2 ms·
To quibble with the headline: not so I'd notice, and I think I know my own situation better than some random writer on the Internet. Appealing to people's self
by skybrian 8y ago
To quibble with the headline: not so I'd notice, and I think I know my own situation better than some random writer on the Internet.
Appealing to people's self-interest doesn't seem like a great argument. How about talking about how it hurts other people that we want to support?
- jsloss 8y agoThere is no shortage of examples of how powerful platforms and governments are using this technology in a way that reduces personal freedom. Surveillance is the name of the game in our current era of internet business models. Are you suggesting that this isn't the case?
- trevyn 8y agoEven if the overall trend is to reduce many human freedoms in the aggregate, there are always individual humans who are outliers and can use technologies and policies in ways other than as “designed” — and I’m sure this forum has many of these individuals as members. In the specific case of the Internet, the broad and rapid access to raw information can be very powerful if you are able to suitably filter, sort, and use that information to increase the freedoms that are meaningful to you. (And, of course, the term “freedom” is extremely overloaded today — it may help to be very clear and precise about one’s usage.)
- skybrian 8y agoTo put it another way, it's odd that the "you" in the headline promises to talk about the average reader's situation but then they talk about what's happening in China.
- iamnothere 8y agoChina and Russia are given as worst case examples. Halfway through the article: "Observed in isolation, the authoritarian measures taken in China and Russia don’t immediately indicate an existential risk to freedom elsewhere." The author gradually redirects their attention to Western nations.
- iamnothere 8y ago> Appealing to people's self-interest doesn't seem like a great argument. I think it depends on the person, and how they themselves have been affected. Likely the author is trying to reach people who have personally felt the downsides of global interconnectedness. I thought this was an interesting take, because by most metrics the Internet is unquestionably a success. Goods are cheaper, information is more widely available, long-distance communication is easier and can be more secure, commerce is easier, and so on. But ever since the mid-2000s I've begun to feel the tightening of the noose in terms of freedom. I used to think it was a brief phenomenon, pushback from a stodgy establishment that didn't understand the future. I'm beginning to think that it may be a feature of the technology, especially with the continued centralization of the Internet.