4 ms·
> So what might happen if California enacted statewide rent control? Capping yearly rent increases at inflation + 3%? No-one would move, ever. People wouldn't
by lmm 8y ago
> So what might happen if California enacted statewide rent control? Capping yearly rent increases at inflation + 3%?
No-one would move, ever. People wouldn't be able to change jobs even for much higher salaries or better conditions. Children would live with their parents forever. Many people would live precariously in illegal sublets with inadequate fire exits etc. Developers would stop building. Landlords would stop doing maintenance and let their buildings rot. Everyone would be miserable.
> Many low income renters are paying 50% or more of their income on rent, that's not sustainable for the wider economy that relies on low skill labor to function, and the solution is not to have people commute 4h every day to clean an office, teach a class, or fight a fire.
Rent control creates longer commutes. To the extent that the economy actually relies on low skill labour, it can pay the actual cost of having that labour where it needs it. In fact by having rent control you artificially depress wages and encourage companies to employ humans in bad jobs rather than finding ways to make things better.
- geezerjay 8y ago> No-one would move, ever. I feel like this post should feature at the top of any discussion on housing.
- lexs 8y ago> No-one would move, ever. People wouldn't be able to change jobs even for much higher salaries or better conditions. Children would live with their parents forever. Many people would live precariously in illegal sublets with inadequate fire exits etc. Why?
- lmm 8y agoBecause anyone who's been living in the same place for a while is paying well below-market (by design, otherwise there'd be no point in the rent control). Actually it's worse than that: the market rate rises much faster because landlords have less upside so there's little reason to build, and existing buildings can make more money as offices rather than residential. And when there's a huge gap between what a new tenant would have to pay and what the current tenant pays, that creates a huge incentive to do illegal sublets, and if your sublet is already illegal then why bother spending money complying with fire regulations or any other safety regulations?
- djd20 8y agoThis depends how you implement rent control. The UAE market has rent controls - the landlord is only allowed to adjust rents within a % and if the rental index of the area is more than 10-15% higher than what you are currently paying. They are also building plenty of new housing to help keep rents stable. This second part is key - and needs to be there for this to work. Your comments assume a rental market that is not increasing in supply.
- lmm 8y agoI'm assuming a rental market that isn't increasing in supply because that's the case that rent control is designed to address. If you're building enough supply to keep market-level rents low then rent control becomes irrelevant.
- Beldin 8y agoWait: the regulation would not apply to new rentals? Yeah, that creates obvious problems. If the policy were to apply to all leases, new as well as existing ones, would the problem be somewhat mitigated? (That's basically how things work here for student housing. Far from perfect, but more sane than housing in the Valley)
- benj111 8y agoSurely the devil us in the detail? inflation + 3% is an investment that I'd make. I don't think you could just set the cap and say job done, there's enough money there to ensure everyone benefits though.
- kmonsen 8y agoThat is not how rent-control works in some places. For example here in Zurich Switzerland you cannot raise rents more than x% even when changing tenants, which means that moving is fine as all places are rent controlled together.
- njepa 8y agoIt is essentially never how it works. Why would you actively regulate something so people can't move? It is when you abandon rent control that the systems become incompatible and people can't move.
- i_am_proteus 8y agoIt's not "so people can't move," inflexibility is a side effect of rent control. The "I can't move because I'm locked into a rent-stabilized lease" phenomenon is real, painfully so in NYC. It's also a problem that's essentially invisible to anyone who bought into the market at a good price, or is wealthy enough to pay market-rate rents. But for the rest of us, it hurts.
- njepa 8y agoAs far as I can tell that is exactly because they abandoned rent stabilization making that market incompatible as it now only applies to certain units and triggers rent increases when you move.
- pcwalton 8y agoInflation + 3% isn't that bad, though you're right that it's too low. There's a bill in committee right now to enact statewide CPI + 5% rent control, and the landlord lobby is not too upset, because inflation + 5% is really quite a large year-over-year amount. I think I read that inflation + 5% has basically never happened in California's history: times in which housing prices were rapidly rising were also times in which CPI was rising, so the allowable increase would have been high. The really problematic rent control is in San Francisco, where rent increases are capped at 60% of CPI (well below inflation). This results in massive giveaways to the rich that grow every year.