3 ms·
Walls throughout history have overwhelmingly been fools errands. It's hard to maintain an exhaustive wall. They can work in the short term (the battle of sadr c
by vorpalhex 8y ago
Walls throughout history have overwhelmingly been fools errands. It's hard to maintain an exhaustive wall. They can work in the short term (the battle of sadr city) but they never hold out in the long term.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoHadrian's Wall protected the Roman frontier in Britain for centuries. Without the Walls of Constantinople, the Eastern Roman Empire would have fallen in the 700's instead of lasting until the 1400's. The Great Wall of China helped protect northern Chinese frontiers for centuries. Are walls 100% effective. Of course not. Nothing is. But walls can be a useful part of a strategy for regulating/protecting your borders. That is not to say that a wall along the Mexican border is advised. It is a very long border, and individuals and groups of smugglers are able to get around an unguarded wall. However, to absolutely dismiss the utility of walls on principle is incorrect.
- 8note 8y agois it still the 1400s? how frequent did planes land in Britannia from the picts? more recently, how'd the Maginot line go? what makes defence against warring enemies similar to preventing immigrants?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoIn regard to planes, planes in general are a lot more expensive, fewer, and thus easier to track than are people on foot. Regarding the Maginot line, it actually forced the Germans to use the Ardennes. This was a high risk move for the Germans and if the French had been doing what they were supposed to be doing, they could have destroyed the German Army in the Ardennes. So, the Maginot line actually was useful, but the French failed to exploit what it was doing for them.
- vorpalhex 8y agoI was actually thinking about Hadrian's wall when I wrote the above! The building of the wall was a super expensive task for the time, and it usurped a ton of manpower (they also had the advantage of using slaves for a lot of it, and it still was expensive). Plus once Hadrian's wall was no longer well manned (once Hadrian died), it became a haven for the picts to launch their raids from and a border through which they couldn't be chased.
- jschwartzi 8y agoWalls are an effective strategy to control where the battle happens rather than an attempt to keep the battle from happening at all. The point of the wall isn't to stop people from crossing the border. It's to slow them down enough to make the CBP response time smaller than the crossing time. Beyond the political aspects of this there are actually some thoughtful reasonable arguments for it. The people in CBP who want to build this thing know that people will break sections of it, but they can't break the entire thing down. So it concentrates the border crossings into smaller areas. The intent wasn't to build it and then not defend it.
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoOK. I'm 100% with you on this reasoning. I'd like to ask if the cost is worth it. I've seen speculation with 'build the wall' that it would be enormously expensive to build and then even more expensive to man and maintain. I've also seen speculation that migrants are actually good for USA (benefits the reduced birth rate, bigger tax base, migrant work willing to do labor americans wont do, the potential for children born to benefit the economy)...
- Consultant32452 8y agoA wall is less expensive to maintain than putting more people there. Increasing the pool of unskilled labor is good for some parts of the economy. It's great for me because I'm wealthy. It's bad for the American poor because it depresses their wages and aids in fighting against unions.
- SolaceQuantum 8y ago> A wall is less expensive to maintain than putting more people there. Is this actually true, given that walls must also be manned, regularly maintained, repaired, etc? > It's bad for the American poor because it depresses their wages and aids in fighting against unions. Is this actually true? I'm really not educated myself on the matter. Do you have sources, studies, etc?