% vat helps drive adoption :) Incidentally I ordered my first one today, a model x with the new drive trains etc. It will take a few months before it arrives.
- madengr 8y agoGM better have something up their sleeve. With the plant closings to divert $ to electric and driverless R&D, I have not read of any new EV models or AI progress.
- newsoul2019 8y agoEverybody is holding their breath to see what happens with Tesla. Will they flame out, or will they win it all?
- brokensegue 8y agoGM owns a large piece of Cruise
- DeonPenny 8y agoThey own all of cruise
- brokensegue 8y agothat's a very large part
- devy 8y agoI would argue that $10k Chevy Bolt discount wasn't originated from the pressure of Model 3's pricing and some low moving EV models have long been getting significant discounts off MSRP. Back in 2017 when the first Bolt model year came out, I've got $4k cash offer mailer from GM and another stackable $5k off MSRP from a large regional GM volume dealership. And Nissan Leaf have been having $10k off MSRP discounts that are subsidized by regional power utilities too. This is a common trend way before $35k Model entered volume production.
- madengr 8y agoMaybe you are in the KC area. KCP&L had $10k rebates in Leafs. I was going to buy a new one, but the dealers were total assholes, jacking up the prices to compensate for the rebate. I ended up buying a used one. I’ll buy a Tesla next, or another used, just to not deal with scumbag dealerships.
- devy 8y agoI live in Northern NJ. PSE&G did that $10k off MSRP for LEAF too a couple years ago.
- Robotbeat 8y agoSpeaking personally, this is pretty straightforward. Why would I buy a Chevy Bolt for the same price as a Model 3, even if I have to buy it "off menu"? (And deliveries have started, BTW: https://electrek.co/2019/04/15/tesla-delivers-35000-model-3/ https://electrek.co/2019/04/15/tesla-delivers-35000-model-3/) Or slightly more for the more available Standard Plus Model 3? The Bolt is wonderful, but it's limited to 50kW charging and even more important it has no access to a consistent, strategically placed network of well-maintained chargers spanning the continent. Basically, the Bolt is still a city commuter which cannot feasibly take road trips of any significant length (outside of charging corridors in the Northeast and West coast), not too different from a Leaf, functionally. At least with the Volt, you could still take road trips the same as any other car. (And all of this ignores the panoramic glass roof, the autopilot features, the superior cosmetics, the improved per-mile efficiency, etc, etc.) And yes, GM is in the same situation as Tesla, having the federal EV credit phased out. And that's a major shame. GM, with the Volt in particular, was a major pioneer in modern electric cars, along with Tesla. And now both are being almost punished for their foresight and initiative. Shows how very little the Congress/Administration/federal government currently values emissions reductions or even rational industrial policy... China very likely may end up owning the EV market.
- newsoul2019 8y ago>> no access to a consistent, strategically placed network of well-maintained chargers spanning the continent. Isn't that called "Chargepoint"?
- Robotbeat 8y agoNot in my experience, no. I own two electric cars (a gen 1 Leaf with DC fast charge and a gen 1 Volt).
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThe Chargepoint network is woefully inadequate (both locations and charge speed, anything capable of less than 120kw-150kw might as well be a 120V outlet) compared to Tesla's Supercharger network. Electrify America's network is still in its infancy (and you can't charge a Tesla on it yet until CCS adapters are available). I travel cross country in the US frequently on the Supercharger network (Model S), without any range anxiety or fear of getting to an inoperable station late at night with little battery range left. Many hotels also have destination chargers, so I can charge overnight at the hotel while I sleep and leave with a full charge. I could not do this with any other EV.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kozak 8y agoAnd that's at the time when people in Europe want to buy the Bolt for a much, much higher price, and cannot.
- Pxtl 8y agoWait, locally discounted? Is that still how this works? Seriously, are cars still being sold where the price varies in those crazy ways? Because those things are sold for over $33,000 USD in Canada ($44,800 CAD). A quick check on car search shows dealers in Canada pricing the thing at $47,000 CAD ($35,000 USD)
- xnyan 8y agoCar makers and dealers learned a long time ago that consumers have wide access to the invoice price of a car (theoretically this is the price at "cost" which the car dealer pays) and have taken steps to obfuscate this with various fees, kickbacks, sales bonus programs and volume sales agreements such that you can't be sure how much margin is really in a car besides looking at the range of actual sales rates of the car. This is the norm and always has been as far as I am aware. If you are buying a Toyota Camry or Honda Accord or other popular, value oriented (lower margin) car then there may be less wiggle room in the sticker, but for a car with an MSRP around 40k there's probably a fair amount of room to change the price. Also, a car that never sells makes $0 in revenue. People tend to buy cars with their heart and the cool factor/brand value of a Tesla 3 is orders of magnitude higher than almost anything chevy makes.
- Pxtl 8y agoYes, but electrics don't stay on the lot either way. These cars all get waiting lists when they launch.
- dmode 8y agoI just bought a Model 3 yesterday. This is my second Tesla and I think it is actually better than my S and a whole 30K cheaper. This car cost me 37k after Fed tax credit, but still comes with Nav, premium audio, autopilot, tons of bells and whistles and safety feature. It is a no brainer - it is the best car in the market right now (yeah, I am biased)
- warp_factor 8y agodid you even try the bolt? It would have been 10k less than yours, and based on the review not that far away in term of comfort//performance etc. But I bet you didn't, because you don't really care. you wanted a Tesla because it's a hype car.
- williesleg 8y agoThe Tesla is a computer that has wheels. The bolt is a car that has a battery. Big difference. Detroit doesn't get it.
- warp_factor 8y agoI'm a big believer in electric vehicles, and it really frustrates me that the Bolt is unknown to the general public. This car is a gem. Cheaper than a Tesla M3, and available before. It shows once more that car buying is more about to be in a cult//group than really about the car itself. 90% of the attraction of the Model3 is that people will think you are somehow hype.
- de_watcher 8y agoCan't really get Bolt in EU where EVs actually make a lot of sense.
- hyuuu 8y agoI believe they are called Opel over in EU
- de_watcher 8y agoCan't buy them in France whatever they're called.
- winter_blue 8y ago$18,995 for a all-electric car is an amazing deal. It's got really incredible range (EPA rated 238 miles) for the price point. The other all-electric car at this price point, the VW e-Golf, has a mileage of 125 miles. 238 miles is close to the Tesla Model 3's EPA rated 250 miles. Here's an EPA comparison of the Bolt, Model 3, and Golf: https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=39786&id=41056&id=39871 https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/Find.do?action=sbs&id=39786&...